Yes

Carsten Bormann

No Objection

Ari Keränen
Colin Perkins
David Oran

No Record

Aaron Falk
Alexey Melnikov
Allison Mankin
Alvaro Retana
Brian Trammell
Dave Plonka
Dirk KUTSCHER
Eve Schooler
Ignacio Castro
Jana Iyengar
Jane Coffin
Jen Linkova
Jianfei(Jeffrey) HE
Jonathan Hoyland
Jérôme François
Kurtis Heimerl
Lars Eggert
Laurent Ciavaglia
Lixia Zhang
Mallory Knodel
Marie-Jose Montpetit
Mat Ford
Melinda Shore
Mirja Kühlewind
Nick Sullivan
Reese Enghardt
Rodney Van Meter
Sara Dickinson
Shivan Sahib
Simone Ferlin
Sofia Celi
Spencer Dawkins
Stanislav Smyshlyaev
Stephen Farrell
Vidhi Goel
Wojciech Kozlowski

Summary: Needs one more YES position to pass.

Ballot question: "Is this draft ready for publication in the IRTF stream?"

Carsten Bormann
Yes
Comment (2024-09-26) Not sent 
I didn't check Appendix A.

## Nits

2: interoperability keywords are not used in this document.  This
section can be deleted.  (It uses incorrect boilerplate as well.)

5: "id is the IANA-defined identifier used to denote this specific
parameter set, and which appears in both public keys and signatures."

(spurious "and")

9: "that attack allows the attacker can compute the hash of the
message"

Sentence.

9: "(because he can compute that anyways)."

Please avoid gendered pronoun.
Ari Keränen
No Objection
Colin Perkins
No Objection
David Oran
No Objection
Aaron Falk
No Record
Alexey Melnikov
No Record
Allison Mankin
No Record
Alvaro Retana
No Record
Brian Trammell
No Record
Dave Plonka
No Record
Dirk KUTSCHER
No Record
Eve Schooler
No Record
Ignacio Castro
No Record
Jana Iyengar
No Record
Jane Coffin
No Record
Jen Linkova
No Record
Jianfei(Jeffrey) HE
No Record
Jonathan Hoyland
No Record
Jérôme François
No Record
Kurtis Heimerl
No Record
Lars Eggert
No Record
Laurent Ciavaglia
No Record
Lixia Zhang
No Record
Mallory Knodel
No Record
Marie-Jose Montpetit
No Record
Mat Ford
No Record
Melinda Shore
No Record
Mirja Kühlewind
No Record
Nick Sullivan
No Record
Reese Enghardt
No Record
Rodney Van Meter
No Record
Sara Dickinson
No Record
Shivan Sahib
No Record
Simone Ferlin
No Record
Sofia Celi
No Record
Spencer Dawkins
No Record
Stanislav Smyshlyaev
No Record
Stephen Farrell
No Record
Vidhi Goel
No Record
Wojciech Kozlowski
No Record