IANA Considerations for RADIUS (Remote Authentication Dial In User Service)
RFC 3575
Revision differences
Document history
| Date | Rev. | By | Action |
|---|---|---|---|
|
2020-01-21
|
07 | (System) | Received changes through RFC Editor sync (added Verified Errata tag) |
|
2015-10-14
|
07 | (System) | Notify list changed from <aboba@internaut.com> to (None) |
|
2012-12-04
|
07 | Cindy Morgan | Stream changed to IETF from ISE |
|
2004-02-12
|
07 | (System) | Ballot writeup text was added |
|
2004-02-12
|
07 | (System) | Last call text was added |
|
2004-02-12
|
07 | (System) | Ballot approval text was added |
|
2004-02-12
|
07 | Bert Wijnen | [Note]: 'Published as RFC3575' added by Bert Wijnen |
|
2003-07-31
|
07 | Michael Lee | State Changes to RFC Published from 0 by Michael Lee |
|
2003-07-31
|
07 | Randy Bush | State Changes to 0 from RFC Published by Randy Bush |
|
2003-07-31
|
07 | Randy Bush | State Changes to RFC Published from RFC Ed Queue by Randy Bush |
|
2003-07-31
|
07 | Randy Bush | RFC3575 |
|
2003-07-30
|
07 | (System) | RFC published |
|
2003-05-06
|
07 | Natalia Syracuse | State Changes to RFC Ed Queue from Approved-announcement to be sent by Syracuse, Natalia |
|
2003-04-25
|
07 | Jacqueline Hargest | State Changes to Approved-announcement to be sent from IESG Evaluation :: Revised ID Needed by Hargest, Jacqueline |
|
2003-04-25
|
07 | (System) | IESG has approved the document |
|
2003-04-24
|
07 | (System) | New version available: draft-aboba-radius-iana-07.txt |
|
2003-04-18
|
06 | (System) | New version available: draft-aboba-radius-iana-06.txt |
|
2003-04-09
|
05 | (System) | New version available: draft-aboba-radius-iana-05.txt |
|
2003-04-03
|
07 | Randy Bush | From: Randy Bush <randy@psg.com> Date: Thu, 3 Apr 2003 09:01:34 -0800 To: ipfix@net.doit.wisc.edu Subject: [ipfix] iesg comment on draft-ietf-ipfix-reqs-09.txt comments from iesg reviewers … From: Randy Bush <randy@psg.com> Date: Thu, 3 Apr 2003 09:01:34 -0800 To: ipfix@net.doit.wisc.edu Subject: [ipfix] iesg comment on draft-ietf-ipfix-reqs-09.txt comments from iesg reviewers randy --- I see: 5.4. Timestamps The metering process MUST be able to generate timestamps for the first and the last observation of a packet of a flow at the observation point. The timestamp resolution MUST be at least the one of the sysUpTime [RFC1213], which is one centisecond. I think I'd rather see a reference to RFC3418 instead of RFC1213. We can do so by RFC-Editor note. May want to check with authors too. On page 14 I see: 9. type of service octet (in case of IPv4), traffic class octet (in case of IPv6) Is that not better state as 9. DSCP, which is set in the type of service octet (in case of IPv4), or in the traffic class octet (in case of IPv6) --- I would prefer to see the paragraph referencing RFC 2119 in section 2. Last paragraph in section 6.3.3 needs to be reworded. In section 10.2, an important point is left unsaid. If the injection of IPFIX traffic fool the network provided into thinking that a DOS attack is underway, the countermeasures employed by the network provider may actually deny service to real customers. The appendix needs to be moved up in the document. --- Overall, I like it. A couple of things jumped out at me, though. This document goes to a lot of trouble to say exactly what is exported (e.g. what fields, etc), except for two cases: 8. byte counter Which bytes of a packet are counted MUST be defined exactly. 20. multicast replication factor the number of outgoing packets originating from a single incoming multicast packet. This is a dynamic property of multicast flows, that may change over time. For unicast flows it has the constant value 1. The computation of the factor MUST be clearly defined. This document is defining what fields are being reported on; why can't it also define these two things that must also be defined? Is it useful to have different ipfix protocols exporting different measurements? Also, at the end of 6.1 it kind of says "Plus other stuff related to inter-AS routing if you want". It's already in the MAY section; can't they just list some concrete items related to inter-AS routing as 27, 28, ...? I don't think it's useful to say what amounts to "plus anything else that you might feel like adding that you think is relevant", since that doesn't encourage different people to make the same choices. --- This is a good document overall. The applications include usage-based accounting. They should cite RFC 2975, and indicate that the particular niche for usage-based accounting would not be met if reliability was not very high. Section 5.1 reliability requirements do not meet the needs, nor do the timestamping of first and last packet of a flow, because the flow may have been mischaracterized and that is first and last of different flows. The way to satisfy this issue is to caveat the discussion of usage-based accounting with strong words on reliability that counter the comments on lesser reliability and more probabilistic techniques for other applications of ipfix. Requirements on the ipfix implementation - the document is long and I wonder if the working group really meant the protocol's confidentiality and anonymization features to be so optional - SHOULD confidentiality, MAY anonymization. Just for implementation. -30- |
|
2003-04-03
|
07 | Randy Bush | State Changes to IESG Evaluation :: Revised ID Needed from IESG Evaluation by Bush, Randy |
|
2003-04-02
|
04 | (System) | New version available: draft-aboba-radius-iana-04.txt |
|
2003-04-01
|
07 | Randy Bush | State Changes to IESG Evaluation from In Last Call by Bush, Randy |
|
2003-04-01
|
07 | Randy Bush | this resolves last call comments and needs to be put on iesg agenda for 2003.04.17 |
|
2003-03-31
|
03 | (System) | New version available: draft-aboba-radius-iana-03.txt |
|
2003-03-24
|
02 | (System) | New version available: draft-aboba-radius-iana-02.txt |
|
2003-02-21
|
07 | Stephen Coya | Status date has been changed to 2003-03-21 from |
|
2003-02-21
|
07 | Stephen Coya | State Changes to In Last Call from Last Call Requested by Coya, Steve |
|
2003-02-21
|
07 | (System) | Last call sent |
|
2003-02-12
|
01 | (System) | New version available: draft-aboba-radius-iana-01.txt |
|
2003-02-11
|
07 | Randy Bush | Draft Added by Bush, Randy |
|
2003-02-10
|
00 | (System) | New version available: draft-aboba-radius-iana-00.txt |