Meetecho (Remote: a/v and chat):
https://meetings.conf.meetecho.com/ietf125/?session=35243
Audio (only):
https://mp3.conf.meetecho.com/ietf124/35423.m3u
CodiMD (Notes):
https://notes.ietf.org/notes-ietf-125-mls
Note Takers: Yan Bo Ti, Jiawei Wu
Richard Barnes noted that draft-ietf-mls-partial-mls (previous
refererred to as "Light MLS") is implemented in MLS++ and ready for
WGLC. There was a requst for test vectors. A poll indicated that 5 had
read the draft and that 17 had not.
Raphael Robert presented The Messaging Layer Security (MLS)
Extensions. One open issue remains regarding mandated extensions in
federated contexts. Rohan Mahy suggested an "opaque dictionary"
extension to allow members to bypass unknown components in the group
context without cryptographic eviction.
After some editorial polishing, the draft will be ready for WGLC.
draft-ietf-mls-targeted-messages
Raphael Robert presented Messaging Layer Security (MLS) Targeted
Messages. Discussion focused on whether to include ratchets for
efficiency. Richard Barnes argued against ratchets, suggesting that if
PCS/forward secrecy is needed beyond one-shot messages, users should
create a new group. Rohan Mahy expressed interest in "wrapping" messages
to support multiple recipients (e.g., sending to all moderators).
draft-ietf-mls-pq-ciphersuites
Rohan Mahy updated the group on ML-KEM and Hybrid Cipher Suites for
Messaging Layer Security. The draft now includes nine ciphersuites
to satisfy varying requirements for AES-128/SHA-256 and AES-256/SHA-384.
The chairs asked where there were objections to issuing a WGLC and there
were none.
draft-ietf-mls-virtual-clients
Konrad Kohbrok updated the group on MLS Virtual Clients. The draft
is being merged with Brendan McMillion's subgroup work. Implementation
in OpenMLS revealed that clients must be able to process their own
commits and manage randomness injection differently than standard MLS.
Konrad noted that future work includes editorial work, emulation client
management, and security considerations. He is hoping to work with
academia to get more insights.
Marta Mularczyk presented Amortized PQ MLS Combiner. The draft was
renamed to "Amortized" to avoid confusion with hybrid ciphersuites. It
now aligns with the Safe Application Interface from the extensions
draft, using the Safe Exporter for PSK injection.
One the PR for PQ Authenticty Guarantees is merged there will be one
small PR to address two points. The chairs asked whether there were any
other objections to another (3rd WGLC) - there were none.
draft-kohbrok-mls-fewer-signatures
Konrad Kohbrok updated the group on Fewer Signatures, aimed at
reducing overhead for ML-DSA by hashing outer message structures into
the leaf node signature. Rohan Mahy raised a concern regarding a
potential circular dependency ("Klein bottle" problem) when applying
this to internal commits that include the group context in the
transcript hash. Konrad noted that you could hash all the contents in
the messages, and only sign the leaf node - will see if it works. Carlos
asked whether we considering cases where we are receiving multiple
signatures? Are we considering merkle trees? Konrad is open to ideas and
is open to considering other use-cases with batched signatures too.
Knorad noted future work includes revisiting the security proofs when
the draft is stable.
draft-kohbrok-mls-two-party-profile
Konrad Kohbrok presented MLS Two Party Profile. The goal is to
provide a standardized way to use MLS for long-lived two-party
connections (e.g., in QUIC/TLS) to gain PCS. Richard Barnes noted Cisco
IPR and research-grade implementations. While there was strong interest
(a poll showed 10 had read the draft and 18 had not; another poll showed
13 interested in implementing), the chairs will coordinate with the
Security Area Director to determine if this work should stay in the MLS
WG or move elsewhere.
draft-mahy-mls-ratchet-tree-options
Rohan Mahy presented Ratchet Tree Options. The chairs noted that
they failed to call consensus on the WG adoption call. The chairs
further noted that there was consensus to adopt the draft and that Rohan
should submit when ready.
draft-mahy-mls-private-external-01
Rohan Mahy presented Private External Commits and External
Proposals. This draft addresses privacy leaks in environments with
private distribution services (e.g., XMTP) by encrypting external
commits via HPKE. There is a new wire format for PrivateExternalMessage.
The chairs polled who had read the I-D: 4 had and 15 had not.
draft-mahy-mls-new-framed-content-types
draft-mahy-mls-new-content-types
draft-mahy-mls-semiprivatemessage
draft-mahy-mls-ext-commit-pp
draft-mahy-mls-sd-cwt-credential
Rohan Mahy presented Web Token Credentials (and others),
introducing Selective Disclosure JWTs (SD-JWT) and COTs for MLS
credentials. This would allow disclosing specific identity claims to
group members while hiding them from the Distribution Service.