Internet Draft CAP October 22, 1999 Network Working Group Steve Mansour/Netscape Internet Draft Frank Dawson/Lotus <draft-ietf-calsch-cap-01.txt> Doug Royer/Software.com Alexander Taler/CS&T Paul Hill/MIT Expires six months from: October 22, 1999 Calendar Access Protocol (CAP) Status of this Memo This memo is an Internet-Draft and is in full conformance with all provisions of Section 10 of RFC2026. Internet-Drafts are working documents of the Internet Engineering Task Force (IETF), its areas, and its working groups. Note that other groups may also distribute working documents as Internet-Drafts. Internet-Drafts are draft documents valid for a maximum of six months and may be updated, replaced, or obsoleted by other documents at any time. It is inappropriate to use Internet- Drafts as reference material or to cite them other than as "work in progress." The list of current Internet-Drafts can be accessed at http://www.ietf.org/ietf/1id-abstracts.txt . The list of Internet-Draft Shadow Directories can be accessed at http://www.ietf.org/shadow.html. Distribution of this document is unlimited. Copyright Statement Copyright (C) The Internet Society 1999. All Rights Reserved. Abstract The Calendar Access Protocol (CAP) is an Internet protocol that permits a Calendar User (CU) to utilize a Calendar User Agent (CUA) to access an [RFC2445] based Calendar Store (CS). This memo defines the CAP specification. The CAP definition is based on requirements identified by the Internet Engineering Task Force (IETF) Calendaring and Scheduling (CALSCH) Working Group. More information about the IETF CALSCH Mansour/Dawson/Royer/Taler/Hill Expires: April 2000 1 Internet Draft CAP October 22, 1999 Working Group activities can be found on the IMC web site at http://www.imc.org/ietf-calendar, and at the IETF web site at http://www.ietf.org/html.charters/calsch-charter.html. Refer to the references within this memo for further information on how to access these various documents. Mansour/Dawson/Royer/Taler/Hill Expires: April 2000 2 Internet Draft CAP October 22, 1999 Table of Contents 1. Introduction ................................................ 3 1.1 Formatting Conventions ..................................... 3 1.2 Related Documents .......................................... 4 1.3 Definitions ................................................ 4 2. CAP Design .................................................. 8 2.1 System Model ............................................... 8 2.2 Calendar Store Object Model ................................ 9 2.3 Protocol Model ............................................. 10 2.4 Roles ...................................................... 11 2.5 Calendar User .............................................. 11 2.5.1 UPNs and Certificates .................................... 11 2.5.2 CAP session identity ..................................... 12 2.6 Calendar Addresses ......................................... 13 2.7 Finding CAP Servers ........................................ 14 2.7.1 Using DNS ................................................ 14 2.7.2 Using SLP ................................................ 14 2.8 Extensions to iCalendar .................................... 16 2.9 Relationship of RFC 2446 (ITIP) to CAP ..................... 17 2.10 VCalendar Access Rights (VCARs) ........................... 17 2.11 Query Schema .............................................. 18 3. State Diagram ............................................... 18 4. Protocol Framework .......................................... 19 4.1 CAP Application Layer ...................................... 19 4.2 CAP Transport Layer ........................................ 20 4.3 Response Format ............................................ 20 4.4 Auto-logout Timer .......................................... 20 4.5 Bounded Latency ............................................ 21 4.6 Data Elements .............................................. 21 5. Formal Command Syntax ....................................... 21 5.1 Searching and Filtering .................................... 21 5.1.1 Grammar For Search Mechanism ............................. 22 6. Access Rights ............................................... 22 6.1 VCAR Inheritance ........................................... 23 6.2 Access Control and NOCONFLICT .............................. 23 7. Commands and Responses ...................................... 23 7.1 Transport Protocol Commands ................................ 24 7.1.1 Initial Connection ....................................... 24 7.1.2 ABORT Command ............................................ 24 7.1.3 AUTHENTICATE Command ..................................... 25 7.1.6 DISCONNECT Command ....................................... 30 7.1.7 IDENTIFY Command ......................................... 30 7.1.8 SENDDATA Command ......................................... 30 7.1.9 STARTTLS Command ......................................... 31 7.2 Application Protocol Commands .............................. 32 7.2.1 Calendaring Commands ..................................... 32 7.2.1.1 CREATE Method .......................................... 32 Mansour/Dawson/Royer/Taler/Hill April 2000 Internet Draft CAP October 22, 1999 7.2.1.1.1 Creating New Calendars ............................... 32 7.2.1.2 DELETE Method .......................................... 34 7.2.1.3 GENERATEUID Method ..................................... 35 7.2.1.4 MODIFY Method .......................................... 35 7.2.1.5 MOVE Method ............................................ 36 7.2.1.6 READ Method ............................................ 37 7.2.2 Scheduling Commands ...................................... 41 7.2.2.1 PUBLISH ................................................ 41 7.2.2.2 REQUEST ................................................ 41 7.2.2.3 REPLY .................................................. 41 7.2.2.4 ADD .................................................... 41 7.2.2.5 CANCEL ................................................. 41 7.2.2.6 REFRESH ................................................ 41 7.2.2.7 COUNTER ................................................ 41 7.2.2.8 DECLINECOUNTER ......................................... 41 7.2.3 iTIP Examples ............................................ 42 7.2.3.1 Sending and Receiving an iTIP request .................. 42 7.2.3.2 Handling an iTIP refresh ............................... 45 7.2.3.3 Sending and accepting an iTIP counter .................. 46 7.2.3.4 Declining an iTIP counter .............................. 47 8. Response Codes .............................................. 48 9. Detailed SQL Schema ......................................... 50 9.1 iCalendar Store Schema ..................................... 51 10. Examples ................................................... 57 10.1 Authentication Examples ................................... 57 10.1.1 Login Using Kerberos V4 ................................. 57 10.1.2 Error Scenarios ......................................... 58 10.2 Read Examples ............................................. 58 10.2.1 Read From A Single Calendar ............................. 58 10.2.2 Read From Multiple Calendars ............................ 59 10.2.3 Timeouts ................................................ 61 10.2.4 Using the Calendar Parent, Children Properties .......... 62 10.2.5 An example that depends on VEVENT.DTSTART and VALARM.DTSTART ............................................ 62 11. Implementation Issues ...................................... 62 12. Properties ................................................. 62 12.1 Calendar Store Properties ................................. 62 12.2 Calendar Properties ....................................... 63 13. Security Considerations .................................... 64 14. Changes to iCalendar ....................................... 64 14.1 Created ................................................... 64 14.2 Last Modified ............................................. 65 14.2.1.1 Time Transparency ..................................... 66 14.3 RIGHTS Value Type ......................................... 67 14.4 VCAR Calendar Component ................................... 70 14.5 GRANT Component Property .................................. 72 14.6 DENY Component Property ................................... 73 Mansour/Dawson/Royer/Taler/Hill April 2000 Internet Draft CAP October 22, 1999 14.7 VCAR Identifier Component Property ........................ 73 15. CAP Entities Registration .................................. 75 15.2.1 Define the Entity ....................................... 76 15.2.2 Post the entity definition .............................. 77 15.2.3 Allow a comment period .................................. 77 15.2.4 Submit the entity for approval .......................... 77 15.3 Property Change Control ................................... 77 16. IANA Considerations ........................................ 78 17. Acknowledgments ............................................ 78 18. Bibliography ............................................... 78 19. Author's Address ........................................... 79 20. Full Copyright Statement ................................... 80 Mansour/Dawson/Royer/Taler/Hill April 2000 Internet Draft CAP October 22, 1999 1. Introduction This document specifies how a Calendar User Agent (CUA) interacts with a Calendar Store (CS) to manage calendar information. In particular, it specifies how to query, create, modify, and delete iCalendar components (e.g., events, to-dos, or daily journal entries). It further specifies how to search for available busy time information. This protocol is based on request/response form of protocol data units, sent from a client CUA to a calendar server. The protocol data units leverage the standard iCalendar format [RFC2445] for conveying CS related information. 1.1 Formatting Conventions The key words "MUST", "MUST NOT", "REQUIRED", "SHALL", "SHALL NOT", "SHOULD", "SHOULD NOT", "RECOMMENDED", "MAY" and "OPTIONAL" in this document are to be interpreted as described in [RFC2119]. Calendaring and scheduling roles are referred to in quoted-strings of text with the first character of each word in upper case. For example, "Organizer" refers to a role of a "Calendar User" (CU) within the protocol defined by this memo. Calendar components defined by [RFC2445] are referred to with capitalized, quoted-strings of text. All calendar components start with the letter "V". For example, "VEVENT" refers to the event calendar component, "VTODO" refers to the to-do calendar component and "VJOURNAL" refers to the daily journal calendar component. Calendar access methods defined by this memo, as well as scheduling methods defined by [RFC2446], are referred to with capitalized, quoted-strings of text. For example, "CREATE" refers to the method for creating a calendar component on a calendar, "READ" refers to the method for reading calendar components. Properties defined by this memo are referred to with capitalized, quoted-strings of text, followed by the word "property". For example, "ATTENDEE" property refers to the iCalendar property used to convey the calendar address of a "Calendar User". Property parameters defined by this memo are referred to with lower case, quoted-strings of text, followed by the word "parameter". For example, "value" parameter refers to the iCalendar property parameter used to override the default data type for a property value. Enumerated values defined by this memo are referred to with capitalized text, either alone or followed by the word "value". In tables, the quoted-string text is specified without quotes in Mansour/Dawson/Royer/Taler/Hill Expires: April 2000 3 Internet Draft CAP October 22, 1999 order to minimize the table length. 1.2 Related Documents Implementers will need to be familiar with several other memos that, along with this one, describe the Internet calendaring and scheduling standards. This document, [RFC2445] specifies the objects, data types, properties and property parameters used in the protocols, along with the methods for representing and encoding them; [RFC2446] specifies an interoperability protocol for scheduling between different implementations. The related documents are: [RFC2447] specifies an Internet email binding for [RFC2446]. [iRIP] specifies a real-time binding for [RFC2446]. This memo does not attempt to repeat the specification of concepts or definitions from these other memos. Where possible, references are made to the memo that provides for the specification of these concepts or definitions. 