Shepherd writeup
rfc8823-14

Summary
This is the shepherd write-up for draft-ietf-acme-email-smime.
 
The shepherd is Rich Salz, who has been WG co-chair since the initial BoF. Roman is the responsible AD. The WG is moving this forward as a informational because, while there are many individual certificate enrollment procedures, none use ACME for email and we are interested in seeking this taken up; this addresses a gap. Quoting the abstract, “This document specifies identifiers and challenges required to enable the Automated Certificate Management Environment (ACME) to issue certificates for use by email users that want to use S/MIME.”
 
Review and Consensus
The document was first adopted by the WG in June 2017. It has been discussed in-person at several IETF’s, and there has been light email discussion in the 2.75 years since. There was never any discussion about not moving this work forward. During the meetings, and on the email list, several technical issuers were discussed, probably around a dozen WG participants total. Some of the discussions included “Should this just use HTML” and the interaction/dependency on DKIM header protection. Discussion was low-key and productive and resolving issues was non-controversial. Some participants were highly involved in email/applications area.
 
intellectual Property
No disclosures, no IP concerns. Confirmed by the author.
 
Other points
There are no downref’s.  There are no nits. There are some IANA registry actions, which are called out in the draft and straightforward.
 
There is detailed discussion of email headers; a close ART review would be helpful.
 
Back