Minutes IETF106: babel
minutes-106-babel-01

Babel at IETF 106
Raffles City Convention Center, Singapore
         13:30-15:00 VIP A Room
Tuesday, 19 November 2019


Chair: Donald Eastlake (Futurewei)
Notes: Barbara Stark (AT&T)
Jabber: Martin Vigoureux (Ericsson)
AD: Martin Vigoureux

Agenda
[Times are time scheduled, not time actually taken]
   5 min.  Administrativia (scribes), Agenda Bashing, Chairs
   5 min.  Status, Milestones, Chairs
   5 min.  YANG Data Model for Babel, Mahesh Jethanandani
              draft-ietf-babel-yang-model-02
  10 min.  BIER in BABEL, Zheng (Sandy) Zhang
              draft-zhang-bier-babel-extensions-02
  15 min.  Babel Futures, Donald Eastlake
   5 min.  Wrap-Up, Chairs

Minutes taken by Barbara Stark, edited by Donald Eastlake.

================================
Donald Eastlake presented the chair slides:
https://datatracker.ietf.org/meeting/106/materials/slides-106-babel-agenda-and-status

Donald: Russ White (Juniper), my co-chair, was unable to attend this
meeting. 

Donald: Any changes to the agenda? Additional items or changes? [no
response] 

Donald: There is a WG Last Call, scheduled to end at this meeting, for
the YANG modle draft. Any objections at this meeting or anyone called
in? [there were none] The YANG checker is complaining about the YANG
model draft.

Mahesh: The complaint is a bug in the tool. I'll check and confirm and
send email to list. 
Donald: OK. After we check on that I'll request publication. There
have been no negative comments and a few positive comments. 

=================================
BIER for BABEL
Sandy Zhang presented slides:
https://datatracker.ietf.org/meeting/106/materials/slides-106-babel-bier-for-babel

Martin: If the WG were to work on this, is it in existing charter or
does it require recharter? 
Donald: It would be in existing charter which includes multi-cast as
an optional work item.
    
=================================
Babel Futures
Donald presented slides:
https://datatracker.ietf.org/meeting/106/materials/slides-106-babel-babel-futures

Barbara Stark: I think we should discuss this on the mailing list.
Martin: I'll be happy if Babel continues, if it has work people want
to do and there is energy to take on new work.
Rod: I'm chair of QIRG [Quantum Internet Research Group] and we're
interested in Babel because we're looking at links that aren't
stable.
Barbara: That's great. Suggest you post to the mailing list and might
get more response there.
Ronald in 't Velt: What about the RTT [Round Trip Time extension]
draft? 
Donald: If people think it is in good enough shape, we could do a WG
Last Call on that.
Ronald: I'll review the draft and see.
    
=================================
Donald: Any further topic or comments? [none] OK, see people on the
mailing list and at the next IETF meeting.

Adjourn