1.3 Definitions Authentication ID (AuthID) A tuple of username, realm, and authentication method, used by the Calendar Service internally to identify a successfully authenticated CAP session. Calendar A collection of logically related objects or entities each of which may be associated with a calendar date and possibly time of day. These entities can include other calendar properties or calendar components. In addition, a calendar might be hierarchically related to other sub-calendars. A calendar is identified by its unique calendar identifier. The [RFC2445] defines calendar properties, calendar components and component properties that make up the content of a calendar. Calendar Access Protocol (CAP) The standard Internet protocol that permits a Calendar User Agent to access and manipulate a calendar residing on a Calendar Store. Calendar Access Rights (CAR) The mechanism for specifying the CAP operations ("ACTIONS") that a particular calendar user ("UPN") are granted or denied permission to perform on a given calendar entity ("OBJECT"). The calendar access rights are specified with the "VCAR" Mansour/Dawson/Royer/Taler/Hill Expires: April 2000 4 Internet Draft CAP October 22, 1999 calendar components within a CS and calendar. Calendar Component An entity within a calendar. Some types of calendar components include events, to-dos, journals, alarms, time zones and freebusy data. A calendar component consists of component properties and possibly other sub-components. For example, an event may contain an alarm component. Calendar Component Properties An attribute of a particular calendar component. Some calendar component properties are applicable to different types of calendar components. For example, DTSTART is applicable to VEVENT, VTODO, VJOURNAL calendar components. Other calendar components are applicable only to an individual type of calendar component. For example, TZURL is only applicable to VTIMEZONE calendar components. Calendar Identifier (CalID) A globally unique identifier associated with a calendar. Calendars reside within a CS. See Qualified Calendar Identifier and Relative Calendar Identifier. Calendar Policy A CAP operational restriction on the access or manipulation of a calendar. For example, "events MUST be scheduled in unit intervals of one hour". Calendar Properties An attribute of a calendar. The attribute applies to the calendar, as a whole. For example, CALSCALE specifies the calendar scale (e.g., GREGORIAN) for the whole calendar. Calendar Service An implementation of a Calendar Store that manages one or more calendars. Calendar Store (CS) The data and service model definition for a Calendar Service. Calendar Store Identifier (CSID) The globally unique identifier for an individual CS. A CSID consists of the host and port portions of a "Common Internet Scheme Syntax" part of a URL, as defined by [RFC2396]. Calendar Store Components Components maintained in a CS specify a grouping of calendar store-wide information. Calendar store components can be accessed using CAP. Calendar Store Properties Properties maintained in a Calendar Store calendar store-wide information. Calendar store properties can be accessed using CAP. Mansour/Dawson/Royer/Taler/Hill Expires: April 2000 5 Internet Draft CAP October 22, 1999 Calendar User (CU) An entity (often biological) that uses a calendaring system. Calendar User Agent (CUA) The CUA is the client application that a CU utilizes to access and manipulate a calendar. Calendaring and Scheduling System The computer sub-system that provides the services for accessing, manipulating calendars and scheduling calendar components. CAP Session An open communication channel between a CAP CUA and a CAP CS. Connected Mode A mobile computing mode where the CUA is directly connected to the CS. Delegate Is a calendar user (sometimes called the delegatee) who has been assigned participation in a scheduled calendar component (e.g., VEVENT) by one of the attendees in the scheduled calendar component (sometimes called the delegator). An example of a delegate is a team member told to go to a particular meeting. Designate Is a calendar user who is authorized to act on behalf of another calendar user. An example of a designate is an assistant. Disconnected Mode A mobile computing mode where a CUA can be disconnected from a CS. When the CUA is disconnected, it is in the disconnected mode. Fan Out The calendaring and scheduling process by which a calendar operation on one calendar is also performed on every other calendar specified in the operation. This may include the calendar associated with TARGET calendar property. Hierarchical Calendars A CS feature where a calendar have a hierarchical relationship with another calendar in the CS. The top- most calendar in the hierarchical relationship has the CS as its parent. There may be multiple top-most calendars in a given CS. Within a given hierarchical relationship, all sub-calendars have a calendar with a "parent" topographical relationship. In addition, sub-calendars may have a relationship with another calendar that has a "child" topographical relationship. In addition, a calendar may have a relationship such that one or more calendars have a "sibling" topographical relationship with the calendar. The hierarchical calendar feature is not a storage relationship of the calendars within the CS. Instead it is a feature that relates access control rights to calendar content between different calendars in the CS. Mansour/Dawson/Royer/Taler/Hill Expires: April 2000 6 Internet Draft CAP October 22, 1999 The hierarchical relationship of a calendar is specified in the "PARENT" and "CHILDREN" calendar properties. High Bandwidth Connection A communications connection supporting high transfer rates; transfer rates commonly found within a LAN. Local Store A CS which is on the same platform as the CUA. Low Bandwidth Connection A communications connection supporting slow transfer rates; transfer rates commonly found in remote access technology. Overlapped Booking A policy which indicates whether or not OPAQUE events can overlap one another. When the policy is applied to a calendar it indicates whether or not any OPAQUE events in the calendar can overlap. When applied to an individual event, it indicates whether or not it can be overlapped by any other OPAQUE event. Owner A CU or CUs that have "OWNER" calendar access rights for a calendar. The owner is specified in the "OWNER" calendar property. Qualified Calendar Identifier (Qualified CalID) A CalID where both the <scheme> and <csid> are present. Realm A collection of calendar user accounts, identified by a string. The name of the realm is only used in UPNs. In order to avoid namespace conflict, the realm SHOULD be postfixed with an appropriate DNS domain name. (eg: the foobar realm could be called foobar.example.com). Relative Calendar Identifier (Relative CalID) An identifier for an individual calendar in a calendar store. It is unique within a calendar store. It is recommended to be globally unique. A Relative CalID consists of the portion of the "scheme part" of a Qualified CalID following the Calendar Store Identifier. This is the same as the "URL path" of the "Common Internet Scheme Syntax" portion of a URL, as defined by [RFC2396]. Remote Store A CS which is not on the same platform as the CUA. Session Identity A UPN associated with a CAP session. A session gains an identity after successful authentication. The identity is used in combination with CAR to determine access to data in the CS. Sub-calendars Calendars that have a "child" hierarchical relationship with another calendar, its "parent". Mansour/Dawson/Royer/Taler/Hill Expires: April 2000 7 Internet Draft CAP October 22, 1999 User Name A name which denotes a Calendar User within a realm. This is part of a UPN. User Principal Name (UPN) An identifier that denotes a unique CU. A UPN strongly resembles an RFC 822 style email address and in some cases it may be identical to the email address for the CU. It consists of a realm in the form of a DNS domain name and a username. It may also have an optional instance. In it's simplest form it looks like "user@example.com". 2. CAP Design 2.1 System Model The system model describes the high level components of a calendar system and how they interact with each other. CAP is used by a "Calendar User Agent" (CUA) to send commands to and receive responses from a "Calendar Service" (CS). The CUA prepares an MIME encapsulated iCalendar object containing a command, sends it to the CS, and receives an iCalendar object as a response. There are two distinct protocols in operation to accomplish this exchange. The Transport Protocol is used to move iCalendar objects between a CUA and a CS. The Application Protocol defines the content and semantics of the iCalendar objects sent between the CUA and the CS. This document defines both the Transport Protocol and the Application Protocol. In the diagram below, a user uses CUA1 to communicate with CS1 using CAP. The CUA must authenticate the Calendar User (CU) so that access to calendars on CS1 can be controlled. The CUA can then view, create, edit, and delete calendars, calendar properties, and calendar components subject to the access rights. CAP servers support fanout. Fanout allows a CUA to communicate with a single CS to perform scheduling operations with calendars on multiple CSs. That is, a Calendar User (CU) can book events on or read events from calendars on other calendar stores. To accomplish this, a CAP server has several options: ? CS1 MAY play the role of a CUA and use CAP to access CS2; ? CS1 MAY be able to play the role of a CUA and use [iRIP] to interoperate with the possible iRIP support in CS2; ? CS1 MUST be able play the role of a CUA and use [RFC2447] to interoperate with other CUAs. ? Storage Agent Mansour/Dawson/Royer/Taler/Hill Expires: April 2000 8 Internet Draft CAP October 22, 1999 +-----+ +-----+ | | CAP | | CAP CUA1 ------| CS1 |-----------| CS2 |--------- CUA2 | | | | A | | | | | | | | | | +-----+ +-----+ | | IMIP | +---------------------------------+ Note that the fanout feature in CAP is a convenience to the CUA. It is perfectly valid for the CUA to assume the responsibility for fanout if it wishes. That is, [RFC2447] messages could also be sent from CUA1 to CUA2. 2.2 Calendar Store Object Model The conceptual model for a calendar store is shown below. The calendar store contains calendars, VTIMEZONEs, VCARs, and calendar store properties. Calendars contain VEVENTs, VTODOs, VJOURNALs, VALARMs, VCARs, and calendar properties. Calendars may also contain other calendars. +---------Calendar Store-----------------------------+ | | | | | VCARs | | +--calendars-------------------------+ | | Properties | | | | | +--calendars--------+ VEVENTs | | | VTIMEZONEs | | | VTODOs | | | | | VEVENTs | VJOURNALs | | | | | VCARs | VALARMs | | | | | +---+ VTODOs | VCARs | | | | | | | VALARMs | Calendar | | | | | +---+ VJOURNALs | Properties | | | | | VTIMEZONEs | VTIMEZONEs | | | | | Calendar | VSCHEDULE | | | | | Properties | | | | | | VSCHEDULE | | | | | +-------------------+ | | | +------------------------------------+ | +----------------------------------------------------+ Calendars within a Calendar Store are identified by their Relative CALID. Mansour/Dawson/Royer/Taler/Hill Expires: April 2000 9 Internet Draft CAP October 22, 1999 In this model, VSCHEDULE is a queue of scheduling messages that have not yet been applied to the calendar. Items in VSCHEDULE are discussed in more detail below. 2.3 Protocol Model A generic transport, Calendar Server Transport Protocol (CSTP), is used to move data objects between a CUA and the CS. CSTP commands are listed below and their usage and semantics are defined in section 7 of this document. CSTP Commands ----------------------------------------------------------------------- Command Description ------------ -------------------------------------------------------- ABORT Stop a command whose latency time has been exceeded. AUTHENTICATE Authenticate a UPN. CONTINUE Continue the execution of a command whose latency time has been exceeded. IDENTIFY Set a new identity for calendar access. DISCONNECT Terminate a connection with the server. SENDDATA Send a data object MIME encapsulated iCalendar. STARTTLS Negotiate transport level security using [TLS] Application-level commands are used to manipulate data on the calendar store. They are listed below and discussed in detail in section 7. CAP Calendaring Commands ----------------------------------------------------------------------- Command Description ------------ -------------------------------------------------------- CREATE Create a new calendar or component DELETE Delete a calendar or component GENERATEUID Generate one or more unique ids MODIFY Change a calendar or component MOVE Move a calendar READ Read a calendar properties or components CAP Scheduling Commands ----------------------------------------------------------------------- Command Description ------------ -------------------------------------------------------- PUBLISH publish a calendar entry to one or more calendars REQUEST schedule a calendar entry with one or more calendars REPLY response to a scheduling request ADD add one or more instances to an existing calendar entry Mansour/Dawson/Royer/Taler/Hill Expires: April 2000 10 Internet Draft CAP October 22, 1999 CANCEL cancel one or more instances to an existing calendar entry REFRESH a request for the latest version of a calendar entry COUNTER a request for a change (a counter-proposal) to a calendar entry DECLINECOUNTER decline a counter proposal 2.4 Roles CAP defines methods for managing [RFC2445] objects on a Calendar Store and exchanging [RFC2445] objects for the purposes of group calendaring and scheduling between "Calendar Users" (CUs). There are two distinct roles taken on by CUs in CAP. The CU who creates an initial event or to-do and invites other CUs as attendees takes on the role of "Organizer". The CUs asked to participate in the group event or to-do take on the role of "Attendee". Note that "role" is also a descriptive parameter to the "ATTENDEE" property. Its use is to convey descriptive context to an "Attendee" such as "chair", "REQ- PARTICIPANT" or NON- PARTICIPANT" and has nothing to do with the scheduling workflow. 2.5 Calendar User A Calendar User (CU) is an entity that can be authenticated. It is represented in CAP as a UPN. A UPN is the owner of a calendar and the subject of access rights. Examples: user@example.com user/cap@example.com The UPN representation is independent of the authentication mechanism used during a particular CUA / CS interaction. A CU may use one mechanism while using one CUA but the same user may use a different authentication mechanism when using a different CUA, or while connecting from a different location. For Calendaring and Scheduling systems that are integrated with a directory system the UPN SHOULD be stored in the attribute [TBD] with OID [TBD]. This enables a clear mapping between a UPN and a Distinguished Name. [note: Microsoft's Active Directory is storing UPNs as the userPrincipalName.] Within a directory service a UPN is a single valued property. 2.5.1 UPNs and Certificates When using certificates for purposes of CAP authentication, the Mansour/Dawson/Royer/Taler/Hill Expires: April 2000 11 Internet Draft CAP October 22, 1999 SubjectName field of the user's certificate SHOULD contain the user's UPN (for example, "juser@example.com") as the value of the "CN=" component, and the user's email address (often the same as the UPN) as the value of the "E=" component . The altSubjectName will contain the DN of the user's account object in the DS. The Issuer field must be that of a root CA trusted to issue login certificates, or the DN of a lower level CA whose certificate includes an "AuthorizedNamingContext" field that authorizes it to issue certificates for "example.com" (exact field name and validation mechanism TBD). Note: If a server is validating data received via iMIP, if the "ORGANIZER" or "ATTENDEE" property said (e.g.) "ATTENDEE;CN=Joe Random User:juser@example.com" then the "juser@example.com" part should be checked against the altSubjectName field of the certificate, and the "Joe Random User" part should be checked against the CN component of the altSubjectName DN. This is so the "ATTENDEE" property couldn't be munged to something misleading like "ATTENDEE;CN=Joe Rictus User:juser@example.com" and have it pass validation. This validation will also defeat other attempts at confusion. 