CCAMP working group agenda - IETF 123
Tuesday, July 22nd, 2025
14:30-16:30 (CEST) – Room Patio 3, Madrid Spain Presentation Start Time Duration Information 0 14:30 15 Title: Administrativia & Agenda Bashing
Presenter: Chairs Oscar (on model dependency): teas is speeding up to get the blocking documents publicated. Scott Mansfield (on liaison): towards 2030 it would be useful to send me anything is done to construct the ecosystem.
1 14:45 10 Title: A YANG data model to manage configurable DWDM optical
interfaces
Draft:
https://datatracker.ietf.org/doc/draft-ietf-ccamp-dwdm-if-param-yang
Presenter: Gabriele Galimberti
Daniele: it's time for a 2nd Yang Doctor Review, together with rtgdir,
then to move forward, after 9093bis.
2 14:55 10 Title: A YANG Data Model for WDM Tunnels
Draft:
https://datatracker.ietf.org/doc/draft-ietf-ccamp-wdm-tunnel-yang
Presenter: Aihua Guo
Daniele: it's useful to indicate the (soft) dependency with the
pluggable. We will note it on the wiki.
3 15:05 10 Title: Use cases, Network Scenarios and gap analysis for
Packet Optical
Integration (POI) with programmable pluggables under ACTN Framework
Draft:
https://datatracker.ietf.org/doc/draft-ietf-ccamp-actn-poi-pluggable-usecases-gaps/
Presenter: Oscar Gonzalez de Dios
Daniele: Question for Ketan, should we target to publish the document ?
Ketan (AD): Informational documents could be published if they help
deployment of the solution. If only needed to coorindate the requirement
does not make sense.
Daniele: we find some value for this document - setting the requirements
and objective would be useful.
Italo: for open issue #12, the discussion from impairment work was that
the validation for the optical feasibility is based on the operational
model rather than the part number. Why don't consider this option?
Oscar: characteristics on the same operational mode from different
vendors are different.
Italo: the opeartional mode from different vendords are different.
Oscar: we need to know the sensitivity of the pluggable
Italo: operational mode could handle sentitivity, including OSNR, PDL,
PMD margin which are needed to check optical feasibility
Oscar: it's just beyond just operational in impairment, it's not covered
in the single number.
Italo: the idea is to have report the same capabilities of a transceiver
independently on which specific hardware (pluggable or even not
pluggable).
Oscar: Key is to have different vendors in a consistent way.
Italo: it's the same/diff operational mode. The design of operational
mode allows different vendors can have different operational mode. The
operational model identifies the performances of transmitter and
receiver.
(Daniele suggests to move the discussion offline.)
Swamy (on page 4 inventory options): what is the inventory related part
(having external ones) of the pluggable management? Does it depend on
what is already discussed as the inventory management?
Oscar: option 1 is for your planning phase, to be used as input to
planning tool, this part is not fully automated in the industry.
Swamy(issue #15): any distinction on pluggable? How complicated ar they?
Oscar: so far it is raised via the weekly call, to add the use case (not
there yet). TBD if we want to split or upgrades existing use cases, may
trigger different mechanism, looking forward to contributions.
Swamy: There is going to be some discussion on CMIS, how to do upgrade
from different vendors. Input from this work is welcome.
Fatai: for option 1 and 2, any analysis? it's better to have only one.
Oscar: option 1 is taken for granted on how to do it today - option 2
provides higher level of automation.
Julien: we need to revolve some misunderstanding - someting is already
defined in optical impairment. Suggest to discuss and align the use of
terms in a consistent manner.
4 15:15 15 Title: Data Modelling and Gap Analysis of Optical Pluggables
in Packet Over Optical Network
Draft:
https://datatracker.ietf.org/doc/html/draft-rokui-ccamp-actn-wdm-pluggable-modelling
Presenter: Reza Rokui
Daniele: ready to start polling, but what is going to be in -03? The
draft still lacks the gap analysis and YANG model. The interest is
clear. What is the planning?
Reza: please wait for -03, it fits into your concern. We will have
something to resolve the problem in -03.
5 15:30 10 Title: A YANG Data Model for CMIS Access and Control
Draft:
https://datatracker.ietf.org/doc/draft-hi-ccamp-cmis-control-yang/
Presenter: Shunsuke Homma
Reza: We consider CMIS usage in the previous draft, so we suggest to put
the model together and specify a single model.
Shunsuke: happy to collaborate.
Fatai: CMIS is introduced by OIF, the term in the draft is not quite
consistent what is defined in OIF.
Shunsuke: Feedback from CMIS aspect will be welcomed.
6 15:40 10 Title: A YANG Data Model for Microwave Radio Link
Draft: https://datatracker.ietf.org/doc/draft-ybam-rfc8561bis/
Presenter: Scott Mansfield
Daniele: it belongs to ccamp! (yes.)
Mohammad Boroon: according to the open issues, there is a gap to fill
between the air interface and the microwave radio link, there is no
clear approach yet. Is there a workflow how the information is handled
in the microwave radio link?
Scott: there is a spread sheet to maintain.
Mohammad: if it needs to address a gap, we need to extend the reach of
the data model - for example the alarm handling, may need to extend the
model massively.
Scott: we will figure out the problem to work, and decide to solve it in
this or another draft.
7 15:50 10 Title: YANG Data Models for fine grain Optical Transport
Network
Draft: https://datatracker.ietf.org/doc/draft-tan-ccamp-fgotn-yang/
Presenter: Yanxia Tan
Aihua: could the hitless resizing be done in bidirectional way
simultaneously?
Yanxia: Forwarding direction adjustment is triggered by the controller,
reverse is triggered by the data plane.
8 16:00 10 Title: Applicability of Service & Infrastructure Maps (SIMAP)
to Transport Networks
Draft:
https://datatracker.ietf.org/doc/html/draft-busi-nmop-transport-simap
Presenter: Italo Busi
Daniele: CCAMP should be the right home for this work, we will look into
NMOP work and adapt it to CCAMP network.
Daniele: use another term than 'transport'.
Julien: make sure this work is visible to nmop.
Luis: maybe include microwave as well?
Italo: at the moment only OTN/WDM.
9 16:10 10 Title: A YANG Data Model of Performance Management Streaming
Draft: https://datatracker.ietf.org/doc/draft-yoon-ccamp-pm-streaming/
Presenter: Bin Yeong Yoon
Aihua: why measurement interval is the child of sampling intervals?
Bin Yeong: it's consistent with G.7710.
10 16:22
Ketan: announcement on the ONIONS work. Call for CCAMP attention, not
final decisions.
Daniele: key for ONIONS is 'abstraction', the draft that is impacted is
about the network slicing.
Adjourn 16:25