Chairs: Akira Tsukamoto, David Waltermire
Notes: Russ Housley, Dave Thaler
Submitted to IESG for Publication, but there are two DISCUSS ballot
position that need to be resolved.
Thomas Fossati: posted feedback on some problems in the examples in -28.
Should be easy to address.
See
https://mailarchive.ietf.org/arch/msg/suit/Oo5qlA-sKE2JlFj6YVD16zTm9CI/
Brendan Moran: will provide a more detailed update later in the agenda,
but lots of work going on this week. Thought an update already happened
on github but will check. -29 is published this week but -30 coming
soon.
[Later in the meeting, Brendan presented the document update]
Brendan Moran: IANA told Brendan what to write to address IANA review,
which is now done in -28. This should resolve Murray's DISCUSS ballot
position. Orie's should be resolved too. Not sure whether Paul Wouters
comments have been sufficiently resolved.
-29 just addressed a merge error in references section.
Github copy now addresses all of points on IANA Considerations,
including Murray's.
Deb Cooley: On Oct 25th, Paul emailed
(https://mailarchive.ietf.org/arch/msg/suit/xT7csz-j3w_mSMuD_8TgTB4wObE/)
saying it wasn't sufficient. Brendan to check and cc Deb.
draft-ietf-suit-trust-domains-08
Submitted to IESG for Publication, and the Security AD (Deb Cooley) has
completed the AD Review. An updated shepherd write-up is needed.
[Later in the meeting, Ken and Brendan remotely presented the document
update]
CCDL examples were corrected; they are now valid, and a Github CI check
as added to ensure they remain correct in the github version.
Brendan explained the reasons for the references -- they are essentially
requirements related to trust docmains.
Deb: fine with keeping the reference, but would like to see more text
along the lines of what you said on slide 18.
Brendan: will get the IPR confirmation done asap
Hannes: regarding PR 24, implicit indices are surprising rather than
explicit indices. Will file issue in tracker. Affects composability of
manifest.
Brendan: will fix or at least explain why it's the way it is. Yes please
file an issue.
Dave Waltermire: And mention on the mailing list.
draft-ietf-suit-firmware-encryption-21
Submitted to IESG for Publication. Will be seeking a new document
shepherd.
[Later in the meeting, Hannes presented the document update]
Recieved reviews from Martin Thomson and Ron Bonica. Comments have been
addressed, and the examples were updated. It is now ready for IESG
Evaluation.
Hannes: Need reviewers since there were so many editorial changes.
Hannes mentioned editing tips from Martin (about tables) and Carsten
(about CDDL), which would have saved him
hours if he had known earlier.
Dave Thaler: is there somewhere that advertises such tips since they
will help many other draft authors?
Henk: Maybe add warnings (or parameters) similar to the "make fix-lint"
hint to Martin's i-d-template CI.
Deb: This draft is on telechat for November 21st. Please review quickly.
Kris Kwiatkowski offered to connect with Hannes to provide some extra
review before the telechat date.
In WG Last Call, but it has been completed.Clarified that encryption is
optional.
[Brendan Moran presented]
No comments.
Submitted to IESG for Publication. Roman is holding the document. No one
in the room knows why.
Deb Cooley: Although it is waiting for normative referencs, Roman
doesn't need to hold it. Chairs should ask Roman to not hold or say why.
Chairs will CC Deb.
[Later in the meeting, Brendan discussed the status]
Brendan: no update to document. Held for manifest so nothing we can do
right now.
Brendan Moran: We need to publish this, but expect we will need a -bis
soon.
Russ Housley will document shepherd this draft.
[Later in the meeting, Brendan presented the document update]
No comments.
draft-ietf-suit-update-management-07
WG Consensus: Waiting for Write-Up.
Thomas Fossati is willing to be document shepherd.
[Later in the meeting, Brendan discussed the status]
Brendan: no update to document. Held for manifest so nothing we can do
right now.
No further topics were raised, so meeting ended 6 minutes early.