2.5.2 CAP session identity A CAP session has an assocatied set of authentication credentials, from which is derived a UPN. This UPN is the identity of the CAP session, and is used to determine access rights for the session. The CUA may change the identity of a CAP session by calling the "IDENTIFY" command. The Calendar Service only permits the operation if the session's authentication credentials are good for the requested identity. The method of checking this permission is implementation dependant, but may be thought of as a mapping from authentication credentials to UPNs. The "IDENTIFY" command allows a single set of authentication credentials to choose from multiple identities, and allows multiple sets of authentication credentials to assume the same identity. For anonymous access the identity of the session is "@", a UPN with a null username and null realm. A UPN with a null username, but non- null realm, such as "@foo.com" may be used to mean any identity from that realm, which is useful to grant access rights to all users in a given realm. A UPN with a non-null username and null realm, such as "bob@" could be a security risk and must not be used. Since the UPN includes realm information it may be used to govern calendar store access rights across realms. However, governing access Mansour/Dawson/Royer/Taler/Hill Expires: April 2000 12 Internet Draft CAP October 22, 1999 rights across realms is only useful if login access is available. This could be done through a trusted server relationship or a temporary account. The "IDENTIFY" command provides for a weak group implementation. By allowing multiple sets of authentication credentials belonging to different users to identify as the same UPN, that UPN essentially identifies a group of people, and may be used for group calendar ownership, or the granting of access rights to a group. 2.6 Calendar Addresses Calendar addresses are URIs that are modeled after [RFC2396]. CAP uses the following forms of URI. [[<scheme>]://<csid>[:<port>]/]<relativeCALID> where: ? <scheme> is "cap" ? <csid> is the Calendar Store ID. It is the network address of the computer on which the CAP server is running ? <port> is optional. Its default value is 5229. The port must be present if the CAP server does not listen on the default port. ? <relativeCALID> is an identifier that uniquely identifies the calendar on a particular calendar store. There is no implied structure in a Relative CALID. It is an arbitrary string of 7 bit ASCII characters. It may refer to the calendar of a user or of a resource such as a conference room. It MUST be unique within the calendar store. It is recommended that the Relative CALID be globally unique. If the <scheme> and <csid> are present the calendar address is said to be "qualified". Senders are required to supply the <relativeCALID> portion of the address. A qualified calendar address is required when the <csid> of the target calendar address differs from that of the CAP server receiving the command. Examples: cap://calendar.example.com/user1 ://calendar.example.com/user1 user1 cap://calendar.example.com/conferenceRoomA cap://calendar.example.com/89798-098-zytytasd For a user currently authenticated to a CAP server on calendar.example.com, the first three addresses refer to the same Mansour/Dawson/Royer/Taler/Hill Expires: April 2000 13 Internet Draft CAP October 22, 1999 calendar. 2.7 Finding CAP Servers 2.7.1 Using DNS <TBD> 2.7.2 Using SLP This section assumes that the reader is familiar with RFC2608 and RFC2609. The Service Location Protocol (SLP) as defined in [RFC2608]: "The Service Location Protocol provides a scalable framework for the discovery and selection of network services. Using this protocol, computers using the Internet need little or no static configuration of network services for network based applications. This is especially important as computers become more portable, and users less tolerant or able to fulfill the demands of network system administration." Each service defines itself so that client applications may locate the service using predefined parameters that apply to that specific service. Below are the definitions for the CAP "Service Template" as defined in [RFC2609]. Name of submitter: "Doug Royer" <Doug.Royer@Software.com> Language of service template: en Security Considerations: <TBD> Template Text: ------------------------template begins here------------------- template-type=Calendar-Access-Protocol # The version will be updated to 1.0 as CAP becomes an RFC. template-version=0.0 template-description= The Calendar-Access-Protocol service provides the location of iCalendar services. # Services can be located or defined with one or more # of the following parameters: # # <port> Port number CAP service is listening to. # # <calendar> Find calendar by calendar name. Mansour/Dawson/Royer/Taler/Hill Expires: April 2000 14 Internet Draft CAP October 22, 1999 # # <user> User name associated with the service. # Aids in locating a calendar or calendars # associated with a user name <string>. # # <scheme> CAP is the only SCHEME supported # # <email> Find calendars associated with an # email address. # # <upn> Find calendars associated with a UPN. # template-url-syntax= url-options = url-port / url-calendar / url-user / url-scheme / url-email / url-upn # The port number(s) the CAP server listens on. url-port = "ports=" ports-list ports-list = port / port "," ports-list port = 1*DIGIT # The CalID for the calendar. url-calendar = "CalID=" calid-list calid-list = CalID / CalID "," CalID # A user associated with a calendar user. url-user = "user=" user-list user-list = user / user "," user-list user = # A CU as defined by # the CS implementation, # Which URL-scheme's are supported by the CS: url-scheme = "scheme=" scheme-list scheme-list = scheme / scheme "," scheme-list scheme = CAP # Only CAP supported at # this time. # Names of calendars associated with an email address. url-email = "mailto=" email-list email-list = email / email "," email-list email = # An RFC822 email address # Names of calendars associated with a UPN. url-upn = "mailto=" upn-list upn-list = upn / upn "," upn-list upn = # An RFC822 upn address Mansour/Dawson/Royer/Taler/Hill Expires: April 2000 15 Internet Draft CAP October 22, 1999 -------------------------template ends here--------------------- Example of SLP advertisement: URL = service:Calendar-Access-Protocol://cal.example.com/ports=1234 Attributes = (location-description=Net iCal server1), (CalID=Doug.Royer,Steve.Mansour,Conference-RM1), (user="Doug Royer", "Steve Mansour", "Conference Room 1"), (scheme=CAP), (email="Doug.Royer@Software.com","Doug@Royer.com","droyer@software.com, "sman@netscape.com","ConfRoom1@example.com"), (upn=droyer@software.com,sman@netscape.com), (template-url-syntax=\0D url-options = url-port / url-calendar / url-user \0D / url-scheme / url-email / url-upn \0D url-port = "ports=" ports-list \0D ports-list = port / port "," ports-list \0D port = 1*DIGIT \0D url-calendar = "CalID=" calid-list \0D calid-list = CalID / CalID "," CalID \0D url-user = "user=" user-list \0D user-list = user / user "," user-list \0D url-scheme = "scheme=" scheme-list \0D scheme-list = scheme / scheme "," scheme-list \0D scheme = CAP \0D url-email = "mailto=" email-list \0D email-list = email / email "," email-list \0D url-upn = "mailto=" upn-list \0D upn-list = upn / upn "," upn-list\0D) 2.8 Extensions to iCalendar In mapping the CAP command set, query feature, and access rights onto the iCalendar format, several extended iCalendar methods and components are defined by this memo. * The search function is specified with the new iCalendar QUERY method. The QUERY method makes use of a new component, called VQUERY, that contains the search filter. The component consists of a set of new properties: SCOPE, MAXRESULTS, MAXRESULTSSIZE, QUERY and QUERYNAME, that define the search filter. * Access control is specified the the new iCalendar VCAR component. * The iCalendar METHOD property format has been updated with new Mansour/Dawson/Royer/Taler/Hill Expires: April 2000 16 Internet Draft CAP October 22, 1999 values. * A new iCalendar component, VCOMMAND, has been added. VCOMMANDs are needed to fully specify CAP commands. * TARGET is a new property within the VCOMMAND component. It indicates the calendars to which the command applies 2.9 Relationship of RFC 2446 (ITIP) to CAP [RFC2446] describes scheduling methods which result in indirect manipulation of calendar components. CAP methods provide direct manipuation of calendar components. In the CAP calendar store model, scheduling messages are kept separate from other calendar components. This is modeled with the VSCHEDULE queue. Note that this is a conceptual model, the actual storage details are left to implementations. The model is shown pictorially as follows: +-----------------VCALENDAR-------------------+ | | | +-----------+ +-------VSCHEDULE---------+ | | | VEVENTs | | PUBLISH messages | | | | VTODOs | | REQUEST messages | | | | VJOURNALs | | REPLY messages | | | | | | ADD messages | | | | | | CANCEL messages | | | | | | REFRESH messages | | | | | | COUNTER messages | | | | | | DECLINECOUNTER messages | | | +-----------+ +-------------------------+ | +---------------------------------------------+ The METHOD is saved along with components. Scheduled components become booked components when the METHOD changes from an ITIP method to the CAP storage method. For example, a component whose METHOD is "REQUEST" is scheduled. The component becomes booked when the METHOD is changed to "CREATED". [ed note: need to clean up the terminology here. We havent discussed "booked"] 2.10 VCalendar Access Rights (VCARs) In simple terms, VCARs are used to grant or deny access to a calendar for a Calendar User. Specifically, they grant User Principal Names (UPNs) the rights to read and write components, properties, and parameters on calendars within a calendar store. Mansour/Dawson/Royer/Taler/Hill Expires: April 2000 17 Internet Draft CAP October 22, 1999 The model does not put any restriction on the sequence in which the object and access rights are created. That is, an event associated with a particular VCAR might be created before or after the actual VCAR is defined. In addition, the VCAR and VEVENT definition might be created in the same iCalendar object and passed together in a single SENDDATA command. 2.11 Query Schema 3. State Diagram This section describes the states of the transport connection between a CUA and a CS. The state diagram is shown below. State names shown with first letter capitalized. The commands used to switch between states are shown next to an arrow connecting the states. The commands are listed in all capital letters. A condition that causes a state to change is shown in lower case letters. STARTTLS / CAPABILITY +-------+ | | +---------------+ | +-----------+ AUTHENTICATE | | +-->| Connected |-------------->| Authenticated | +-----------+ | | | +---------------+ | | | | | | | | +-----+ STARTTLS / | V | | CAPABILITY / | +---------------+ | IDENTIFY | | |<-+ | | Identified |<----+ | +--------| | | | | +---------------+ | command | | | | completes V |DISCONNECT | | +--------------+ | |SENDDATA | | Disconnected |<--+ | | +--------------+ | | ABORT A | | | V | | DISCONNECT +---------------+ | +--------------------| Receive |--------+ | |<--+ Mansour/Dawson/Royer/Taler/Hill Expires: April 2000 18 Internet Draft CAP October 22, 1999 +---------------+ | | | CONTINUTE +----+ The connection begins the Connected state when a CUA connects to a CAP server. The capabilities of the CS are reported in the response from the CS. From this state, the CUA can issue the DISCONNECT command to terminate the connection, the CAPABILITY, STARTTLS, or AUTHENTICATE commands. One use of the CAPABILITY command at this stage is to determine the supported authentication mechanisms supported by the server. Once the STARTTLS command has been successfully executed from either the Connected or Authenticated state, it must not be executed again. If an AUTHENTICATE command is successful, the connection enters the Authenticated state and then immediately goes to the IDENTIFIED state. From here the CUA can issue the CAPABILITY command. The capabilities the server offers in the Authenticated state may be different than those in the Connected state. The CUA can also use the IDENTIFY command to change the identity of the user subject to access control. The connection remains in the Authenticated state after the CAPABILITY command completes. The CUA can issue the DISCONNECT command to terminate the connection. The SENDDATA command can be used to send a request to read, write, modify, or delete data on the server. After the SENDDATA command has been issued the connection enters the Receive state while the CUA awaits and reads a server reply. Normally, the server handles the command, sends a reply which is read by the CUA and the connection returns to the Authenticated state. The CUA may have issued the SENDATA command with a maximum latency time. This informs the server that the CUA expects a response within the maximum latency time, even if the command was not completed. When the server is unable to complete the command in the maximum latency time, it issues an appropriate reply code and waits for the CUA to tell it how to proceed. If the CUA issues a CONTINUE command the server continues processing the command and the connection remains in the Receive state. If the CUA issues the ABORT command the server need not process the command any further and the connection returns to the Authenticated state. The DISCONNECT command can also be issued from the Receive state. 4. Protocol Framework 4.1 CAP Application Layer The CAP application layer is used for the manipulation of the calendar store. Commands and responses are transmitted between the CUA and CS inside "VCALENDAR" component wrappers. Commands are specified as the Mansour/Dawson/Royer/Taler/Hill Expires: April 2000 19 Internet Draft CAP October 22, 1999 value of a "METHOD" property, and responses are specified as the value of a "REQUEST-STATUS" property. 