GMPLS Signaling Extensions for Control of Evolving G.709 Optical Transport Networks
draft-ietf-ccamp-gmpls-signaling-g709v3-12
Yes
No Objection
(Brian Haberman)
(Gonzalo Camarillo)
(Jari Arkko)
(Joel Jaeggli)
(Martin Stiemerling)
(Pete Resnick)
(Sean Turner)
(Spencer Dawkins)
(Stephen Farrell)
(Stewart Bryant)
Note: This ballot was opened for revision 12 and is now closed.
Adrian Farrel Former IESG member
(was Discuss, Yes)
Yes
Yes
(2013-09-25)
Unknown
IANA issues addressed in email and RFC Editor note
Barry Leiba Former IESG member
No Objection
No Objection
(2013-09-25)
Unknown
Just two minor, non-blocking things related to the use of "REQUIRED" as a 2119 key word along with the modifier "not":
-- Section 6.2 --
- In case of ODUk to OTUk mapping, TPN field MUST be set to 0. Bit
Map information is not REQUIRED and MUST NOT be included, so
Length field MUST be set to 0 as well.
The "REQUIRED" there should not be a 2119 key word, and should be made lower case. Otherwise, there's a conflict with the MUST NOT. And see below.
-- Section 9 --
o A node supporting both sets of procedures (i.e., [RFC4328] and
this document) is not REQUIRED to signal an LSP using both
procedures, i.e., to act as a signaling version translator.
Similar to the above. The problem is that "REQUIRED" means "MUST", but "not REQUIRED" does not mean "MUST NOT". It's best to avoid "not REQUIRED" with a 2119 meaning. The easiest fix is just to make "required" lower case (or another way to say "is not required" is "need not"). And I can't really think of a good way to say what you want to say in 2119-ese, nor why you'd have to.
Brian Haberman Former IESG member
No Objection
No Objection
()
Unknown
Gonzalo Camarillo Former IESG member
No Objection
No Objection
()
Unknown
Jari Arkko Former IESG member
No Objection
No Objection
()
Unknown
Joel Jaeggli Former IESG member
No Objection
No Objection
()
Unknown
Martin Stiemerling Former IESG member
No Objection
No Objection
()
Unknown
Pete Resnick Former IESG member
No Objection
No Objection
()
Unknown
Sean Turner Former IESG member
No Objection
No Objection
()
Unknown
Spencer Dawkins Former IESG member
No Objection
No Objection
()
Unknown
Stephen Farrell Former IESG member
No Objection
No Objection
()
Unknown
Stewart Bryant Former IESG member
No Objection
No Objection
()
Unknown