Minutes interim-2018-cbor-04: Wed 15:00

Meeting Minutes Concise Binary Object Representation Maintenance and Extensions (cbor) WG
Title Minutes interim-2018-cbor-04: Wed 15:00
State Active
Other versions plain text
Last updated 2018-09-19

Meeting Minutes

   CBOR WG Conference Call
Wednesday, Sept 19 2018, 15:00 - 16:00 UTC
Chairs: Barry Leiba, Francesca Palombini

Minute takers: Francesca

* Carsten Bormann
* Michael Richardson
* Laurence Lundblade
* Sean
* Jim Schaad
* Henk Birkholz
* Francesca

Carsten presenting updates to documents:

CDDL in Alexey's hands. Will start with open PR on CBORBis, then let's talk
some more about CDDL.

CBOR bis pull requests:
    * #32
- Laurence: proposal sounds reasonable
- Carsten: will make a change to reduce the text. Let's do 28 first and then we
can go back to 32 and fix it.
    * #28
- will go not to the next update because we need an update right now (draft
expired), but for the next one (October 1, after Carsten's vacation)
   * #27
- will go in this week
   * #24
- proposal: fix text for tag 35 but not try to do stronger version
- Michael: makes total sense.
   * #19
-  tried to understand this, but needs details from Jeffrey. Waiting for his
eply, but will probably get in the version uploaded in october
   * #17
- will partly integrate this this week. Needs more input from the wg if we want
to distinguish between "illformed" and "fatally illformed" - Laurence: dont
want to distinguish between those two. Bad idea to "allow" some form of
ill-formed. - Carsten: Jeffrey want to underline that broken is broken

CDDL: received several comments (although in IESG review):

* Representation variants: some parts are not in CBOR (but are in CBORbis)...
might need to add some text. * Map matching is not very well defined. *
.cborseq * additional editorial comments (other comments go to another version)

Francesca: will send an email to Alexey notifying we are improving on editorial
(and his review can be done in parallel)

- Carsten: A while ago the array tag got stuck. Resolution: going to change
into 2 bytes then working group adoption. - Francesca: Yes, the document
already had agreement to be adopted, it was confirmed in the ml as well, it was
just waiting on your update - Carsten: Ok, let's get it adopted this week