Shepherd writeup entered on 03-05-2024:
- Individual draft was adopted as RG document on 02-07-2024
- The draft received a support from 13 participants who particularly
acknowledge the importance of the topic, its adequacy with NMRG and
the quality of the draft serving as a good basis for future evolution.
- Draft already considered very mature based on comments received
- Document was revised according to comments received (mainly by detailing some
of the proposed challenges and including more discussion about IoT)
- New versions presented in
- NMRG (IETF 117 and IETF 118)
- in e-impact interim meeting on 15-02-2024 (in Map/survey of e-impact
drafts) - Positive feedback
- RG last call initiated on 20-12-2023, concluded on 19-01-2024
- No objection received.
- Last call also shared on the e-impact mailing list: one comment
received highlighting that the "energy" goal is well covered in the
draft even though the introduction was considered too simplistic in
regard to that problem.
- Update on 03-03-2025
- IETF-conflict review: the IESG has concluded that publication could
potentially disrupt the IETF work done in WG GREEN and recommends not
publishing the document at this time." - The authors revised the draft
to address received comments, in particular they removed any statement
that might have been construed as providing IETF direction - New
version sent to IRSG review