4.2 CAP Transport Layer The CAP transport layer handles the transmission of CAP application layer messages. CAP transport layer commands are transmitted across the underlying transport. The transport used is a TCP/IP socket connection between the CUA and the CS. The CS listens for connections on port <xyz>. Messages sent between the CUA and CS are formatted as a command followed by any associated data: <command> [<command data>] 4.3 Response Format Server responses consist of a response code and any parameters: <response code> [; debug text ; more text] [<CRLF><application-data>]<CRLF>.CRLF> The response codes are defined in Section 8. The debug text is human- readable information for protocol debugging. The optional application-data begins on the next line. The response is terminated with a <CRLF> "." <CRLF> sequence. Any <CRLF> "." sequences which appear in the transmitted data must be quoted by placing an additional "." between the <CRLF> and the ".". For example, the following sequences of characters in the application data: are quoted as follows: No other tagged command sequence can be sent until the special terminating character sequence <CRLF>.<CRLF> has been sent. 4.4 Auto-logout Timer If a server has an inactivity auto-logout timer, that timer MUST be of at least 15 minutes duration. The receipt of ANY command from the client during that interval MUST suffice to reset the auto-logout timer. Mansour/Dawson/Royer/Taler/Hill Expires: April 2000 20 Internet Draft CAP October 22, 1999 When a timeout occurs, the server drops the connection to the CUA. 4.5 Bounded Latency [CAP] is designed so that the CUA can either obtain an immediate response from a request or discover within a specified amount of time that the request could not be completed in the requested amount of time. When the CUA initiates a command that the server cannot complete within the specified latency time, the server returns an appropriate response code. The CUA then issues either a CONTINUE or ABORT command. The ABORT command immediately terminates the command in progress and the connection returns to the Authenticated state. The CONTINUE command instructs the server to continue processing the command. 4.6 Data Elements The data elements for CAP are MIME encapsulated iCalendar objects. 5. Formal Command Syntax 5.1 Searching and Filtering This section describes CAPs searching and filtering entities within a remote store. It is based on the Standard Query Language (SQL) defined by [SQL]. The QUERY property value MUST be a valid QUERY value type. This new value type is defined to be a "name=value" value type grammar, similar in syntax to the format already in use for the iCalendar RECUR value type. Each "name" is the name of a valid SQL statement component (e.g., SELECT, WHERE, etc.). Each "value" is valid string associated with one of these SQL statement components. [Editor's note: We need to precisely define what part of SQL were using and why we chose what we did.] Examples needed: Grant someone access to June events Grant someone access to events during the month of June. (i.e., based on the current system date, if it's prior to June or after June you don't have access) Example for denying access to a specific property: DENY:UPN=FOO;ACTION=*;OBJECT=CLASS *scope vcar to a component Mansour/Dawson/Royer/Taler/Hill Expires: April 2000 21 Internet Draft CAP October 22, 1999 *scope Grant, Deny of a VCAR 5.1.1 Grammar For Search Mechanism SEARCH = "BEGIN:VQUERY" CRLF [scope] [maxresults] [maxsize] querycomp "END:VQUERY" CRLF scope = "SCOPE:" comp-name ("," comp-name)* comp-name = "VEVENT" / "VTODO" / "VJOURNAL" / "VTIMEZONE" / "VALARM" / "VFREEBUSY" / iana-name / x-name maxresults = integer maxsize = integer querycomp = (query) / (queryname query) / queryname queryname = "QUERYNAME:" text query = "QUERY:" queryrule queryrule = select where orderby ... select = <any valid SQL string that goes into a SELECT clause> where = <any valid SQL string that goes into a WHERE clause> orderby = <any valid SQL string that goes into a ORDERBY clause> 6. Access Rights Access rights within CAP are specified with the "VCAR" calendar component, "RIGHTS" value type and the "GRANT", "DENY" and "CARID" component properties. Individual calendar access rights MUST be specifically granted to an authenticated calendar user (i.e., UPN); all rights are denied unless specifically granted. Properties within an iCalendar object are unordered. This also is the case for the "GRANT", "DENY" and "CARID" properties. Likewise, there is no implied ordering required for components of a "RIGHTS" value type other than that specified by the ABNF. Mansour/Dawson/Royer/Taler/Hill Expires: April 2000 22 Internet Draft CAP October 22, 1999 6.1 VCAR Inheritance Calendar access rights specified in a calendar store are inherited as default calendar access rights for any calendar in the parent calendar store. Likewise, any calendar access rights specified in a root calendar are inherited as default calendar access rights for any sub- calendar to the root calendar. By implication, calendar access rights specified in a sub-calendar are inherited as default calendar access rights for any calendars that are hierarchically below the sub- calendar. Calendar access rights specified in a calendar override any default calendar access rights. Calendar access rights specified within a sub- calendar override any default calendar access rights. 6.2 Access Control and NOCONFLICT The TRANSP property can take on values (TRANSPARENT-NOCONFLICT, OPAQUE- NOCONFLICT) that prohibit other events from overlapping it. This setting overrides access While access control may allow a UPN to store an event on a particular calendar. , the CONFLICTS Calendar or component setting may prevent it, returning an error code "6.3" 7. Commands and Responses CAP commands and responses are described in this section. Command arguments, identified by "Arguments:" in the command descriptions below, are described by function, not by syntax. The precise syntax of command arguments is described in the Formal Syntax section. Some commands cause specific server data to be returned; these are identified by "Data:" in the command descriptions below. See the response descriptions in the Responses section for information on these responses, and the Formal Syntax section for the precise syntax of these responses. The "Result:" in the command description refers to the possible status responses to a command, and any special interpretation of these status responses. Commands have the general form: <command> [arguments...] where <command> is a command listed in the table above. A command MAY Mansour/Dawson/Royer/Taler/Hill Expires: April 2000 23 Internet Draft CAP October 22, 1999 have arguments. Arguments are defined in the detailed command definitions below. Responses to commands have the following general form: responseCode [sep transportDescr sep [applicationDescr]] CRLF "." CRLF In the examples below, lines preceded with "S:" refer to the sender and lines preceded with "R:" refer to the receiver. Lines in which the first non-whitespace character is a "#" are editorial comments and are not part of the protocol. 7.1 Transport Protocol Commands 7.1.1 Initial Connection Arguments: none Data: none Result: 2.0 - success. 8.1 - server too busy Upon session startup, the server sends a response of 2.0 to indicate that it is ready to receive commands. A response of 8.1 indicates that the server is too busy to accept the connection. In addition, the general capabilities of the CS are reported in the response from the CS. These capabilities may be different than those reported in the authenticated state. The supported authentication mechanisms. There may be 1 or more. CAPVERSION IRIPVERSION 7.1.2 ABORT Command Arguments: none Data: none Result: 2.0 - success 2.2 - no command is in progres The ABORT command is issued by the CUA to stop a command whose Mansour/Dawson/Royer/Taler/Hill Expires: April 2000 24 Internet Draft CAP October 22, 1999 latency time has been exceeded. When the latency time is specified on the SENDATA command, the CS must issue a reply to the CUA within the specified time. It may be a reply code indicating that the CS has not yet processed the request. The CUA must then tell the server whether to continue or abort. The CUA can issue the ABORT command at any time after the SENDATA command has been completed but before receiving a reply. 7.1.3 AUTHENTICATE Command Arguments: <SASL mechanism name> [<initial data>] Data: continuation data may be requested Result: 2.0 - Authenticate completed, now in authenticated state 6.0 - Failed authentication 6.1 - Authorization identity refused. 6.2 - Sender aborted authentication, authentication exchange cancelled 6.3 - Unsupported Authentication Mechanism 9.1 - Unexpected command. The capabilities of the CS in the authenticated state are reported in the response from the CS. These may be different than the capabilities in the Connected, but unauthenticated state. The AUTHENTICATE command is used by the CUA to identify the user to the CS. CAP uses the [SASL] specification for authentication. The desired SASL mechanism is specified as the initial argument. <SASL mechanism name> is a registered SASL authentication mechanism. (Refer to [SASL] for information on obtaining a list of currently registered mechanisms.) CS Supported authentication mechanisms can be discovered using the CAPABILITY command. All implementations MUST support Digest-MD5 authentication using DES and 3DES, as well as DES-56 for link level encryption. Implementations MUST support the SASL Anonymous mechanism, although this may be disabled in installations. Implementations SHOULD implement the External SASL mechanism and the command STARTTLS. <initial data> is an optional parameter which can be used for mechanisms which require an initial response from the CUA. The AUTHENTICATE command is followed by an authentication protocol exchange, in the form of a series of CS challenges and CUA responses. These challenges and responses are encoded in Base64 and transmitted Mansour/Dawson/Royer/Taler/Hill Expires: April 2000 25 Internet Draft CAP October 22, 1999 with a terminating CRLF. The CS terminates the exchange with a "." <CRLF> sequence followed by a reply code. ("." is not a legal Base64 character.) Possible reply codes are listed above. CAP does not provide support for SASL authorization identities. If a CUA attempts to use an authorization identity the Calendar Service must return the reply code indicating that the authorization identity was refused. If the CUA wishes to cancel an authentication exchange it may do so by issuing a "." <CRLF> sequence. Upon receipt of such a sequence the CS MUST terminate the exchange and return the appropriate reply code. If a security layer was negotiated it comes into effect for the CS starting with the first octet transmitted after the CRLF which follows the 2.0 reply code, and for the CUA starting with the first octet after the CRLF of its last response in the authentication exchange. Encrypted data is transmitted as described in [SASL]. The service name specified by this protocol's profile of SASL is "cap". The result of the AUTHENTICATE command includes data indicating the identity which has been assigned to the session, derived from the supplied authentication credentials. A CAP session does not have an identity until the CUA has issued the "AUTHENTCATE" command. The CUA may not issue the "AUTHENTCATE" command multiple times, even if the first attempt was aborted. If a CUA attempts to do this the CS must terminate the session. Data returned in response to a successful logon is: The following examples illustrate the various possiblities for an authentication protocol exchange. Here are examples of a successful authentication: C: AUTHENTICATE KERBEROS_V4 S: AmFYig== C: BAcAQU5EUkVXLkNNVS5FRFUAOCAsho84kLN3/IJmrMG+25a4DT S: or//EoAADZI= C: DiAF5A4gA+oOIALuBkAAmw== S: 2.0 S: Content-Type:text/calendar; method=REQUEST; charset=US-ASCII Mansour/Dawson/Royer/Taler/Hill Expires: April 2000 26 Internet Draft CAP October 22, 1999 S: Content-Transfer-Encoding: 7bit S: S: BEGIN:VCALENDAR S: PRODID:-//ACME/CAPserver//EN S: VERSION:2.1 S: IDENTITY=bill@example.com S: CAPVERSION=1.0 S: ITIPVERSION=1.0 S: AUTH=KERBEROS_V4 S: AUTH=DIGEST_MD5 S: CAR=CAR1 appl S: MINDATE=19700101T000000Z appl S: MAXDATE=20370201T000000Z S: END:VCALENDAR S: . C: AUTHENTICATE ANONYMOUS S: 2.0 S: Content-Type:text/calendar; method=REQUEST; charset=US-ASCII S: Content-Transfer-Encoding: 7bit S: S: BEGIN:VCALENDAR S: PRODID:-//ACME/CAPserver//EN S: VERSION:2.1 S: CAPVERSION=1.0 S: ITIPVERSION=1.0 S: AUTH=KERBEROS_V4 S: AUTH=DIGEST_MD5 S: CAR=CAR1 S: MINDATE=19700101T000000Z S: MAXDATE=20370201T000000Z S: END:VCALENDAR S: . This example shows a failed authentication: C: AUTHENTICATE KERBEROS_V4 S: AmFYig== C: BAcAQU5EUkVXLkNNVS5FRFUAOCAsho84kLN3/IJmrMG+25a4DT S: . S: 6.0 7.1.4 CAPABILITY Command Arguments: none Mansour/Dawson/Royer/Taler/Hill Expires: April 2000 27 Internet Draft CAP October 22, 1999 Data: none Result: capabilities as described below The CAPABILTY command returns information about the CAP server given the current state of the connection with the client. The values returned may differ depending on whether the connection is in the Connected or the Authenticated state. The return values may also be different for a secure versus a non-secure connection. Client implementations SHOULD NOT require any capability name beyond those defined in this specification, and MAY ignore any non-standard, experimental capability names. Non-standard capability names are prefixed with the text "X-". The prefix SHOULD also include a short character vendor identifier For example, "X-FOO-BARCAPABILITY", for the non-standard "BARCAPABILITY" capability of the implementor "FOO". This command may return different results in the Connected state versus the Authenticated state. It may also return different results depending on the UPN. Capability Occurs Description --------------------- ------- ---------------------------------- CAPrev1 1 Revision of CAP, must be "CAPrev1" IRIPrev1 0 or 1 Revision of IRIP, MAY be present. If present, it MUST be "IRIPrev1" CAR 0 or 1 Indicates level of CAR support CAR0, CAR1, CAR2, CAR3 MAXICALOBJECTSIZE 0 or 1 An integer value that specifies The largest ICAL object the server will accept. Objects larger than this will be rejected. MAXDATE 0 or 1 The datetime value beyond which the server cannot accept. MINDATE 0 or 1 The datetime value prior to which the server cannot accept. Example: C: CAPABILTIY S: 2.0 S: CAPVERSION=1.0 Mansour/Dawson/Royer/Taler/Hill Expires: April 2000 28 Internet Draft CAP October 22, 1999 S: ITIPVERSION=1.0 S: AUTH=KERBEROS_V4 S: AUTH=DIGEST_MD5 S: . 