NAT Behavioral Requirements for ICMP
RFC 5508

Revision differences

Document history

Date Rev. By Action
2015-10-14
12 (System) Notify list changed from behave-chairs@ietf.org, suresh@kazeon.com, srisuresh@yahoo.com to suresh@kazeon.com
2012-08-22
12 (System) post-migration administrative database adjustment to the No Objection position for Tim Polk
2012-08-22
12 (System) post-migration administrative database adjustment to the Abstain position for Lars Eggert
2009-04-13
12 Cindy Morgan State Changes to RFC Published from RFC Ed Queue by Cindy Morgan
2009-04-13
12 Cindy Morgan [Note]: 'BCP 148; RFC 5508' added by Cindy Morgan
2009-04-06
12 (System) RFC published
2009-02-17
12 Cindy Morgan State Changes to RFC Ed Queue from Approved-announcement sent by Cindy Morgan
2009-02-17
12 (System) IANA Action state changed to No IC from In Progress
2009-02-17
12 (System) IANA Action state changed to In Progress
2009-02-17
12 Amy Vezza IESG state changed to Approved-announcement sent
2009-02-17
12 Amy Vezza IESG has approved the document
2009-02-17
12 Amy Vezza Closed "Approve" ballot
2009-02-17
12 Amy Vezza State Changes to Approved-announcement to be sent from IESG Evaluation::AD Followup by Amy Vezza
2009-01-23
12 Cullen Jennings [Ballot Position Update] Position for Cullen Jennings has been changed to Undefined from Discuss by Cullen Jennings
2009-01-23
12 Cullen Jennings [Ballot discuss]
2009-01-07
12 (System) New version available: draft-ietf-behave-nat-icmp-12.txt
2009-01-07
12 Cullen Jennings State Change Notice email list have been change to behave-chairs@tools.ietf.org, suresh@kazeon.com, srisuresh@yahoo.com from behave-chairs@tools.ietf.org
2009-01-07
12 Cullen Jennings

Hi Suresh,

I sent you a separate test ping message yesterday but I suspect you did not get that and I'm worried you are not ...
2008-12-26
12 Cullen Jennings
[Ballot comment]
This draft has changed substantially since the version that went to WGLC and IETF LC. I feel very uncomfortable with having all these ...
2008-12-26
12 Cullen Jennings
[Ballot discuss]
The latest draft is looking very good and I think we are close to done. I do have a problem claiming a NAT ...
2008-11-22
11 (System) New version available: draft-ietf-behave-nat-icmp-11.txt
2008-10-20
10 (System) New version available: draft-ietf-behave-nat-icmp-10.txt
2008-09-30
12 (System) Sub state has been changed to AD Follow up from New Id Needed
2008-09-30
09 (System) New version available: draft-ietf-behave-nat-icmp-09.txt
2008-09-05
12 Magnus Westerlund State Changes to IESG Evaluation::Revised ID Needed from IESG Evaluation::AD Followup by Magnus Westerlund
2008-09-05
12 Magnus Westerlund
Finally managed to get Cullen into a phone conference to resolve this. The main issue is that we still point to requirement that aren't desirable ...
2008-09-04
12 Cullen Jennings [Ballot comment]
2008-09-04
12 Cullen Jennings
[Ballot discuss]
The document requires implementation of some parts of RFC 1812 section 4.3 which I don't think there was WG consensus (or even discussion) ...
2008-07-01
12 Lars Eggert [Ballot Position Update] Position for Lars Eggert has been changed to Abstain from Discuss by Lars Eggert
2008-06-09
12 (System) Sub state has been changed to AD Follow up from New Id Needed
2008-06-09
08 (System) New version available: draft-ietf-behave-nat-icmp-08.txt
2008-05-13
12 Magnus Westerlund State Changes to IESG Evaluation::Revised ID Needed from IESG Evaluation::AD Followup by Magnus Westerlund
2008-03-19
12 Cullen Jennings
[Ballot discuss]
I have a bunch of issues here but they are all very easy to resolve.

The document states a NAT is a router ...
2008-03-19
12 Cullen Jennings
[Ballot discuss]
I have a bunch of issues here but they are all very easy to resolve.

The document states a NAT is a router ...
2008-03-19
12 Cullen Jennings
[Ballot discuss]
I have a bunch of issues here but they are all very easy to resolve.

The document states a NAT is a router ...
2008-02-28
12 Magnus Westerlund Still issues unresolved with Cullen's discuss. Need to figure out how to resolved them. Talk in Philadelphia
2008-02-14
12 Jari Arkko [Ballot Position Update] Position for Jari Arkko has been changed to No Objection from Discuss by Jari Arkko
2008-02-14
12 Jari Arkko [Ballot discuss]
2008-02-14
12 Jari Arkko
[Ballot discuss]
This document is much needed, thanks for writing it!

