The IETF Administrative Oversight Committee (IAOC) Member Selection Guidelines and Process
draft-iab-iesg-iaoc-selection-03

[Ballot comment]
I've never understood why this is a BCP.  Why do we believe we want to
require community consensus to change our selection process?  I don't
actually have a problem doing so, I'm just confused.

[Ballot discuss]
>  The IAB and IESG expect to seat their selected committee member at
>  the first IETF meeting of every second year, for a two year term of
>  office.

>  Also
>  for the first year the IESG-selected candidate will serve on the
>  committee for an initial term ending with the first IETF meeting of
>  the following year,

I think we should be precise as to whether this is the beginning, end, or some other time of the meeting itself.

> o  2 - 3 weeks for solicitation of nominations.

I'm a little concerned about this time-frame. People go on vacations. Is it too burdensome to extend this a bit?

>  If the selecting body does not
>  invoke the interim process, the next biannual selection process will
>  fill the vacancy.

>  If the selecting body elects to fill the mid-term vacancy before the
>  next biannual selection, a

"biannual" means "occurring twice a year" is this the intended meaning?

[Ballot comment]
Edits suggested by Leslie Daigle:

Change title to:
  IAOC member selection guidelines and process

Change 4th paragraph of section 2 to:

  The candidates will also be expected to exercise all the duties of an
  IAOC member, including being prepared to undertake any associated
  responsibilities.  These include, but are not limited to,  the
  setting of administrative support policies, oversight of the
  administrative operations of the IETF, and representing the interests
  of the IETF to the IAOC.  The candidates must be able to undertake
  full participation in all Committee meetings and Committee
  activities.

[Ballot comment]
Edits suggested by Leslie Daigle:

Change title to:
  Process for the IAB and IESG selection of IAOC members

Change 4th paragraph of section 2 to:

  The candidates will also be expected to exercise all the duties of an
  IAOC member, including being prepared to undertake any associated
  responsibilities.  These include, but are not limited to,  the
  setting of administrative support policies, oversight of the
  administrative operations of the IETF, and representing the interests
  of the IETF to the IAOC.  The candidates must be able to undertake
  full participation in all Committee meetings and Committee
  activities.