SIP Recording
charter-ietf-siprec-02

Added charter milestone "Protocol and metadata for using RTP media to record the sharing of applications, documents and screens to the IESG as Proposed Standard RFC", due February 2015

[Ballot comment]
I though it was a new WG. So much for me: I should be paying more attention to SIP related WGs :-)

Two small points:
- expand MSRP
- formatting issue in the first paragraph

[Ballot comment]

Thanks for the notes about privacy and security and the ref to 2804.

I think I would suggest (but not block on) two additions:

- Perhaps say that security for recordings needs to be commensurate
with the security for the underlying calls - there's a problem if e.g.
one has setup DTLS-SRTP for calls, but recordings have to (not can)
be left lying about in clear.

- Consider adding a ref to our shiny new RFC7258 as well as
2804 - I don' t think that ought be difficult for the enterprise cases
that I assume are the meat of the work here, but it might help
in e.g. crafting applicability statement text later if that's in the
charter.

[Ballot comment]
I found it was a new WG. So much for me: I should be paying more attention to SIP related WGs :-)

Two small points:
- expand MSRP
- formatting issue in the first paragraph

[Ballot comment]
Like Joel, I'm not clear on the reason for the charter change (note to self as tools liaison: there should be a place for the AD to add a comment to explain such things), but I agree that either way no external review required.

This is a very minor clarification of one sentence in the charter.

OLD:
The working group will determine requirements and produce a
specification for a protocol that will manage delivery of media from an
end-point that originates media, or that has access to it, to a
recording device.

NEW:
The working group will determine requirements and produce a
specification for a protocol that will manage delivery of media
(including audio, video, MSRP instant message sessions, and real-time
text), in SIP-based systems from an end-point that originates media, or
that has access to it, to a recording device.