7.1.5 CONTINUE Command Arguments: latency time in seconds (optional) Data: none Result: results from the command in progress 2.0.2 - reply pending. The CONTINUE command is issued by the client in response to a SENDATA timeout. When a timeout value is specified on the SENDDATA command, the server must issue a reply to the client within the specified time. If the latency time has elapsed prior to the server completing the command it returns a timeout response code. If the client wants the server to continue processing the command it responds with the CONTINUE command. If latencyTime is present, it must be a positive integer that specifies the maximum number of seconds the client will wait for the next response. If it is omitted, the receiver waits an indefinite period of time for the response. In this example, the client requests a response from the server every 10 seconds. C: SENDDATA:10 C: Content-Type:text/calendar; method=READ; component=VEVENT C: C: BEGIN:VCALENDAR # etc C: END:VCALENDAR C: . # after 10 seconds... S: . S: 2.0.2 C: CONTINUE:10 S: 2.0 S: Content-type:text/calendar; Method=RESPONSE;Component=VDATA; S: Optinfo=VERSION:2.1 S: S: BEGIN:VCALENDAR S: VERSION:2.1 Mansour/Dawson/Royer/Taler/Hill Expires: April 2000 29 Internet Draft CAP October 22, 1999 S: CALID:cap://cal.example.com/relcal2 # etc. S: END:VCALENDAR S: . 7.1.6 DISCONNECT Command Arguments: none Data: Result: 2.0 The DISCONNECT command is used by a client to terminate a connection. It always succeeds. Example: C: DISCONNECT # [ed. Note: should the client now wait for a response from the server # before disconnecting? ] S: 2.0 C: <drops connection> S: <drops connection> 7.1.7 IDENTIFY Command Arguments: Identity to assume Data: None Result: 2.0 6.4 Identity not permitted The "IDENTIFY" command allows the CUA to select a new identity to be used for calendar access. This command may only be called in the Identified State. The CS determines through an internal mechanism if the credentials supplied at authentication permit the assumption of the selected the identity. If they do the session assumes the new identity, otherwise a security error is returned. 7.1.8 SENDDATA Command Mansour/Dawson/Royer/Taler/Hill Expires: April 2000 30 Internet Draft CAP October 22, 1999 Arguments: [latencyTime] Data: a MIME encapsulated iCalendar object Result: 2.0.1 - Server will now accept input until <CRLF>.<CRLF> is encountered. The SENDDATA command is used to send calendar requests and commands to the server. After a response code of 2.0.1 is issued the CUA sends a MIME encapsulated iCalendar object to the server. The end of this MIME data is signaleled by the special sequence <CRLF>.<CRLF> . 7.1.9 STARTTLS Command Arguments: None Data: None Result: 2.0 6.5 TLS not supported The "STARTTLS" command is issued by the CUA to indicate to the CS that it wishes to negotiate transport level security using [TLS]. If the CS does not support TLS it returns status code 6.5. If the CS supports TLS it issues an initial response of 2.0.12 indicating that the CUA should proceed with TLS negotiation. Once the TLS negotiation is complete the server returns the response code 2.0. After issuing the "STARTTLS" command the CUA issues the "AUTHENTICATE" command. The SASL external mechanism may be used if the CUA wishes to use the authentication id which was used in the TLS negotiation. If an authentication id was determined during TLS negotiations it MUST NOT be used for the purpose of granting a CAP session identity unless the CUA authenticates using the SASL external mechanism. The CUA MUST NOT issue a "STARTTLS" if it has already issued an "AUTHENTICATE" or "STARTTLS" command in this session. If a CUA does this the CS must terminate the session. The following examples illustrate the use of the "STARTTLS" command: Unsupported TLS: C: STARTTLS S: 6.5 Supported TLS: Mansour/Dawson/Royer/Taler/Hill Expires: April 2000 31 Internet Draft CAP October 22, 1999 C: STARTTLS S: 2.0.12 <tls negotiation> S: 2.0 7.2 Application Protocol Commands 7.2.1 Calendaring Commands The following methods provide a set of calendaring commands in CAP. Calendaring commands (or methods) allow a CU to directly manipulate a calendar. Calendar access rights can be granted for the more generalized access provided by the calendar commands. 7.2.1.1 CREATE Method Arguments: objtype Data: no specific data for this command Result: 2.0 - successfully created the component or calendar 6.0 - Permission denied 6.1 - Container(s) not found 6.2 - Calendar or component already exists 6.3 - Bad args The CREATE method is used to create a new iCalendar object of type objtype. ContainerId1 through ContainerIdn specify the container(s) for the create. When creating a new calendar at the top level, the CSID is specified. Otherwise the container will be a CalID. 7.2.1.1.1 Creating New Calendars Example to create a new calendar named "Bill's Soccer Team" in several different containers. In the following example, the client is in the Authenticated state with CS cal.example.com. C: SENDDATA C: CONTENT-TYPE: text/calendar;method=CREATE;component=VCOMMAND C: Content-Transfer-Encoding:7bit C: C: BEGIN:VCALENDAR C: VERSION:2.1 C: BEGIN:VCOMMAND Mansour/Dawson/Royer/Taler/Hill Expires: April 2000 32 Internet Draft CAP October 22, 1999 C: METHOD:CREATE;VCALENDAR C: TARGET:cap://cal.example.com/ C: TARGET:relcal4 C: TARGET://bobo.ex.com/ C: TARGET:relcal5 C: TARGET:cap://cal.example.com/relcal8 C: TARGET:relcal9 C: BEGIN:VCALENDAR C: RELCALID:relcalz C: NAME:CHARSET=us-ascii;LANGUAGE=EN-us:Bill's Soccer Team C: OWNER:capcar:bill C: OWNER:capcar:mary C: CALMASTER:mailto:bill@example.com C: PREFERRED-TZID:US_PST C: BEGIN:VCAR C: CARID:12345 C: GRANT;CN="Bill Jones":UPN=capcar:bill;ACTION=ALL;OBJECT=all C: GRANT;CN="Mary Jones":UPN=capcar:mary;ACTION=read;OBJECT=all C: END:VCAR C: END:VCALENDAR C: END:VCOMMAND C: END:VCALENDAR C: . S: 6.0 cap://cal.example.com/ S: 2.0 cap://cal.example.com/relcal4 cap://cal.example.com/relcalz S: 3.1.4 cap://bobo.ex.com/ S: 6.2 cap://cal.example.com/relcal5 S: 3.1.5 cap://cal.example.com/relcal8 S: 7.0 cap://cal.example.com/relcal9 If the example above, the Relative CALID is specified. The values for this property must be unique on a CS. That is the reason for the 3.1.5 error response. In the example below, the Relative CalID is not specified. So, the CAP server will generate one for each calendar successfully created. The value of the Relative CalID appears as the second parameter on the response code. S: 6.0 cap://cal.example.com/ S: 2.0 cap://cal.example.com/relcal4 cap://cal.example.com/rand123 S: 3.1.4 cap://bobo.ex.com/ S: 6.2 cap://cal.example.com/relcal5 S: 3.1.4 cap://cal.example.com/relcal8 S: 2.0 cap://cal.example.com/relcal9 cap://cal.example.com/rand456 Example to create a new component. Mansour/Dawson/Royer/Taler/Hill Expires: April 2000 33 Internet Draft CAP October 22, 1999 C: SENDDATA C: Content-Type:text/calendar; method=CREATE; charset=US-ASCII C: Content-Transfer-Encoding:7bit C: C: BEGIN:VCALENDAR C: VERSION:2.1 C: CMDID:abcde C: METHOD:CREATE C: TARGET:cap://cal.foo.com/relcal1 C: TARGET:relcal2 C: BEGIN:VEVENT C: DTSTART:19990307T180000Z C: UID:abcd12345 C: DTEND:19990307T190000Z C: SUMMARY:Important Meeting C: END:VEVENT C: END:VCALENDAR C: . S: 2.0 S: Content-Type:text/calendar; method=RESPONSE; OPTINFO="CMDID:abcde" S: S: BEGIN:VCALENDAR S: VERSION:2.1 S: CMDID:abcde S: METHOD:RESPONSE S: BEGIN:VEVENT S: REQUEST-STATUS:2.0;cap://cal.foo.com/relcal1 abcd12345 S: REQUEST-STATUS:2.0;cap://cal.foo.com/relcal2 abcd12345 S: END:VEVENT S: END:VCALENDAR [Editors Note: this returns the calendar and UID? Is this right? It could also be UID and RecurrenceID ? what about if the event has an RRULE?] 7.2.1.2 DELETE Method Arguments: ContainerId1 [;...ContainerIdn] Data: no specific data for this command Result: 2.0 - successfully deleted the component or calendar Permission Calendar or component not found Bad args Container(s) not found Mansour/Dawson/Royer/Taler/Hill Expires: April 2000 34 Internet Draft CAP October 22, 1999 The DELETE method is used to delete a calendar or component. ContainerId1 through ContainerIdn specify the container(s) for the delete. When deleting a calendar at the top level, the CSID is specified. Otherwise the container will be a CalID. Example to delete a calendar at the top level: C: SENDDATA C: Content-Type:text/calendar; method=DELETE; component=VCOMMAND C: Content-Transfer-Encoding:7bit C: C: BEGIN:VCALENDAR C: BEGIN:VCOMMAND C: METHOD:DELETE C: TARGET:cap://cal.foo.com/bill C: BEGIN:VQUERY C: SCOPE:VEVENT C: QUERY SELECT="UID" C: WHERE (UID EQ abcd12345) C: END:VQUERY C: END:VCOMMAND C: END:VCALENDAR C: . S: 2.0 cap://cal.foo.com/bill 7.2.1.3 GENERATEUID Method Arguments: number of uids to generate Data: new uids Result: 2.0 GENERATEUID returns one or more new unique identifier which MUST be unique on the servers calendar store. It is recommended that the return value be a globally unique id. Example: C: GENERATEUID 2 S: 2.0 abcde1234567-asdf-lkhh abcde1234567-asdf-3455 7.2.1.4 MODIFY Method Arguments: ContainerId1 [...ContainerIdn] Data: no specific data for this command Mansour/Dawson/Royer/Taler/Hill Expires: April 2000 35 Internet Draft CAP October 22, 1999 Result: 2.0 - successfully modified the component or calendar Permission Calendar or component not found Bad args Container(s) not found The MODIFY method is used to change an existing calendar or component. ContainerId1 through ContainerIdn specify the container(s) of the modification. When modifying a calendar at the top level, the CSID is specified. Otherwise the container will be a CalID. In the example below, the start and end time of the event with UID abcd12345 is changed and the LOCATION property is removed. C: SENDDATA C: Content-type:text/calendar; Method=MODIFY; Component=VCOMMAND C: C: BEGIN:VCALENDAR C: VERSION:2.1 C: METHOD:MODIFY;VEVENT C: TARGET:relcal2 C: BEGIN:VCOMMAND C: BEGIN:VQUERY C: SCOPE:VEVENT C: QUERY SELECT="UID" C: WHERE (UID EQ abcd12345) C: END:VQUERY C: BEGIN:VOLD C: DTSTART:19990421T160000Z C: DTEND:19990421T163000Z C: LOCATION:Joes Diner C: END:VOLD C: BEGIN:VNEW C: DTSTART:19990421T160000Z C: DTEND:19990421T163000Z C: END:VNEW C: END:VCOMMAND C: END:VCALENDAR C: . S: 2.0 cap://cal.example.com/relcal2 7.2.1.5 MOVE Method Arguments: ContainerId Data: data as described below Mansour/Dawson/Royer/Taler/Hill Expires: April 2000 36 Internet Draft CAP October 22, 1999 Result: 2.0 - success 2.2 - will attempt operation on the remote cap server Permission Calendar already exists Bad args Parent Calendar(s) not found This method is used to move a calendar within the CSs hierarchy of calendars. [Editors Note: there could be VCAR issues with this... if a VCARs scope of influence is limited to a calendar, were probably OK. We should discuss this one] 7.2.1.6 READ Method Arguments: ContainerId Data: data as described below Result: 2.0 - successful and the requested data follows 2.2 - will attempt read on the remote cap server Permission Bad args Read Events In the example below events on March 10,1999 between 080000Z and 190000Z are read. In this case only 4 properties for each event are returned. Two calendars are specified. C: SENDDATA C: Content-type:text/calendar; Method=READ; Component=VQUERY C: C: BEGIN:VCALENDAR C: VERSION:2.1 C: METHOD:READ C: CMDID:xyz12345 C: TARGET:relcal2 C: TARGET:cap://bobo.ex.com/relcal3 C: BEGIN:VQUERY C: QUERY:SELECT (DTSTART,DTEND,SUMMARY,UID); C: FROM VEVENT; C: WHERE (DTEND >= 19990310T080000Z AND C: DTSTART <= 19990310T190000Z); C: ORDERBY (DTSTART ASC, DTEND, UID, SUMMARY) C: END:VQUERY Mansour/Dawson/Royer/Taler/Hill Expires: April 2000 37 Internet Draft CAP October 22, 1999 C: END:VCALENDAR C: . S: 2.0 cap://cal.example.com/relcal2 S: Content-type:text/calendar; Method=RESPONSE; S: Optinfo=VERSION:2.1 S: Content-Transfer-Encoding: 7bit S: S: BEGIN:VCALENDAR S: VERSION:2.1 S: METHOD:RESPONSE S: BEGIN:VEVENT S: DTSTART:19990310T090000Z S: DTEND:19990310T100000Z S: UID:abcxyz12345 S: SUMMARY:Meet with Sir Elton S: END:VEVENT S: BEGIN:VEVENT S: DTSTART:19990310T130000Z S: DTEND:19990310T133000Z S: UID:abcxyz8999 S: SUMMARY:Meet with brave brave Sir Robin S: END:VEVENT S: END:VCALENDAR S: . S: 2.0 cap://bobo.ex.com/relcal3 S: Content-type:text/calendar; Method=RESPONSE;Component=VDATA; S: Optinfo=VERSION:2.1 S: Content-Transfer-Encoding: 7bit S: S: BEGIN:VCALENDAR S: VERSION:2.1 S: METHOD:RESPONSE S: BEGIN:VDATA S: BEGIN:VEVENT S: DTSTART:19990310T140000Z S: DTEND:19990310T150000Z S: UID:123456asdf S: SUMMARY:Summer Budget S: END:VEVENT S: END:VDATA S: END:VCALENDAR S: . The return values are subject to VCAR filtering. That is, if the request contains properties to which the UPN does not have access, those properties will not appear in the return values. If the UPN has access to at least one property of events, but has been denied access Mansour/Dawson/Royer/Taler/Hill Expires: April 2000 38 Internet Draft CAP October 22, 1999 to all properties called out in the request, the response will contain a single RESPONSE-CODE property indicating the error. That is, the VEVENT components will be the following: S: 2.0 cap://bobo.ex.com/sally S: Content-type:text/calendar; Method=RESPONSE;Component=VDATA; S: Optinfo=VERSION:2.1 S: Content-Transfer-Encoding: 7bit S: S: BEGIN:VCALENDAR S: VERSION:2.1 S: BEGIN:VDATA S: BEGIN:VEVENT S: RESPONSE-CODE:3.8 S: END:VEVENT S: END:VDATA S: END:VCALENDAR S: . If the UPN has no access to any events at all, the response will simply be an empty data set. The response looks the same if there are particular events to which the requester has been denied access. S: 2.0 cap://bobo.ex.com/sally S: Content-type:text/calendar; Method=RESPONSE;Component=VDATA; S: Optinfo=VERSION:2.1 S: Content-Transfer-Encoding: 7bit S: S: BEGIN:VCALENDAR S: VERSION:2.1 S: BEGIN:VDATA S: END:VDATA S: END:VCALENDAR S: . Find alarms within a range of time. C: SENDDATA C: Content-type:text/calendar; Method=READ; Component=VQUERY C: C: BEGIN:VCALENDAR C: VERSION:2.1 C: METHOD:READ C: CMDID:xyz12345 C: TARGET:relcal2 C: TARGET:cap://bobo.ex.com/relcal3 C: BEGIN:VQUERY Mansour/Dawson/Royer/Taler/Hill Expires: April 2000 39 Internet Draft CAP October 22, 1999 C: QUERY:SELECT (VEVENT.DTSTART, VEVENT.DTEND,VEVENT.SUMMARY, VEVENT.UID, VALARM.