July 18th, 2018, 1520-1650 (EDT)
(Chairs, 5m)
Blue SheetsNote taker - Phill Hallam Baker Jabber relay - Dave Thaler
Thanks to both.
(Chairs, 2m)
Updated Drafts:
Progressing Drafts: - draft-ietf-homenet-babel-profile-07
(Daniel Migault, Jacques Latour, 20m)
drafts on front-end-naming-delegation and naming-architecture-dhc-options, and their implementation [See slides for presentation]
Draft has been on hold pending architecture work but is pretty well baked.
Ted Lemon: Useful and important work. Main question, have you tried implementing?
= Daniel: Have synced main and secondary. Have not implemented myself but Jacques Latour has. = Jacques Latour: Have spent two years developing an secure home gateway. Syrahlabs?? Goal is to have DNSSEC inside and outside the house for the home gateway. Sign DNSSEC inside the house.
Ted Lemon: How was the document? = Jacques Latour: It is a bit long and could be shortened. Don't know if we do the signing on the gateway or the outsourced signing gateway - capacity issues.
Ted Lemon: I think the document needs to be more concise.
Denis Ovsienko: Have you considered home.arpa? Did you consider possibility of desynchronization of records? = Daniel: We assume home has a zone, not looking at using .arpa zone.
Juliusz Chroboczek: Can you hear me now? :-) What problem are you solving that is not solved by DYN-DNS? = Mark Andrews: Juliusz is talking about Microsoft Dynamic update. If you are doing Windows AD the host does a periodic DNS update and this pushes the records to the zone uses the standard DNS protocol then reads them back forcing garbage collection. Difference is that the update is permanent.
(This has subsequently been taken to list so any further discussion is likely better on that thread.)
(Barbara Stark, 10m)
What Babel will deliver...
(Ted Lemon, 50m)
Naming Slides What's Left? Slides
Phillip Prendaville: If we are using static mappings, discovery must work when the device is switched off.
Stuart Cheshire: Would like WG to make a request to the list to ask if reverse queries matter in various contexts.
David Schemazi: Plug for DNSSD working group next morning.
The specification of friendly link names should be a WG item.
Suggestion is to have 4-5 calls, 2-3 weeks apart to progress this draft to the point where it's editorially complete and consistent, and at the point where we can get good implementer feedback.
Plan is for WG to wait for implementer feedback before hitting the "Publication Requested" button for the draft, so these calls do not have that as an immediate target.
Juliusz: We need a prototype to play with = Ted Lemon: Have been working quite a bit on implementation. Discovery relay is done, need to finish discovery proxy. Needs to work how to get code out (will be OS some point).
Barbara: Would be good if people mailed chairs and say if they are interested and when their times would be.
Meeting adjourned.