Skip to main content

Requirements for Discovering Designated Resolvers
draft-box-add-requirements-02

Revision differences

Document history

Date Rev. By Action
2021-03-01
02 Glenn Deen Tag Polled for WG adoption but not adopted cleared.
2021-03-01
02 Glenn Deen IETF WG state changed to Adopted for WG Info Only from WG Document
2021-02-22
02 Glenn Deen
The chairs have reviewed the ADD list discussion and have concluded that there is not consensus for adoption of draft-box-add-requirements.

The comments received showed a …
The chairs have reviewed the ADD list discussion and have concluded that there is not consensus for adoption of draft-box-add-requirements.

The comments received showed a split in the group's view on adoption.  While there were many who supported adoption, there were also many who recognized the value of the document but did not support adoption since the document itself was not intended to be published, and that the documents input had already served its purpose of triggering much needed discussion.

The chairs want to sincerely thank the document authors and contributors, this document has significantly contributed to the ADD group's thinking and discussions during IETF meetings and numerous ADD Interim meetings.

It's safe to say that without this document the ADD group would not be as far along as it is with 2 discovery method documents already adopted.  The ideas in the document and the discussion they triggered helped ADD move forward during a time when many directions and many potential road-blocks where swirling about in discussions.    ADD's future success owes a lot to this very important contribution.

Looking to the future, if there are new requirements not yet captured by this draft the authors are encourage to submit updated revisions to the group, and likewise if others have thoughts for the group to consider they should either work with the current draft authors on a revision, or consider submitting a new document capturing their thoughts.
2021-02-22
02 Glenn Deen Tag Polled for WG adoption but not adopted set.
2021-02-22
02 Glenn Deen IETF WG state changed to WG Document from Call For Adoption By WG Issued
2021-01-27
02 Glenn Deen
Based on list and discussion during the January 27th ADD Interim this document is being put up for call for WG Adoption.

WG Call for …
Based on list and discussion during the January 27th ADD Interim this document is being put up for call for WG Adoption.

WG Call for adoption is open until February 10th, 2021
2021-01-27
02 Glenn Deen IETF WG state changed to Call For Adoption By WG Issued
2021-01-27
02 Glenn Deen Notification list changed to none
2021-01-27
02 Glenn Deen Changed group to Adaptive DNS Discovery (ADD)
2021-01-27
02 Glenn Deen Changed stream to IETF
2021-01-24
02 Chris Box New version available: draft-box-add-requirements-02.txt
2021-01-24
02 (System) New version accepted (logged-in submitter: Chris Box)
2021-01-24
02 Chris Box Uploaded new revision
2021-01-14
01 Glenn Deen Changed stream to None from IETF
2021-01-14
01 Glenn Deen State changed to None from Call For Adoption By WG Issued
2021-01-14
01 Glenn Deen Call issued to ADD list on Jan 14, 2021 until January 26, 2021
2021-01-14
01 Glenn Deen IETF WG state changed to Call For Adoption By WG Issued
2021-01-14
01 Glenn Deen Notification list changed to none
2021-01-14
01 Glenn Deen Changed group to Adaptive DNS Discovery (ADD)
2021-01-14
01 Glenn Deen Changed stream to IETF
2020-11-02
01 Chris Box New version available: draft-box-add-requirements-01.txt
2020-11-02
01 (System) New version accepted (logged-in submitter: Chris Box)
2020-11-02
01 Chris Box Uploaded new revision
2020-09-10
00 Glenn Deen Added to session: interim-2020-add-01
2020-09-04
00 Cindy Morgan This document now replaces draft-pauly-add-requirements instead of None
2020-09-04
00 Cindy Morgan Reviewed suggested replacement relationships: draft-pauly-add-requirements
2020-09-04
00 (System) Added suggested replacement relationships: draft-pauly-add-requirements
2020-09-04
00 (System) This document now replaces None instead of None
2020-09-04
00 Chris Box New version available: draft-box-add-requirements-00.txt
2020-09-04
00 (System) New version approved
2020-09-04
00 Chris Box Request for posting confirmation emailed  to submitter and authors: Christopher Wood , Chris Box , "Tirumaleswar Reddy.K" , Tommy Pauly
2020-09-04
00 Chris Box Uploaded new revision