*); C: FROM VEVENT,VTODO; C: WHERE (VALARM.TRIGGER >= 19990310T080000Z AND C: VALARM.TRIGGER <= 19990310T190000Z); C: ORDERBY (VALARM.TRIGGER ASC) C: END:VQUERY C: END:VCALENDAR C: . S: 2.0 cap://bobo.ex.com/relcal3 S: Content-type:text/calendar; Method=RESPONSE; S: Optinfo=VERSION:2.1 S: Content-Transfer-Encoding: 7bit S: S: BEGIN:VCALENDAR S: VERSION:2.1 S: METHOD:RESPONSE S: CMDID:xyz12345 S: TARGET:cap://bobo.ex.com/relcal3 S: BEGIN:VEVENT S: DTSTART:19990310T130000Z S: DTEND:19990310T133000Z S: UID:abcxyz8999 S: SUMMARY:Meet with brave brave Sir Robin S: BEGIN:VALARM S: TRIGGER:19990310T132500Z S: SUMMARY:Almost time.. S: ACTION:DISPLAY S: END:VALARM S: END:VEVENT S: END:VCALENDAR S: . S: 2.0 cap://bobo.ex.com/relcal2 S: Content-type:text/calendar; Method=RESPONSE; S: Optinfo=VERSION:2.1 S: Content-Transfer-Encoding: 7bit S: S: BEGIN:VCALENDAR S: VERSION:2.1 S: METHOD:RESPONSE S: CMDID:xyz12345 S: TARGET:cap://bobo.ex.com/relcal2 S: BEGIN:VEVENT S: REQUEST-STATUS:2.0 S: END:VEVENT S: END:VCALENDAR Mansour/Dawson/Royer/Taler/Hill Expires: April 2000 40 Internet Draft CAP October 22, 1999 S: . 7.2.2 Scheduling Commands The following provide a set of scheduling commands (or methods) in CAP. Scheduling commands allow a CU to indirectly manipulate a calendar by asking another CU to perform an operation on their calendar. For example, CU-A can request CU-B to add a meeting to their calendar; in effect inviting CU-B to the meeting. Calendar access rights can be granted for scheduling commands without granting rights for more generalized access with the calendar commands. [Editors Note: This section needs to be completed by adding the restriction tables for each of these iTIP methods. The basis for the text is to be taken from [RFC2446].] 7.2.2.1 PUBLISH Arguments: Data: data as described below Result: 2.0 - success 2.2 - will attempt operation on the remote cap server Permission Calendar already exists Bad args Parent Calendar(s) not found This method is used to move a calendar within the CSs hierarchy of calendars. 7.2.2.2 REQUEST 7.2.2.3 REPLY 7.2.2.4 ADD 7.2.2.5 CANCEL 7.2.2.6 REFRESH 7.2.2.7 COUNTER 7.2.2.8 DECLINECOUNTER Mansour/Dawson/Royer/Taler/Hill Expires: April 2000 41 Internet Draft CAP October 22, 1999 7.2.3 iTIP Examples The following examples describe scenarios for the handling of incoming iTIP data. An appropriate sort-order for the handling of icoming iTIP is by UID, Recurrence-id, sequence, dtstamp. This processing may be optimized, for instance, REFRESHs could be processed last. As an update to [RFC2446], data with the "COUNTER" method should be processed even if the Seqeunce number is stale. 7.2.3.1 Sending and Receiving an iTIP request In this example A invites B and C to a meeting, B accepts the meeting and C rejects it. The calendars for A, B and C are relcal1, relcal2 and relcal3 respectively, and are all on the same server, "cal.foo.com". A lot of these described actions are performed by the CUAs and not the users themselves, the CUAs are called A-c, B-c and C-c respectively. A wishes to create a meeting with B and C, so A-c uses CAP to send the following iTIP request to relcal2 and relcal3, while logged in to "cal.foo.com". BEGIN:VCALENDAR VERSION:2.1 CMDID:xhj-dd METHOD:REQUEST TARGET:cap://cal.foo.com/relcal2 TARGET:relcal3 BEGIN:VEVENT UID:abcd12345 DTSTART:19990307T180000Z DTEND:19990307T190000Z ORGANIZER:cap://cal.foo.com/relcal1 ATTENDEE;RSVP=TRUE;PARTSTAT=NEEDS-ACTION:cap://cal.foo.com/relcal2 ATTENDEE;RSVP=TRUE;PARTSTAT=NEEDS-ACTION:cap://cal.foo.com/relcal3 SUMMARY:Important Meeting END:VEVENT END:VCALENDAR An incoming event (indicated by the value of the "METHOD" property) then appears in relcal2 and relcal3, with the following data: BEGIN:VEVENT METHOD:REQUEST UID:abcd12345 Mansour/Dawson/Royer/Taler/Hill Expires: April 2000 42 Internet Draft CAP October 22, 1999 DTSTART:19990307T180000Z DTEND:19990307T190000Z ORGANIZER:cap://cal.foo.com/relcal1 ATTENDEE;RSVP=TRUE;PARTSTAT=NEEDS-ACTION:cap://cal.foo.com/relcal2 ATTENDEE;RSVP=TRUE;PARTSTAT=NEEDS-ACTION:cap://cal.foo.com/relcal3 SUMMARY:Important Meeting END:VEVENT B-c and C-c must search for such incoming events, they do so using the following CAP search: BEGIN:VCALENDAR VERSION:2.1 METHOD:READ CMDID:xhr-de TARGET:relcal2 # or TARGET:relcal3 BEGIN:VQUERY QUERY:SELECT (ALL); FROM VEVENT; WHERE (METHOD == REQUEST); END:VQUERY END:VCALENDAR In response to this search they get the above event. B-c and C-c must then crack open the VEVENT, find the UID and determine if there is already an event on their calendar with that UID. To do this they use the following search: BEGIN:VCALENDAR VERSION:2.1 METHOD:READ CMDID:xhr-df TARGET:relcal2 BEGIN:VQUERY QUERY:SELECT (ALL); FROM VEVENT; WHERE (UID == abcd12345); END:VQUERY END:VCALENDAR We assume that the event is not already in their relcal2 or relcal3, so the read they only returns the original incoming iTIP (the UID matched), but this can be ignored since it is incoming. B-c prompts B who decides to accept the meeting request, and B-c creates a copy of the event in relcal2, with the "PARTSTAT" parameter Mansour/Dawson/Royer/Taler/Hill Expires: April 2000 43 Internet Draft CAP October 22, 1999 set to ACCEPTED. B-c also sends this copy to the Organizer at relcal1 as an iTIP REPLY, preserving the CMDID: BEGIN:VCALENDAR VERSION:2.1 CMDID:xhj-dd METHOD:REPLY TARGET:cap://cal.foo.com/relcal1 BEGIN:VEVENT UID:abcd12345 DTSTART:19990307T180000Z DTEND:19990307T190000Z ORGANIZER:cap://cal.foo.com/relcal1 ATTENDEE;PARTSTAT=ACCEPTED:cap://cal.foo.com/relcal2 SUMMARY:Important Meeting END:VEVENT END:VCALENDAR C, on the other hand, decides to decline the meeting, and C-c sends a reply to the Organizer to that effect, as follows: BEGIN:VCALENDAR VERSION:2.1 CMDID:xhj-dd METHOD:REPLY TARGET:cap://cal.foo.com/relcal1 BEGIN:VEVENT UID:abcd12345 DTSTART:19990307T180000Z DTEND:19990307T190000Z ORGANIZER:cap://cal.foo.com/relcal1 ATTENDEE;PARTSTAT=DECLINED:cap://cal.foo.com/relcal3 SUMMARY:Important Meeting END:VEVENT END:VCALENDAR It is preferable that C-c store the event in relcal3 even though it has been declined. Storing the event in relcal3 allows subsequent iTIP messages to be interpreted correctly. The "PARTSTAT" parameter indicates that the event was refused, and a tombstone property may be necessary if the user wishes to delete the event. After receiving the replies from relcal2 and relcal3, A-c updates the version of the event in relcal1 to indicate the new participation statii: BEGIN:VEVENT Mansour/Dawson/Royer/Taler/Hill Expires: April 2000 44 Internet Draft CAP October 22, 1999 METHOD:REQUEST UID:abcd12345 DTSTART:19990307T180000Z DTEND:19990307T190000Z ORGANIZER:cap://cal.foo.com/relcal1 ATTENDEE;PARTSTAT=ACCEPTED:cap://cal.foo.com/relcal2 ATTENDEE;PARTSTAT=DECLINED:cap://cal.foo.com/relcal3 SUMMARY:Important Meeting END:VEVENT A-c then sends a new iTIP request to relcal2 only, indicating the updated information. 7.2.3.2 Handling an iTIP refresh A little bit later, C is thinking about accepting the event in the previous example, but first wants to check the current state of the event. To find the current state C-c uses the iTIP "REFRESH" method, sending the following to relcal1: BEGIN:VCALENDAR VERSION:2.1 CMDID:xud-pn METHOD:REFRESH TARGET:cap://cal.foo.com/relcal1 BEGIN:VEVENT UID:abcd12345 ORGANIZER:cap://cal.foo.com/relcal1 ATTENDEE:cap://cal.foo.com/relcal3 DTSTAMP:19990306T202333Z END:VEVENT END:VCALENDAR A-c finds the refresh as an incoming iTIP, and searches for the corresponding event. Having found the event (with no changes since the last example) A-c then verifies that relcal3 is in fact an Attendee of the event and is thus allowed to request a refresh. (In the case of a published event things are more complicated.) A-c packages the event up as an iTIP request and sends it to relcal3: BEGIN:VCALENDAR VERSION:2.1 CMDID: xud-pn METHOD:REQUEST TARGET:cap://cal.foo.com/relcal3 BEGIN:VEVENT UID:abcd12345 Mansour/Dawson/Royer/Taler/Hill Expires: April 2000 45 Internet Draft CAP October 22, 1999 DTSTART:19990307T180000Z DTEND:19990307T190000Z ORGANIZER:cap://cal.foo.com/relcal1 ATTENDEE;PARTSTAT=ACCEPTED:cap://cal.foo.com/relcal2 ATTENDEE;PARTSTAT=DECLINED:cap://cal.foo.com/relcal3 SUMMARY:Important Meeting SEQUENCE:0 DTSTAMP:19990306T204333Z END:VEVENT END:VCALENDAR [Ed. - should the CMDID match that of the REFRESH?] 7.2.3.3 Sending and accepting an iTIP counter Having received the latest copy of the event C wishes to propose a venue for the event, using an iTIP COUNTER. To do this C-c sends the following to relcal1: BEGIN:VCALENDAR VERSION:2.1 CMDID:zzykjjk METHOD:COUNTER TARGET:cap://cal.foo.com/relcal1 BEGIN:VEVENT UID:abcd12345 DTSTART:19990307T180000Z DTEND:19990307T190000Z ORGANIZER:cap://cal.foo.com/relcal1 ATTENDEE;PARTSTAT=DECLINED:cap://cal.foo.com/relcal3 SUMMARY:Important Meeting LOCATION:La Belle Province COMMENT:My favourite restaurant I'll definitely go if it's there. END:VEVENT END:VCALENDAR Having sent the information to relcal1, C-c shouldn't store the new details in relcal3. If C-c updated the version in relcal3 and relcal1 did not reply to the counter, then relcal3 would have incorrect information. Instead C-c preserves the correct information and waits for a response from relcal1. A CUA implementation may wish to preserve this information itself, externally to the CS. In order to receive an iTIP counter A-c follows the same search as for other iTIP data, first find the incoming message, next find any matching events in the calendar store. Mansour/Dawson/Royer/Taler/Hill Expires: April 2000 46 Internet Draft CAP October 22, 1999 Having found the matching event, A reviews the proposed changes and decides to accept the COUNTER. To do this, A-c modifies the version in relcal1 (bumping the sequence number) to: BEGIN:VEVENT METHOD:CREATE UID:abcd12345 DTSTART:19990307T180000Z DTEND:19990307T190000Z ORGANIZER:cap://cal.foo.com/relcal1 ATTENDEE;PARTSTAT=ACCEPTED:cap://cal.foo.com/relcal2 ATTENDEE;PARTSTAT=DECLINED:cap://cal.foo.com/relcal3 SUMMARY:Important Meeting LOCATION:La Belle Province SEQUENCE:1 END:VEVENT A-c then sends the updated version as a request to both relcal2 and relcal3: BEGIN:VCALENDAR VERSION:2.1 CMDID:xup-po METHOD:REQUEST TARGET:cap://cal.foo.com/relcal2 TARGET:cap://cal.foo.com/relcal3 BEGIN:VEVENT UID:abcd12345 DTSTART:19990307T180000Z DTEND:19990307T190000Z ORGANIZER:cap://cal.foo.com/relcal1 ATTENDEE;RSVP=TRUE;PARTSTAT=NEEDS-ACTION:cap://cal.foo.com/relcal2 ATTENDEE;RSVP=TRUE;PARTSTAT=NEEDS-ACTION:cap://cal.foo.com/relcal3 SUMMARY:Important Meeting LOCATION:La Belle Province SEQUENCE:1 DTSTAMP:19990307T054339Z END:VEVENT END:VCALENDAR 7.2.3.4 Declining an iTIP counter B does not like the new location and also counters the event, B-c sends the following iTIP: BEGIN:VCALENDAR VERSION:2.1 CMDID:xim-ef METHOD:COUNTER TARGET:cap://cal.foo.com/relcal1 BEGIN:VEVENT UID:abcd12345 DTSTART:19990307T180000Z Mansour/Dawson/Royer/Taler/Hill Expires: April 2000 47 Internet Draft CAP October 22, 1999 DTEND:19990307T190000Z ORGANIZER:cap://cal.foo.com/relcal1 ATTENDEE:cap://cal.foo.com/relcal2 SUMMARY:Important Meeting LOCATION:Au Coin Dor=E9 END:VEVENT END:VCALENDAR However, C does not accept the counter, and C-c replies with a decline counter: BEGIN:VCALENDAR VERSION:2.1 CMDID:xim-ef METHOD:DECLINE-COUNTER TARGET:cap://cal.foo.com/relcal2 BEGIN:VEVENT DTSTAMP:19990307T093245Z UID:abcd12345 ORGANIZER:cap://cal.foo.com/relcal1 SEQUENCE:1 END:VEVENT END:VCALENDAR Fortunately B-c kept the original information when sending the counter, and there is no problem when no information is returned in the DECLINE-COUNTER. 8. Response Codes Numeric response codes are returned at both the transport and application layer. The same set of codes is used in both cases. [Editors Note: Do we want to use the same set of codes?] The format of these codes is described in [RFC2445], and extend in [RFC2446] and [RFC2447]. The following describes new codes added to this set. At the application layer response codes are returned as the value of a "REQUEST-STATUS" property. The value type of this property is modified from that defined in [RFC2445], to make the accompanying text optional. Code Params Description -------------------------------------------------------------------- 2.0 varies Success. The parameters vary with the operation Mansour/Dawson/Royer/Taler/Hill Expires: April 2000 48 Internet Draft CAP October 22, 1999 and are specified 2.0.1 none Success, send data, terminate with <CRLF>.<CRLF> 2.0.2 A reply is pending. It could not be completed in the specified amount of time. The server awaits a CONTINUE or ABORT command. 2.0.3 In response to the client issuing an ABORT command, this reply code indicates that any command currently underway was successfully aborted. 2.0.6 An operation is being attempted on a remote server. This response indicates that the server has not yet been contacted but an attempt will be made to contact it after the command has been sent. 3.1.4 Capability not supported 4.1 Calendar store access denied 6.1 authenticate failure: unsupported authentication mechanism, credentials rejected 6.2 Sender aborted authentication, authentication exchange cancelled 6.3 Attempt to create or modify an event such that it would overlap another event in either of the following two circumstances: a) one of the events has a TRANSP property set to OPAQUE-NOCONFLICT or TRANSPARENT-NOCONFLICT. b) the calendar's ALLOW-CONFLICT property is set to NO. 7.0 A timeout has occurred. The server was unable to complete the operation in the requested time. 8.0 A failure has occurred in the Receiver that prevents the operation from succeeding. 8.1 Sent when a session cannot be established because Mansour/Dawson/Royer/Taler/Hill Expires: April 2000 49 Internet Draft CAP October 22, 1999 the CAP Server is too busy. 8.2 Used to signal that an ICAL object has exceeded the server's size limit. 8.3 A DATETIME value was too large to be represented on this Calendar. 8.4 A DATETIME value was too far in the past to be represented on this Calendar. 8.5 An attempt was made to create a new object but the unique id specified is already in use. 8.6 ID clash 9.0 An unrecongnized command was received. 10.1 Accompanied by an alternate address. The RECIPIENT specified should be contacted at the given alternate address. The referral address MUST follow the reply code. 10.2 The server is shutting down. 10.4 The operation has not be performed because it would cause the resources (memory, disk,CPU, etc) to exceed the allocated quota. 10.5 The ITIP message has been queued too too long. Delivery has been aborted. 