Minutes IETF101: icnrg
minutes-101-icnrg-00

Find material on the wiki: https://trac.ietf.org/trac/irtf/wiki/icnrg
Note taker: M.J. Montpetit

        •       Welcome, Agenda Bashing, Minutes taker, Blue sheets, Status -
        Chairs (10 min) ◦       Administrivia ◦       Progress report on
        current, finalized and new work ◦ •       Report from the interim
        meeting on Sunday - Chairs (10 min) ◦       See notes and presentations
        on the wiki ◦       Summary of the presentations including the live
        demo ◦ •       TODAY’s Presentations

        •       New draft defining the IPoC (IP over CCN) protocol: "Internet
        Protocol Tunneling over Content Centric Mobile Networks" :
        https://datatracker.ietf.org/doc/draft-white-icnrg-ipoc/ - Greg White
        (20 min) ◦       Q&A: ◦       Oran: Will you address congestion control
        and how to avoid silly windows effects in TCP ◦       Greg: Yes, in
        later slides. if you have more questions, ask then ◦       Thomas:
        Reference to Stanford NDN - can you make the addressing simpler because
        of the nesting of addresses IP/ICN ◦       Greg: support applications
        that are not aware of ICN ◦       Thomas: how about aggregation ◦      
        Greg: system supports unicast only, each client sends unique interests;
        interest aggregation is only important during handovers ◦       Cedric:
        Hard vs. soft handover? Buffering etc. ◦       Greg: Resending the
        interest from the PIT either after radio link break/make or via a new
        link in make/break ◦       Cedric: Scalability of solution? ◦      
        Greg: Network can have many Gateways, each supporting an IP subnet of
        some size (could be small or large) ◦       Alan: PIT time-out/ refresh
        time for the PIT entries? Is the protocol excessively chatty during
        idle periods? ◦       Greg: no real consensus on the refresh of PIT
        seconds; 300ms in experiments. We currently use min_CIT=10, so minimum
        10 pkts per PIT refresh time. ◦       Alan: IP fragmentation? ◦      
        Greg: We don’t support IP fragmentation; MTU for IPOC is sufficient

        •       Breaking out of the Cloud: Local Trust Management and
        Rendezvous in Named Data Networking of Things? - Lixia Zhang (20 min) -
        how get a better IOT that uses less layering than the current cloud
        implementation less prone to failures and easier to use with NDN (no
        time for questions)

        •       Deployment of ICN stacks and NDN in particular by leveraging
        NFV - Guillaume Doyen (20 min) (no time for questions)

        •       Revised draft: "ICN Adaptation to LowPAN Networks (ICN LoWPAN)"
        : https://datatracker.ietf.org/doc/draft-gundogan-icnrg-ccnlowpan/ -
        Cenk Gündoğan (15 min) ◦       Q&A: no time for questions ◦      
        Comment from Dirk: Good work!

        •       Revised drafts: "CNx Messages in TLV Format" :
        https://datatracker.ietf.org/doc/draft-irtf-icnrg-ccnxmessages/ & "CCNx
        Semantics" :
        https://datatracker.ietf.org/doc/draft-irtf-icnrg-ccnxsemantics/ - Marc
        Mosko (10 min) (remotely) ◦       Q&A: no time for questions

        •       Revised draft : "Enabling ICN in 3GPP's 5G NextGen Core
        Architecture" :
        https://datatracker.ietf.org/doc/draft-ravi-icnrg-5gc-icn/ - Ravi
        Ravindran (10 min) - An INC architecture embedded in 5G - ran out of
        time - last slides not presented. ◦       Q&A: no time for questions ◦
        ◦       New draft: "Consideration on Applying ICN to Edge Computing" :
        https://datatracker.ietf.org/doc/draft-wang-icnrg-icn-edge/- Lei Wang
        (15 min) Combining EC and ICN and show how it helps both. ◦       Q&A:
        ◦       Dirk: a quick reaction from the people doing edge and ICN? ◦   
           Eve: Yes! ◦       Luca: What are the definitions on ICN and edge in
        the draft? ◦       Lei: Edge can be wifi can be anything. ◦       Luca:
        But for ICN is it CCNx, NDN, other? ◦       Lei: Broad for now next
        steps will be more detailed

        •       Revised draft: "Native Deployment of ICN in LTE, 4G Mobile
        Networks" :
        https://datatracker.ietf.org/doc/draft-irtf-icnrg-icn-lte-4g/ - Milan
        Stolic (10 min) Lab trials in next steps. ◦       Q&A: ◦       Eve:
        which Lab? ◦       Milan: Cisco ◦       Dirk: good to see it’s
        progressing and going to lab

        •       Wrap up - Chairs (10 min)
        ◦       Upcoming ICN events
        ▪       RIOT Summint Sept. 13-14 2018
        ▪       NDN Community Meeting Sept. 19
        ▪       Interim at ACM-ICN on 24 Sept 2018 (Conference is 21-23
        September) in Boston ▪       Future ICNRG meetings ▪       ICNRG @
        IETF102, Montreal ▪       Sunday Interim ▪       Regular
Meeting Ends 18:25