This document originally lived in draft-gont-predictable-protocol-ids along
with draft-irtf-pearg-numeric-ids-history and
draft-gont-numeric-ids-sec-considerations and was later on broken up into 3
separate drafts. This particular document concerns itself with analyzing the
security and privacy aspects of numeric identifiers used by various IETF
protocols and provides guidance on writing algorithms that generate transient
In general this document is well-written and comprehensive. It went through
review in its previous incarnation and the PEARG chairs asked for an early
TSVART review that raised comments that the authors addressed in subsequent
revisions. No additional comments were received in the PEARG Last Call.
The chairs consider this document ready to proceed to IRSG last call.