I agree though with the Discusses and Comments given by other ADs. In addition, ...
2008-02-14
12 Ron Bonica [Ballot Position Update] Position for Ron Bonica has been changed to No Objection from Discuss by Ron Bonica
2008-02-13
12 Tim Polk [Ballot Position Update] Position for Tim Polk has been changed to No Objection from Undefined by Tim Polk
2008-02-13
12 Tim Polk [Ballot Position Update] Position for Tim Polk has been changed to Undefined from Discuss by Tim Polk
2008-02-07
12 (System) Sub state has been changed to AD Follow up from New Id Needed
2008-02-07
07 (System) New version available: draft-ietf-behave-nat-icmp-07.txt
2007-11-15
12 Amy Vezza State Changes to IESG Evaluation::Revised ID Needed from IESG Evaluation by Amy Vezza
2007-11-15
12 Lisa Dusseault [Ballot Position Update] New position, No Objection, has been recorded by Lisa Dusseault
2007-11-15
12 Jari Arkko
[Ballot discuss]
This document is much needed, thanks for writing it!

I agree though with the Discusses and Comments given by other ADs. In addition, ...
2007-11-15
12 Jari Arkko
[Ballot comment]
REQ-9 in summary has a different (and incorrect) capitalization
of the Packet Too Big message from what appeared in the body
of the ...
2007-11-15
12 Jari Arkko [Ballot Position Update] New position, Discuss, has been recorded by Jari Arkko
2007-11-15
12 Jon Peterson [Ballot Position Update] New position, No Objection, has been recorded by Jon Peterson
2007-11-15
12 Cullen Jennings
[Ballot discuss]
I have a bunch of issues here but they are all very easy to resolve.

The document states a NAT is a router ...
2007-11-15
12 Cullen Jennings
[Ballot comment]
In section 3.2, first sentence.
  When an application initiates an ICMP Query that transits a NAT
  device, the NAT associates a ...
2007-11-15
12 Cullen Jennings [Ballot Position Update] New position, Discuss, has been recorded by Cullen Jennings
2007-11-14
12 Amy Vezza State Changes to IESG Evaluation from IESG Evaluation - Defer by Amy Vezza
2007-11-02
12 Ron Bonica
[Ballot comment]
COMMENT:

In Section 4.1, you say that if an ICMP Error message includes the entire embedded packet, the NAT box should try to ...
2007-11-02
12 (System) Removed from agenda for telechat - 2007-11-01
2007-11-01
12 Chris Newman [Ballot Position Update] New position, No Objection, has been recorded by Chris Newman
2007-11-01
12 Chris Newman
[Ballot comment]
I suspect the last occurrence of the word "Error" should be removed in
the following text:

  do not have an "Identifier" field ...
2007-11-01
12 Chris Newman
[Ballot comment]
I suspect the last occurrence of the word "Error" should be removed in
the following text:

  do not have an "Identifier" field ...
2007-11-01
12 Chris Newman
[Ballot comment]
I suspect the last occurrence of the word "Error" should be removed in
the following text:

  do not have an "Identifier" field ...
2007-10-31
12 Cullen Jennings State Changes to IESG Evaluation - Defer from IESG Evaluation by Cullen Jennings
2007-10-31
12 Ross Callon [Ballot Position Update] New position, No Objection, has been recorded by Ross Callon
2007-10-31
12 Ron Bonica
[Ballot comment]
You say:

The mapping of ICMP Query identifier within the NAT device SHOULD
  be external endpoint independent. Say, an internal host A ...
2007-10-31
12 Ron Bonica
[Ballot comment]
You say:

The mapping of ICMP Query identifier within the NAT device SHOULD
  be external endpoint independent. Say, an internal host A ...
2007-10-31
12 Ron Bonica [Ballot Position Update] New position, Discuss, has been recorded by Ron Bonica
2007-10-31
12 Russ Housley [Ballot Position Update] New position, No Objection, has been recorded by Russ Housley
2007-10-31
12 Dan Romascanu [Ballot comment]
Informative reference [BEH-APP] seems to be expired and does not have any continuation in the Working Group.
2007-10-31
12 David Ward
[Ballot comment]
The issue of 4.1 appears to be under active discussion w/ Carlos, Lars, Suresh and they are working towards resolution. I put this ...
2007-10-31
12 David Ward [Ballot Position Update] New position, No Objection, has been recorded by David Ward
2007-10-31
12 Dan Romascanu [Ballot Position Update] New position, No Objection, has been recorded by Dan Romascanu
2007-10-30
12 Tim Polk
[Ballot discuss]
In section 4.1, paragraph two the document states

