Technical Summary
The draft describes L2VPN requirements for a Metro Ethernet Forum
services, known as the E-Tree services. An E-Tree services is
defined by a one or more roots and one or more leaves. Roots
can send traffic to other roots and leaves and received traffic from
other roots and leaves. Leaves can only receive traffic from roots
and send traffic to roots. E-Tree requirements are not satisfied by
existing L2VPN solution.
Working Group Summary
This document is an L2VPN Working Group document. It has gone
through a few iterations that addressed few comments received from
the Working group and comments received the WG chairs. The draft
was generalized from VPLS to L2VPN to allow for a potentially wider
solution set, namely including E-VPN. The draft also has a substantial
number of authors and contributors from the Working Group. The draft
had good support when it was adopted as a WG draft. However when
the draft was last called, no feedback was received, maybe due to the
nature of the draft and the fact that there are several authors and
contributors to the draft already from the WG. Upon last review by
the WG chairs of the draft and feedback to the authors, the authors
updated the draft addressing the chairs' comments, mainly modifying
the author list and moving some to contributors, performing few edits,
and removing the appendix on use cases as it did not include
requirements. The use cases are part of another framework draft.
Document Quality
The document has good quality. It is clear on the technical content
and written with good English and layout. There may be an edit
or so needed that may be taken up during the RFC edits.
Personnel
Nabil Bitar (nabil.n.bitar@verizon.com) is the Document Shepherd.
Stewart Bryant (stbryant@cisco.com is the Responsible Area Director.
RFC Editor Note
OLD
Appendix A. Frequently Asked Questions
NEW
Appendix A. A Frequently Asked Question
END
Please remove section 8
The following seem not to have been expanded on first use:
L2VPN - Layer 2 Virtual Private Network (L2VPN)
E-VPN - Ethernet VPN
PW - pseudowire
CE - Customer Edge (CE)
VPMS - Virtual Private Multicast Service
P2MP - Point-to-Multipoint