9. Detailed SQL Schema This section describes a conceptual schema for object model in CAP. It is used as the basis for querying data managed by the CS. This is only a conceptual schema. Implementations can use any schema they like so long as they are prepared to map CAP queries that are expressed in this conceptual schema. Implementations are not required to use SQL database technology. The protocol is designed such that a CUA does not need to handle these queries. This schema is based on SQL-92 [SQL] along with the [SQLCOM] corrections. Properties than can occur multiple times are intended to be put in Mansour/Dawson/Royer/Taler/Hill Expires: April 2000 50 Internet Draft CAP October 22, 1999 separate tables. For example BEGIN:VEVENT UID:1 DTSTART:19990326T201400Z ORGANIZER:mailto:sam@abc.COM SUMMARY:I have 2 attachments ATTACHMENT;FMTTYPE=audio/basic:ftp://host.com/pub/sounds/bell.au ATTACHMENT;FMTTYPE=audio/basic:ftp://host.com/pub/sounds/bell2.au END:VEVENT There are two ATTACHMENT properties each having a unique value. These are kept in separate tables. This is diagrammed below. The diagram is not a complete representation of the VEVENT table. It is an abbreviated table used to illustrate how properties that can occur multiple times are intended to be represented. ABBREVIATED VEVENT TABLE UID DTSTART ORGANIZER SUMMARY ATTACH_LIST +----+----------------+-------------------+------------+------------+ |1 |19990326T201400Z|mailto:sam@abc.com |I have 2 | 123 | | | | |attachments | | +----+----------------+-------------------+------------+------------+ |999 |19700101T000000Z|mailto:usr@host.com|I have no | | | | | |attachments | | +----+----------------+-------------------+------------+------------+ ABBREVIATED ATTACH_LIST TABLE ATTACH_LIST VALUE INLINE_BLOB +------------+------------------------------------+-----------------+ |123 | ftp://host.com/pub/sounds/bell.au | | +------------+------------------------------------+-----------------+ |123 | ftp://host.com/pub/sounds/bell2.au| | +------------+------------------------------------+-----------------+ |234 | | MIICajCCAdO- | | | | gAwIBAgICBEU | | | | <...remainder | | | | of "BASE64"| | | | encoded binary| | | | data...> | +------------+------------------------------------+-----------------+ 9.1 iCalendar Store Schema The following defines the schema for an iCalendar object and the Mansour/Dawson/Royer/Taler/Hill Expires: April 2000 51 Internet Draft CAP October 22, 1999 components, properties, and parameters defined in [RFC2445]. Create table VCALENDAR { RELATIVECALID VARCHAR(256) PRIMARY KEY, CALMASTER VARCHAR(256), CHARSET VARCHAR(256), CHILDREN VARCHAR(256) LANGUAGE CHAR(5) LAST_MODIFIED NAME VARCHAR(256), OWNERS PARENT CHAR(16), PATH SCHEDULABLE_HOURS TOMBSTONE TZID LAST_MODIFIED_BY }; create table VEVENT { ATTACH_LIST INTEGER, ATTENDEE_LIST INTEGER, /* CATEGORIES may contain a comma seperated list */ CATEGORIES VARCHAR(len?), CLASS INTEGER, CLASS_PARAMS INTEGER, COMMENT VARCHA, COMMENT_PARAMS INTEGER, CONTACT_LIST INTEGER, CREATED TIMESTAMP NOT NULL DEFAULT CURRENT_DATE, CREATED_PARAMS INTEGER, DESCRIPTION VARCHAR(len?), DESCRIPTION_PARAMS INTEGER, DTEND TIMESTAMP, DTEND_PARAMS INTEGER, DTSTAMP TIMESTAMP NOT NULL, DTSTAMP_PARAMS INTEGER, DTSTART TIMESTAMP NOT NULL, DTSTART_PARAMS INTEGER, DURATION <?type?>, DURATION_PARAMS INTEGER, EXDATE_LIST INTEGER, EXRULE_LIST INTEGER, GEO_LAT NUMBER, GEO_LON NUMBER, GEO_PARAMS INTEGER, Mansour/Dawson/Royer/Taler/Hill Expires: April 2000 52 Internet Draft CAP October 22, 1999 LAST_MODIFIED TIMESTAMP NOT NULL DEFAULT CURRENT_DATE, LAST_MODIFIED_PARAMS INTEGER, LOCATION VARCHA, LOCATION_PARAMS INTEGER, METHOD VARCHAR(len20?), ORGANIZER VARCHAR(len?) NOT NULL, ORGANIZER_PARAMS INTEGER, PRIORITY INTEGER, PRIORITY_PARAMS CHAR(1), RECURRENCE_ID VARCHAR(len?), RECURRENCE_ID_PARAMS INTEGER, RDATE_LIST INTEGER, RELATED_TO_LIST INTEGER, /* RESOURCES may contain a comma seperated list */ RESOURCES VARCHAR(len?), RESOURCES_PARAMS INTEGER, RRULE_LIST INTEGER, SUMMARY VARCHAR(len?) NOT NULL DEFAULT "", SUMMARY_PARAMS INTEGER, SEQUENCE INTEGER NOT NULL DEFAULT 0, SEQUENCE_PARAMS INTEGER, STATUS INTEGER, STATUS_PARAMS CHAR(1), TRANSP CHAR(1), TRANSP_PARAMS INTEGER, UID VARCHAR(len?) NOT NULL, UID_PARAMS INTEGER, URL VARCHA, URL_PARAMS INTEGER, X_PROP_LIST INTEGER, VALARM_LIST INTEGER, }; create table VTODO { ATTENDEE_LISTINTEGER, ATTACH_LIST INTEGER, /* CATEGORIES may contain a comma separated list */ CATEGORIES VARCHAR(len?), CLASS INTEGER, CLASS_PARAMS INTEGER, COMMENT VARCHAR(len?), COMMENT_PARAMS INTEGER, CONTACT_LIST INTEGER, CREATED TIMESTAMP NOT NULL DEFAULT CURRENT_DATE, CREATED_PARAMS INTEGER, Mansour/Dawson/Royer/Taler/Hill Expires: April 2000 53 Internet Draft CAP October 22, 1999 DESCRIPTION VARCHAR(len?), DESCRIPTION_PARAMS INTEGER, DTSTAMP TIMESTAMP NOT NULL, DTSTAMP_PARAMS INTEGER, DTSTART TIMESTAMP NOT NULL, DTSTART_PARAMS INTEGER, DUE TIMESTAMP, DUE_PARAMS INTEGER, DURATION <?type?>, DURATION_PARAMS INTEGER, EXDATE_LIST INTEGER, EXRULE_LIST INTEGER, GEO_LAT NUMBER, GEO_LON NUMBER, GEO_PARAMS INTEGER, LAST_MODIFIED TIMESTAMP NOT NULL DEFAULT CURRENT_DATE, LAST_MODIFIED_PARAMS INTEGER, LOCATION VARCHA, LOCATION_PARAMS INTEGER, METHOD VARCHAR(len20?), ORGANIZER VARCHAR(len?) NOT NULL, ORGANIZER_PARAMS INTEGER, PERCENT_COMPLETE INTEGER, PERCENT_COMPLETE_PARAMSLETE INTEGER PRIORITY INTEGER NOT NULL, PRIORITY_PARAMS INTEGER, RDATE_LIST INTEGER, RECURRENCE_ID VARCHAR(len?), RECURRENCE_ID_PARAMS INTEGER, /* RESOURCES may contain a comma seperated list */ RESOURCES VARCHAR(len?), RESOURCES_PARAMS INTEGER, RRULE_LIST INTEGER, SEQUENCE INTEGER NOT NULL DEFAULT 0, SEQUENCE_PARAMS INTEGER, SUMMARY VARCHAR(len?) NOT NULL DEFAULT "", SUMMARY_PARAMS INTEGER, UID VARCHAR(len?) NOT NULL, UID_PARAMS INTEGER, URL VARCHAR(len?) URL_PARAMS INTEGER, X_PROP_LIST INTEGER VALARM_LIST INTEGER, }; create table VJOURNAL { Mansour/Dawson/Royer/Taler/Hill Expires: April 2000 54 Internet Draft CAP October 22, 1999 ATTACH_LIST INTEGER, /* CATEGORIES may contain a comma seperated list */ CATEGORIES VARCHAR(len?), CLASS INTEGER, CLASS_PARAMS INTEGER, COMMENT VARCHAR(len?), COMMENT_PARAMS INTEGER, CONTACT_LIST INTEGER, CREATED TIMESTAMP NOT NULL DEFAULT CURRENT_DATE, CREATED_PARAMS INTEGER, DESCRIPTION VARCHAR(len?) NOT NULL DEFAUT "", DESCRIPTION_PARAMS INTEGER, DTSTAMP TIMESTAMP NOT NULL, DTSTAMP_PARAMS INTEGER, DTSTART TIMESTAMP NOT NULL, DTSTART_PARAMS INTEGER, EXDATE_LIST INTEGER, EXRULE_LIST INTEGER, LAST_MODIFIED TIMESTAMP NOT NULL DEFAULT CURRENT_DATE, METHOD VARCHAR(len20?), LAST_MODIFIED_PARAMS INTEGER, ORGANIZER VARCHAR(len?) NOT NULL, ORGANIZER_PARAMS INTEGER, RDATE_LIST INTEGER, RECURRENCE_ID VARCHAR(len?), RECURRENCE_ID_PARAMS INTEGER, RELATED_TO_LIST INTEGER, RRULE_LIST INTEGER, SEQUENCE INTEGER NOT NULL DEFAULT 0, SEQUENCE_PARAMS INTEGER, STATUS INTEGER, STATUS_PARAMS CHAR(1), SUMMARY VARCHAR(len?) NOT NULL DEFAULT "", SUMMARY_PARAMS INTEGER, UID VARCHAR(len?) NOT NULL, UID_PARAMS INTEGER, X_PROP_LIST INTEGER }; An implementation may not actually have a VFREEBUSY table as the information may be produced dynamicly. However a CS MUST appear to provide this table as this may be how a CUA chooses to query for VFREEBUSY information while using [CAP]. Example, it probabily would not make any sense for ATTENDEE to exist in this table, yet a CUA may wish to ask for the VFREEBUSY for an ATTENDEE. Mansour/Dawson/Royer/Taler/Hill Expires: April 2000 55 Internet Draft CAP October 22, 1999 create table VFREEBUSY { ATTENDEE_LIST VARCHAR(len?), COMMENT VARCHAR(len?), COMMENT_PARAMS INTEGER, CONTACT_LIST INTEGER, DTEND TIMESTAMP NOT NULL, DTEND_PARAMS INTEGER, DTSTAMP TIMESTAMP NOT NULL, DTSTAMP_PARAMS INTEGER, DTSTART TIMESTAMP NOT NULL, DTSTART_PARAMS INTEGER, FREEBUSY_LIST INTEGER NOT NULL, METHOD VARCHAR(len20?), ORGANIZER VARCHAR(len?) NOT NULL, ORGANIZER_PARAMS INTEGER, X_PROP_LIST INTEGER URL VARCHAR(len?) }; create table VTIMEZONE { DAYLIGHT_LIST INTEGER, /* In TZ_LIST table */ STANDARD_LIST INTEGER, /* In TZ_LIST table */ TZID VARCHAR(len?) NOT NULL, TZID_PARAM INTEGER, TZURL VARCHAR(len?) NOT NULL, TZURL_PARAM INTEGER, X_PROP_LIST INTEGER }; create table TZ_LIST { /* Maps to DAYLIGHT_LIST or STANDARD_LIST in VTIMEZONE table */ TZ_KEY INTEGER, COMMENT VARCHAR(len?), COMMENT_PARAMS INTEGER, DTSTART TIMESTAMP NOT NULL, DTSTART_PARAMS INTEGER, LAST_MODIFIED TIMESTAMP NOT NULL DEFAULT CURRENT_DATE, LAST_MODIFIED_PARAMS INTEGER, RDATE_LIST INTEGER, RRULE_LIST INTEGER, TZNAME VARCHAR(len?), TZOFFSET <?type?> NOT NULL, TZOFFSETFROM <?type?> NOT NULL, TZOFFSETTO <?type?> NOT NULL, }; Mansour/Dawson/Royer/Taler/Hill Expires: April 2000 56 Internet Draft CAP October 22, 1999 create table VALARM_LIST { /* Maps to VALARM_LIST in other tables */ VALARM_KEY INTEGER, ACTION INTEGER NOT NULL, ACTION_PARAMS INTEGER, ATTACH_LIST INTEGER, DESCRIPTION VARCHAR(len?) NOT NULL DEFAUT "", DESCRIPTION_PARAMS INTEGER, DURATION <?type?>, DURATION_PARAMS INTEGER, REPEAT INTEGER, REPEAT_PARAMS INTEGER, SUMMARY VARCHAR(len?) NOT NULL DEFAULT "", SUMMARY_PARAMS INTEGER, TRIGGER_DT TIMESTAMP, TRIGGER_DURATION <?type?>, X_PROP_LIST INTEGER }; 10. Examples For all the examples in this section, the authenticated user is user@example.com. 10.1 Authentication Examples 10.1.1 Login Using Kerberos V4 Use Kerberos V4 to authenticate as bill@example.com to the CAP server on cal.example.com. C: <connect to cal.example.com on port ...> S: 2.0 S: . C: CAPABILTY S: CAPVERSION=1.0 S: ITIPVERSION=1.0 S: AUTH=KERBEROS_V4 S: AUTH=DIGEST_MD5 S: . C: AUTHENTICATE KERBEROS_V4 S: AmFYig== C: BAcAQU5EUkVXLkNNVS5FRFUAOCAsho84kLN3/IJmrMG+25a4DT S: or//EoAADZI= C: DiAF5A4gA+oOIALuBkAAmw== S: 2.0 S: IDENTITY=bill@example.com Mansour/Dawson/Royer/Taler/Hill Expires: April 2000 57 Internet Draft CAP October 22, 1999 S: CAPVERSION=1.0 S: ITIPVERSION=1.0 S: AUTH=KERBEROS_V4 S: AUTH=DIGEST_MD5 S: CAR=CAR1 appl S: MINDATE=19700101T000000Z appl # who knows this date (end of the 32 bit number)? S: MAXDATE=20370201T000000Z S: . 10.1.2 Error Scenarios Use of SASL Authorization Identity is not supported. Use the IDENTITY command instead. If you attempt to use the Authorization Identity, an error status will be returned. C: AUTHENTICATE KERBEROS_V4 S: AmFYig== C: BAcAQU5EUkVXLkNNVS5FRFUAOCAsho84kLN3/IJmrMG+25a4DT S: or//EoAADZI= C: DiAF5A4gA+oOIALuBkAAmw== S: 6.1 S: . Sender aborted authentication: C: AUTHENTICATE KERBEROS_V4 S: AmFYig== C: . S: 6.2 S: . Unsupported mechanism: C: AUTHENTICATE Experimental_Auth S: 6.3 S: . 10.2 Read Examples 10.2.1 Read From A Single Calendar In this example bill@example.com reads a day's worth of events from cap://cal.example.com/opaqueid99. C: SENDDATA C: Content-type:text/calendar; Method=READ; Component=VQUERY Mansour/Dawson/Royer/Taler/Hill Expires: April 2000 58 Internet Draft CAP October 22, 1999 C: C: BEGIN:VCALENDAR C: VERSION:2.1 C: METHOD:READ C: CMDID:xyz12345 C: TARGET:cap://cal.example.com/opaqueid99 C: BEGIN:VQUERY C: QUERY:SELECT (VEVENT.DTSTART,VEVENT.DTEND,SUMMARY,UID); C: FROM VEVENTTABLE; C: WHERE (VEVENT.DTEND >= 19990714T080000Z AND C: VEVENT.DTSTART <= 19990715T080000Z); C: ORDERBY (VEVENT.DTSTART ASC, VEVENT.DTEND, UID, SUMMARY) C: END:VQUERY C: END:VCALENDAR C: . # this response code means that the transport successfully # delivered the data. S: 2.0 ; got the request OK ; really S: Content-type:text/calendar; Method=RESPONSE; S: Optinfo=VERSION:2.1 S: Content-Transfer-Encoding: 7bit S: S: BEGIN:VCALENDAR S: VERSION:2.1 S: METHOD:RESPONSE S: TARGET:cap://cal.example.com/opaqueid99 S: CMDID:xyz12345 # we have not yet discussed response-status S: RESPONSE-STATUS:2.0 S: BEGIN:VEVENT S: DTSTART:19990714T200000Z S: DTEND:19990714T210000Z S: UID:000444888929922 S: SUMMARY:Blah bla S: END:VEVENT S: BEGIN:VEVENT S: UID:0034848098038888989443 S: SUMMARY:meeting S: DTEND:19990714T233000Z S: DTSTART:19990714T223000Z S: END:VEVENT S: END:VCALENDAR S: . 10.2.2 Read From Multiple Calendars Mansour/Dawson/Royer/Taler/Hill Expires: April 2000 59 Internet Draft CAP October 22, 1999 In this example bill@example.com reads a day's worth of events from cap://cal.example.com/opaqueid101 and cap://cal.example.com/opaqueid103 C: SENDDATA C: Content-type:text/calendar; Method=READ; Component=VQUERY C: C: BEGIN:VCALENDAR C: VERSION:2.1 C: METHOD:READ C: CMDID:xyz12346 C: TARGET:cap://cal.example.com/opaqueid101 C: TARGET:opaqueid103 C: BEGIN:VQUERY C: QUERY:SELECT (DTSTART,DTEND,SUMMARY,UID); C: FROM VEVENT; C: WHERE (DTEND >= 19990714T080000Z AND C: DTSTART <= 19990715T080000Z); C: ORDERBY (DTSTART ASC, DTEND, UID, SUMMARY) C: END:VQUERY C: END:VCALENDAR C: . S: 2.0 S: Content-Type:multipart/mixed;boundary="--FEE3790DC7E35189CA67" S: S: ----FEE3790DC7E35189CA67 S: Content-type:text/calendar; Method=RESPONSE; S: Optinfo=VERSION:2.1 S: Content-Transfer-Encoding: 7bit S: S: BEGIN:VCALENDAR S: VERSION:2.1 S: METHOD:RESPONSE S: TARGET:cap://cal.example.com/opaqueid103 S: CMDID:xyz12346 S: RESPONSE-CODE:2.0 S: BEGIN:VEVENT S: UID:0034848098038888989443 S: SUMMARY:meeting S: DTEND:19990714T233000Z S: DTSTART:19990714T223000Z S: END:VEVENT S: END:VCALENDAR S: S: ----FEE3790DC7E35189CA67CE2C S: Content-type:text/calendar; Method=RESPONSE; S: Optinfo=VERSION:2.1 Mansour/Dawson/Royer/Taler/Hill Expires: April 2000 60 Internet Draft CAP October 22, 1999 S: Content-Transfer-Encoding: 7bit S: S: BEGIN:VCALENDAR S: VERSION:2.1 S: METHOD:RESPONSE S: TARGET:cap://cal.example.com/opaqueid101 S: CMDID:xyz12346 S: RESPONSE-CODE:4.1 ; access denied S: END:VCALENDAR S: S: ----FEE3790DC7E35189CA67CE2C S: . 10.2.3 Timeouts In this example bill@example.com attempts to read a calendar but the latency time he supplies is not sufficient for the server to complete the command. C: SENDDATA 3 C: Content-type:text/calendar; Method=READ; Component=VQUERY C: C: BEGIN:VCALENDAR C: VERSION:2.1 C: METHOD:READ C: CMDID:xyz12346 C: TARGET:cap://cal.example.com/opaqueid101 C: TARGET:opaqueid103 C: BEGIN:VQUERY C: QUERY:SELECT (DTSTART,DTEND,SUMMARY,UID); C: FROM VEVENT; C: WHERE (DTEND >= 19990714T080000Z AND C: DTSTART <= 19990715T080000Z); C: ORDERBY (DTSTART ASC, DTEND, UID, SUMMARY) C: END:VQUERY C: END:VCALENDAR C: . S: 7.0 ; timeout S: . If Bill wants to continue and give the server more time he would issue a CONTINUE command: C: CONTINUE 10 If Bill wants to abort the command and not wait any further he would issue an ABORT command: Mansour/Dawson/Royer/Taler/Hill Expires: April 2000 61 Internet Draft CAP October 22, 1999 C: ABORT S: 2.0 S: . 10.2.4 Using the Calendar Parent, Children Properties 10.2.5 An example that depends on VEVENT.DTSTART and VALARM.DTSTART 11. Implementation Issues 1. What are the minimum component properties set required to create a new VEVENT, VTODO and VJOURNAL?. PROPOSAL: DTSTART, SUMMARY and UID. 2. What is the state of all undefined properties? PROPOSAL: Not defined. So a query will not return them, if they are selected. 