Skip to main content

Minutes IETF97: dmm
minutes-97-dmm-00

Meeting Minutes Distributed Mobility Management (dmm) WG
Date and time 2016-11-14 00:30
Title Minutes IETF97: dmm
State Active
Other versions plain text
Last updated 2016-12-10

minutes-97-dmm-00
09:30     Title: Administrivia & Intro
         Presenter: Chairs

Sri: asking about adoption of a draft, did not get the name.

09:40     Title: Enhanced Mobility Anchoring
         Presenter: Anthony Chan
         Draft: .../draft-ietf-dmm-distributed-mobility-anchoring-02
         Slides: .../slides-97-dmm-enhanced-mobility-anchoring-00.pptx
 Jouni: Is the draft ready to move forward?
 Anthony: Have not received comments from the list, so don't know.
 Jouni: Everyone please read the draft and submit comments.

10:00     Title: Use Cases and API Extension for Source IP Address Selection
         Presenter: Seil Jeon
         .../draft-sijeon-dmm-use-cases-api-source-05
.../slides-97-dmm-use-cases-and-api-extension-for-source-ip-address-selection-00.pptx
 Suresh: Why isn't this part of the on-demand-mobility document?
 Seon: The authors did not seem to be interested...
 Suresh: There is not enough material in this document to publish separately
 Jouni: Consensus seems to bring on-demand document back to dmm WG to
   continue work, see whether Seil Jeon's document should be included

10:30     Title: Implementation Status of FPC
         Presenter: Lyle Bertz
         .../draft-ietf-dmm-fpc-cpdp-05
         .../slides-97-dmm-fpcv04-implementation-00.pptx
 Remote presenter Lyle Bertz
 Really looking at feasibility of RESTconf
 Preponderance of delay due to JSON processing!
 Is 8700 TPS enough (1000 TPS can handle 250k users?! [did I hear that right?])

10:40     Title: Overview of draft-ietf-dmm-fpc-cpdp
         Presenter: Marco Liebsh
         .../draft-ietf-dmm-fpc-cpdp-05
.../slides-97-dmm-overview-of-draft-ietf-dmm-fpc-cpdp-00.pptx
 Satoru: No one knows just what a slice actually is...
 Seil: slice enables multiple virtual networks over single network..
 Charlie: asks for many clarifications for picture showing tenancy
 Charlie: asks for many clarifications for picture showing kinds of DPN Agents
 Marco: a lot of different views about implementations
 Jouni: bring further discussion the mailing list
 Jouni: What do the authors intend to do next
 Marco: Need feedback from the WG that the specification is clear


11:00     Title: DHCPv6 Extension for On Demand Mobility exposure
         Presenter: Danny Moses, who made it even in the face of flight delays...
         .../draft-moses-dmm-dhcp-ondemand-mobility-04
.../slides-97-dmm-dhcpv6-extension-for-on-demand-mobility-exposure-00.pptx
 Author describes the few changes since Buenos Aires
 Asks for adoption as WG draft
 Lorenzo: discusses recommending against using DHCP for IA address
 Lorenzo: Never want an address, always should get a prefix
 Danny: Should DHCPv6 be disallowed from allocating a single address?
 Suresh: Lorenzo is suggesting to use IA prefix instead of IA address.
 Jouni asks for the temperature of the room to adopt the document
 Result: several people are in agreement
 Jouni asks for the document to be resubmitted according to comments received