Shepherd writeup

{ re-wrapped. /pr }

> == Document Writeup ==

I've separately posted a review of the document.

> === 1. Summary ===
> Who is the document shepherd?

  D. Crocker

> Who is the responsible Area Director?

  P. Resnick

> Explain briefly what the intent of the document is (the document's
> abstract is usually good for this), and why the working group has
> chosen the requested publication type (BCP, Proposed Standard,
> Internet Standard, Informational, Experimental, or Historic).

     Once there is a validated identifier associated with an object or
activity, it is possible to develop and communicate its behavioral
"reputation".  The current draft is part of an effort to define a
reputation query/report mechanism. This draft specifically defines the
response syntax and format and the media-type for packaging it.

> === 2. Review and Consensus ===
> Explain how actively the document was reviewed and discussed, by the
> working group and external parties, and explain in a general sense
> how much of the interested community is behind the document.  Explain
> anything notable about the discussion of the document.

   The document has gone through multiple drafts, over a period of time,
that were discussed in the working group. Discussion was mild and
supportive, with no significant controversy. The working group 'style'
was mostly of a small, collaborative set of active participants.

   The specified protocol is reasonable simple and flexible, tailored to
the semantics of requesting reputation-related attributes about a

> === 3. Intellectual Property ===
> Confirm that each author has stated that their direct, personal
> knowledge of any IPR related to this document has already been
> disclosed, in conformance with BCPs 78 and 79.  Explain briefly the
> working group discussion about any IPR disclosures regarding this
> document, and summarize the outcome.

   The author is highly experienced with IETF work and the document IPR
standard is the default.  No IPR concerns are anticipated.

> === 4. Other Points ===

   None noted.