Skip to main content

Loss and Delay Measurement in Transparent Interconnection of Lots of Links (TRILL)
RFC 7456

Yes

(Ted Lemon)

No Objection

(Barry Leiba)
(Jari Arkko)
(Joel Jaeggli)
(Kathleen Moriarty)
(Martin Stiemerling)
(Pete Resnick)
(Spencer Dawkins)
(Stephen Farrell)

Abstain


Note: This ballot was opened for revision 05 and is now closed.

Ted Lemon Former IESG member
Yes
Yes (for -05)

                            
Adrian Farrel Former IESG member
No Objection
No Objection (2014-08-07 for -06)
I am balloting No objection on the basis of a very light review. I trust the responsible AD to have ensured adequate review.

Here are some nits:

---

You say:

   Operations, Administration and Maintenance (OAM) [OAM]

But the cited document uses:

   Operations, Administration, and Maintenance (OAM)

See also your Abstract.

---

While you have correctly noted that Y.1731 is now G.8013/Y.1731, you 
should update your reference to the most recent edition.

   [ITU-T.Y.8013-2013]
              ITU, "ITU-T Recommendation G.8013/Y.1731: OAM functions and
              mechanisms for Ethernet based networks", ITU-T
              Recommendation G.8013/Y.1731, 2013.

---

Section 1

   These protocols generally conform to
   the performance monitoring functionality defined in ITU-T
   G.8013/Y.1731 [Y.1731].

"generally conform" is an odd term. Things either conform or they don't.
So I interpret that some of the protocols conform and some don't, with 
the balance being that most of the protocols conform. That means a few
don't and it would be good call out the specifics.
Barry Leiba Former IESG member
No Objection
No Objection (for -06)

                            
Jari Arkko Former IESG member
No Objection
No Objection (for -06)

                            
Joel Jaeggli Former IESG member
No Objection
No Objection (for -06)

                            
Kathleen Moriarty Former IESG member
No Objection
No Objection (for -06)

                            
Martin Stiemerling Former IESG member
No Objection
No Objection (for -05)

                            
Pete Resnick Former IESG member
No Objection
No Objection (2014-09-26)

                            
Spencer Dawkins Former IESG member
No Objection
No Objection (for -06)

                            
Stephen Farrell Former IESG member
No Objection
No Objection (for -06)

                            
Richard Barnes Former IESG member
Abstain
Abstain (2014-08-14 for -06)
My ABSTAIN here is because Donald Eastlake is both chair of the WG and editor of many of its documents.  This undermines the consensus process in TRILL to the degree that I cannot support the publication of documents on which he is editor.