Minutes IETF106: dnssd
minutes-106-dnssd-00

IETF 106 DNSSD Minutes
* Singapore
* 2019-11-18 14:30-15:00 (Monday Afternoon session I)
* 2019-11-18 18:10-19:10 (Monday Afternoon session III, dnssd topics only)
* Meeting Room: VIP A

Chairs: David Schinazi, Barbara Stark
AD: Éric Vyncke
Jabber: Tim Wattenberg
Notes: Mal Hubert, Barbara Stark, Tim Wattenberg

============== Agenda ==============

- Administrivia and Status Update: Chairs
  * Blue Sheets
- Service Registration and roadmap (Stuart Cheshire)
  * draft-ietf-dnssd-srp
- Discovery Relay (Stuart Cheshire)
  * draft-ietf-dnssd-mdns-relay
- Rechartering discussions (led by chairs)

===================================================
# Administrivia and Status Update

Chairs presented dnssd Chair slides
https://datatracker.ietf.org/meeting/106/materials/slides-106-dnssd-dnssd-chair-slides

Notetaker and jabber scribe identified. No-one bashed the agenda.

===================================================
# Service Registration, roadmap, discovery relay

Stuart Cheshire presented slides
https://datatracker.ietf.org/meeting/106/materials/slides-106-dnssd-sessa-cheshire-status

## Re: draft-ietf-dnssd-srp
Service Registration Protocol (SRP)  - Thread Group Mesh Networking for low
power wireless nets. Stuart was in Switzerland on a meeting of the Thread Group
to introduce SRP.

Ted Lemon (remote): Regarding SRP: Work has been done over the last months,
some updates needed but getting mature. New version of the spec possibly before
next IETF. Asks for contributions.

## Re: draft-cheshire-dnssd-roadmap
Stuart welcomes contributions from the group. If anyone would like to be a
co-author of the roadmap document, please contact him. Co-author would be much
appreciated.

Daniel Migault: Thank you, good draft; looking forward to next version.

Ted: Started to make comment but thought the comment would be better for
homenet session. Never mind.

## Re: draft-ietf-dnssd-mdns-relay
Stuart : Not a "Ted and Stuart"-show, please feel free to contribute!

## Re: draft-ietf-dnssd-push
Stuart: Is ready to be published. So minor IPR issues which should be solved by
Apple (legal).

No questions

===================================================
# Rechartering discussion

Daniel: If recharter, why not merge with homenet?
David: We wouldn't "take over" homenet.
Daniel: Right, probably rechartering not needed.

Ted: There is quite some work left.

Ray Hunter: What we need is running code.

Tim W: I agree. We need multiple implementations. Also, the current charter is
focused on reducing multicast traffic. But there is still a need for service
discovery in areas where other transport mechanisms may be needed/wanted
(Thread, LoRa, etc).

Stuart: Maybe we could make a plan for the next hackathon for concrete list of
things to work on. David: Stuart, will you create a starter list for the next
hackathon? Stuart: Yes.

===================================================
Privacy related issues will be discussed in the second session later on Monday.

// End of Session 1

============== Agenda Session 2 ==============

- Administrivia (Chairs)
- Privacy topics/drafts (Christian Huitema)
- Conclusion (Chairs)

Still note well.

============================================
Christian Huitema presented:
https://datatracker.ietf.org/meeting/106/materials/slides-106-dnssd-huitema-privacy

David: Who has read this draft? <about 5 hands raised> Could you who have read
it say something about your thoughts on the draft? Tim W: Will send to the
list. David: Let's extend WGLC to end of next week.

David: Anything else?

Daniel Migault: I have a comment regarding scenario 1. You can see IP connected
to printer. Christian: We know the printer is a printer -- that's not a secret.
What you don't want to disclose is who is using the printer. No MAC address or
hostname.

David: We're ready to adjourn. We  hope to see you in Vancouver. Please read
the draft and send email. Even if your email says this is find. Please say so.