A Survey of In-Network Storage Systems
Summary: Needs a YES.
Note: This ballot was opened for revision 04 and is now closed.
( Wesley Eddy ) (was Discuss) Yes
( David Harrington ) Yes
Jari Arkko No Objection
( Ron Bonica ) No Objection
( Stewart Bryant ) No Objection
( Gonzalo Camarillo ) No Objection
Comment (2011-08-08 for -)
The draft references the DECADE problem statement draft for further discussions on use cases. Additionally, it might be useful to provide a brief description (e.g., a one liner) of the prototypical use case for DECADE. For example the problem statement draft provides this example: "As a simple example, a peer of a P2P application may upload to other peers through its in-network storage, saving its usage of last-mile uplink bandwidth." In the section on Amazon S3, an additional example of a third-party service (which is very popular nowadays) that uses it would be dropbox.
( Ralph Droms ) No Objection
Comment (2011-08-09 for -)
Minor editorial suggestions. In section 4.5.2: The content provider can access network edge servers and store content on them. Or edge servers can retrieve content from content providers. Combine these two sentences into one with a comma. In section 4.7: A key aspect of NDN is that router have the capability s/router/routers/
( Adrian Farrel ) No Objection
Comment (2011-08-06 for -)
Stephen Farrell No Objection
( Russ Housley ) No Objection
Comment (2011-08-10 for -)
Please consider the comments from the Gen-ART Review by Kathleen Moriarty on 18-July-2011. The review can be found here: http://www.ietf.org/mail-archive/web/gen-art/current/msg06526.html