                              ...
2007-10-30
12 Tim Polk [Ballot Position Update] New position, Discuss, has been recorded by Tim Polk
2007-10-30
12 Sam Hartman
[Ballot comment]
I'd like to strongly agree with Lars's discuss on section 4.1.  A NAT
is not a security firewall.  NATs may be combined with ...
2007-10-30
12 Sam Hartman [Ballot Position Update] New position, No Objection, has been recorded by Sam Hartman
2007-10-27
12 Lars Eggert
[Ballot comment]
Section 240, paragraph 0:
>    ICMP Query session timer MUST not expire in less than 60 seconds. We

  s/MUST not/MUST NOT/ ...
2007-10-27
12 Lars Eggert
[Ballot discuss]
Section 4.1., paragraph 4:
>    REQ-3:  When an ICMP Error packet is received, the NAT device
>    SHOULD do the following. ...
2007-10-27
12 Lars Eggert [Ballot Position Update] New position, Discuss, has been recorded by Lars Eggert
2007-10-16
12 Magnus Westerlund State Changes to IESG Evaluation from Waiting for AD Go-Ahead::AD Followup by Magnus Westerlund
2007-10-16
12 Magnus Westerlund Placed on agenda for telechat - 2007-11-01 by Magnus Westerlund
2007-10-16
12 Magnus Westerlund [Ballot Position Update] New position, Yes, has been recorded for Magnus Westerlund
2007-10-16
12 Magnus Westerlund Ballot has been issued by Magnus Westerlund
2007-10-16
12 Magnus Westerlund Created "Approve" ballot
2007-10-16
12 (System) Sub state has been changed to AD Follow up from New Id Needed
2007-10-16
06 (System) New version available: draft-ietf-behave-nat-icmp-06.txt
2007-10-12
12 Magnus Westerlund State Changes to Waiting for AD Go-Ahead::Revised ID Needed from Waiting for AD Go-Ahead by Magnus Westerlund
2007-10-12
12 Magnus Westerlund State Changes to Waiting for AD Go-Ahead from Waiting for Writeup by Magnus Westerlund
2007-10-11
12 (System) State has been changed to Waiting for Writeup from In Last Call by system
2007-10-11
12 Samuel Weiler Request for Last Call review by SECDIR Completed. Reviewer: Chris Lonvick.
2007-10-08
12 Amanda Baber IANA Last Call comments:

As described in the IANA Considerations section, we understand this document
to have NO IANA Actions.
2007-09-29
12 Samuel Weiler Request for Last Call review by SECDIR is assigned to Chris Lonvick
2007-09-29
12 Samuel Weiler Request for Last Call review by SECDIR is assigned to Chris Lonvick
2007-09-27
12 Amy Vezza Last call sent
2007-09-27
12 Amy Vezza State Changes to In Last Call from Last Call Requested by Amy Vezza
2007-09-27
12 Magnus Westerlund State Changes to Last Call Requested from AD Evaluation::AD Followup by Magnus Westerlund
2007-09-27
12 Magnus Westerlund Last Call was requested by Magnus Westerlund
2007-09-27
12 (System) Ballot writeup text was added
2007-09-27
12 (System) Last call text was added
2007-09-27
12 (System) Ballot approval text was added
2007-09-26
12 (System) Sub state has been changed to AD Follow up from New Id Needed
2007-09-26
05 (System) New version available: draft-ietf-behave-nat-icmp-05.txt
2007-09-04
12 Magnus Westerlund State Changes to AD Evaluation::Revised ID Needed from AD Evaluation by Magnus Westerlund
2007-09-04
12 Magnus Westerlund AD comments sent to authors and WG.
2007-09-03
12 Magnus Westerlund State Changes to AD Evaluation from Publication Requested by Magnus Westerlund
2007-08-14
12 Dinara Suleymanova
PROTO Write-up

(1.a) Who is the Document Shepherd for this document?

Dan Wing, dwing@cisco.com

Has the
Document Shepherd personally reviewed this version of the
document ...
2007-08-14
12 Dinara Suleymanova Draft Added by Dinara Suleymanova in state Publication Requested
2007-07-03
04 (System) New version available: draft-ietf-behave-nat-icmp-04.txt
2007-03-01
03 (System) New version available: draft-ietf-behave-nat-icmp-03.txt
2007-02-20
02 (System) New version available: draft-ietf-behave-nat-icmp-02.txt
2006-10-05
01 (System) New version available: draft-ietf-behave-nat-icmp-01.txt
2006-05-24
00 (System) New version available: draft-ietf-behave-nat-icmp-00.txt