12. Properties [Editors Note: These extensions/changes to iCalendar need to be reformatted to conform to the IANA registration process defined in section 7 of [RFC2445].] 12.1 Calendar Store Properties Read Name Only Description ------------- ---- --------------------------------------------------- DEFAULT-VCARS N The default VCARs for newly created toplevel calendars MAXDATE Y The date/time in the future beyond which the server cannot represent. MINDATE Y The date/time in the past prior to which the server cannot represent. TIME Y Current server time. This is returned as a localtime and TZID RECURRENCE Y Boolean value set to TRUE if the server supports recurrence rules, or FALSE if it does not. RECUR-LIMIT Y This numeric value describes how the server handles unbounded recurrences. The value is only valid if RECURRENCE is TRUE. If the value is 0 it means that the server supports unbounded recurrence rules. If it is non-zero, it is a positive integer indicating the number of instances that will be created when Mansour/Dawson/Royer/Taler/Hill Expires: April 2000 62 Internet Draft CAP October 22, 1999 the server expands an unbounded recurrence rule. [Editors Note: Can/MUST the server unzip RRULES/EXRULES?] 12.2 Calendar Properties Read Name Only Description ------------- ---- ------------------------------------------------- ALLOW-CONFLICTS N This boolean value indicates whether or not the calendar supports event conflicts. That is, whether or not any of the events in the calendar can overlap. The default value is YES meaning that conflicts are allowed. CHARSET N the default charset for localized strings in this calendar CHILDREN Y the sub-calendars belonging to this calendar. CREATED Y the timestamp of the calendars create date LANGUAGE N the default language for localizable strings in this calendar LAST-MODIFIED N the timestamp when the properties of the calendar were last updated. Note that the UPN parameter may be present to indicate the person or process that last modified the calendar properties. NAME N the display name for this calendar. It is a localizable string. OWNERS N a multi instanced property indicating the calendar owner. PARENT N maintained by a CAP server. PATH Y ?? human readable path of name. ?? [editors note: I think this is going to be really problematic. Can we do away with this? Or perhaps make it optional? ] RELATIVECALID N a unique name for the calendar. It is made up of 7 bit ASCII characters. Mansour/Dawson/Royer/Taler/Hill Expires: April 2000 63 Internet Draft CAP October 22, 1999 SCHEDULABLE- N the preferred time range for scheduling HOURS events on this calendar. This value is a collection of RRULEs and EXRULEs TOMBSTONE N a marker indicating that this calendar has been Deleted. TZID N the id of the timezone associated with this calendar 13. Security Considerations For the mandatory SASL mechanism that CAP specifies, the mechanism support is: ? MUST authentication ? MUST authorization ? MAY impersonation The security issue: +---------+ +----------+ CUA1 ------ | CS1 |--------CAP----------| CS2 |-----CUA2 | calF | | calA | +---------+ +----------+ ? UserListX is not an owner of calF ? UserListX has been given ACTONBEHALF of rights to calF by an owner of calF, UserY ? UserX authenticates to CS1 as UserX ? UserX wants to update the attendee status of an event on calA ? An owner of calA has granted access to UserY to update an event they have been invited to ? How do we grant UserX access to do this? [Editors Note: This needs further work and examples.] 14. Changes to iCalendar [Editors Note: These extensions/changes to iCalendar need to be reformatted to conform to the IANA registration process defined in section 7 of [RFC2445].] 14.1 Created Property Name: CREATED Purpose: This property specifies the date and time that the calendar information was created by the calendar user agent in the calendar store. Mansour/Dawson/Royer/Taler/Hill Expires: April 2000 64 Internet Draft CAP October 22, 1999 Note: This is analogous to the creation date and time for a file in the file system. Value Type: DATE-TIME Property Parameters: Non-standard property parameters can be specified on this property. Conformance: The property can be specified once in "VEVENT", "VTODO" or "VJOURNAL" calendar components. Description: The date and time is a UTC value. Format Definition: The property is defined by the following notation: created = "CREATED" creaparam ":" date-time CRLF creaparam = (";" upnparam) *(";" xparam) upnparam = "UPN" "=" DQUOTE upn-value DQUOTE Example: The following is an example of this property: CREATED:19960329T133000Z CREATED;UPN=sman@netscape.com:19991018T203000Z 14.2 Last Modified Property Name: LAST-MODIFIED Purpose: The property specifies the date and time that the information associated with the calendar component was last revised in the calendar store. Note: This is analogous to the modification date and time for a file in the file system. Value Type: DATE-TIME Property Parameters: Non-standard property parameters can be specified on this property. Conformance: This property can be specified in the "EVENT", "VTODO", "VJOURNAL" or "VTIMEZONE" calendar components. Description: The property value MUST be specified in the UTC time format. Format Definition: The property is defined by the following notation: last-mod = "LAST-MODIFIED" lstparam ":" date-time CRLF lstparam = (";" upnparam) *(";" xparam) upnparam = "UPN" "=" DQUOTE upn-value DQUOTE Example: The following is are examples of this property: LAST- Mansour/Dawson/Royer/Taler/Hill Expires: April 2000 65 Internet Draft CAP October 22, 1999 MODIFIED:19960817T133000Z LAST- MODIFIED;UPN=sman@netscape.com:19991018T200000Z 14.2.1.1 Time Transparency Property Name: TRANSP Purpose: This property defines whether an event is transparent or not to busy time searches. Value Type: TEXT Property Parameters: Non-standard property parameters can be specified on this property. Conformance: This property can be specified once in a "VEVENT" calendar component. Description: Time Transparency is the characteristic of an event that determines whether it appears to consume time on a calendar. Events that consume actual time for the individual or resource associated with the calendar SHOULD be recorded as OPAQUE, allowing them to be detected by free-busy time searches. Other events, which do not take up the individual's (or resource's) time SHOULD be recorded as TRANSPARENT, making them invisible to free-busy time searches. Format Definition: The property is specified by the following notation: transp = "TRANSP" tranparam ":" transvalue CRLF tranparam = *(";" xparam) transvalue = "OPAQUE" ;Blocks or opaque on busy time searches. / "TRANSPARENT" ;Transparent on busy time searches. / "TRANSPARENT-NOCONFLICT" ; Transparent on busy time ; searches and no other OPAQUE ; or OPAQUE-NOCONFLICT event can ; overlap it. / "OPAQUE-NOCONFLICT" ; Opaque on busy time ; searches and no other OPAQUE ; or OPAQUE-NOCONFLICT event can ; overlap it. ;Default value is OPAQUE Example: The following is an example of this property for an event that is transparent or does not block on free/busy time searches: Mansour/Dawson/Royer/Taler/Hill Expires: April 2000 66 Internet Draft CAP October 22, 1999 TRANSP:TRANSPARENT The following is an example of this property for an event that is opaque or blocks on free/busy time searches: TRANSP:OPAQUE The following is an example of this property for an event that is opaque or blocks on free/busy time searches plus no other event can overlap it: TRANSP:OPAQUE-NOCONFLICT 14.3 RIGHTS Value Type Value Name: RIGHTS Purpose: This value type is used to identify properties whose value is a calendar access rights. Formal Definition: The value type is defined by the following notation: rights = [princ] (policy / carref / cardef) CRLF princ = "UPN" "=" (text / all / "OWNER" / "NONOWNER") policy = ";" "POLICY" "=" policyname policyname = "READBUSYTIMEINFO" / "ACTONBEHALFOF" / "REQUESTONLY" / "UPDATEPARTSTATUS" / "OWNER" / iana-name carref = ";" "CARREF" "=" text *("," text) cardef = action object action = ";" "ACTION" "=" act-type *("," act-type) act-type = ("CREATE" / "MODIFY" / "DELETE" / "READ" / all) object = ";" "OBJECT" "=" (csprop *("," csprop) [propvalue]) / (calprop *("," calprop) [propvalue]) / (component *("," component)) [compvalue] / (compprop *("," compprop) [propvalue]) / (compparam *("," compparam) [paramvalue]) Mansour/Dawson/Royer/Taler/Hill Expires: April 2000 67 Internet Draft CAP October 22, 1999 csprop = csprop2 / all / iana-name csprop2 = <any calendar store property defined in [CAP]> propvalue = propvalue2 / all / iana-name propvalue2 = <any value appropriate for the named property> calprop = calprop2 / all / iana-name calprop2 = <any calendar property name defined in [RFC2445] or [CAP]> component = component2 / all / iana-name component2 = <any calendar component defined in [RFC2445] or [CAP]> compprop = compprop2 / all / iana-name compprop2 = <any component property name defined in [RFC2445] or [CAP]> compparam = compparm2 / all / iana-name compparm2 = <any component parameter name defined in [RFC2445] or [CAP]> compvalue = ";" "VALUE" "=" ((component2 *("," component2)) / all / iana-name) paramvalue = paramvalue2 / all / iana-name paramvalue2 = <any value appropriate for the named parameter> all = "ALL" iana-name = <A name registered with IANA> Description: The value type is a structured value consisting of a list of one or more access control rights rule parts. Each rule part is defined by a "NAME=VALUE" pair. The rule parts are separated from each other by the SEMICOLON character (US-ASCII decimal 59). The rule parts are not ordered in any particular sequence, unless otherwise specified by the ABNF. Individual rule parts MUST only be specified once. Mansour/Dawson/Royer/Taler/Hill Expires: April 2000 68 Internet Draft CAP October 22, 1999 The UPN rule part specifies the authenticated calendar user that the calendar access rights applies to. The value of this rule part is either a quoted text specifying a UPN or an unquoted text specifying a keyword enumerating a standard authenticated user type. If the value is the keyword is ALL, then the rule applies to all authenticated calendar users (i.e., all UPNs). If the value is the keyword OWNER, then the rule applies to any of the owners of the calendar store or calendar. If the value is the keyword NONOWNER, then the rule applies to a UPN that is not the owner of the calendar store or calendar. If this rule part is not specified in the value, then the calendar access rights do not apply to any UPN. In this case, the calendar access rights can be defined for reference by another instance of a calendar access rights. For example, a complex set of calendar access rights can be defined once and referenced many times in the rights specified for individual calendar users. The POLICY rule part specifies a standard calendar access policy. Calendar access policies are individual sets of well-defined calendar access rights that can be referenced by their policy name. NOTE: Possible calendar access policy that may be standardized by CAP include: ? READBUSYTIMEINFO - Specifies rights for reading busy time data. ? ACTONBEHALFOF - Specifies rights for any CAP function taken on PUBLIC or PRIVATE calendar components. However, no CAP function can be taken on CONFIDENTIAL classified calendar components. ? REQUESTONLY - Specifies rights for creating new event invitations, to-do assignments and journal entries. ? UPDATEPARTSTATUS - Specifies rights for modifying ones own participation status. ? OWNER - Specifies the same rights given to the owner of the calendar store or calendar. The CARREF rule part specifies a reference to a particular "VCAR" calendar component. The text is matched to a CARID property value within a "VCAR" calendar component. This allows for a particular set of calendar access rights to be defined once and referenced multiple times. The "VCAR" identifier specified by this rule part is unique to the calendar store. The ACTION rule part defines one or more CAP actions that are allowed for the UPN. The valid values are CREATE, COPY, DELETE, MODIFY, MOVE, Mansour/Dawson/Royer/Taler/Hill Expires: April 2000 69 Internet Draft CAP October 22, 1999 READ, corresponding to the calendar commands; PUBLISH, REQUEST, REPLY, ADD, CANCEL, REFRESH, COUNTER, DECLINECOUNTER, corresponding to the scheduling commands; and ALL, meaning all of calendaring commands and scheduling commands. Multiple ACTION enumerations can be specified as a COMMA character (US-ASCII decimal 44) separated list of ACTION enumerated values. The text ALL is the same as specifying the enumerated values "CREATE, MODIFY, DELETE, READ". The OBJECT rule part defines the calendar store property, calendar property, calendar component, component property, or parameter that the ACTION is restricted to. Multiple OBJECT enumerations can be specified as a COMMA character (US-ASCII decimal 44) separated list of OBJECT enumerated values. The value ALL specifies any and all valid objects. The VALUE rule part specifies the restricted values for the OBJECT rule part. Multiple VALUE strings can be specified as a COMMA character (US- ASCII decimal 44) separated list of VALUE strings. The text ALL specifies any and all valid values. If an OBJECT rule part is specified but no corresponding VALUE rule part is specified, then the rule applies to any and all valid values of the specified OBJECT(s). Example: The following is a rule which specifies access rights for "foo" calendar user to read busy time values: UPN="foo@host.com";ACTION=READ;OBJECT=DTSTART,DTEND 14.4 VCAR Calendar Component Component Name: "VCAR" Purpose: Provide a grouping of calendar access rights. Format Definition: A "VCAR" calendar component is defined by the following notation: aclc = "BEGIN" ":" "VCAR" CRLF carprop "END" ":" "VCAR" CRLF carprop = carid 1*(grant / deny) Description: A "VCAR" calendar component is a grouping of calendar access rights component properties. Mansour/Dawson/Royer/Taler/Hill Expires: April 2000 70 Internet Draft CAP October 22, 1999 The "CARID" property specifies the local identifier for the "VCAR" calendar component. The "GRANT" property specifies calendar access rights granted to an UPN. The "DENY" property specifies calendar access rights denied from an UPN. Example: In the following example, the UPN "foo@host.com" has read access to the "DTSTART" and "DTEND" calendar properties. No other access is specified: BEGIN:VCAR CARID:"View Start and End Times" GRANT:UPN="foo@host.com";ACTION="READ";OBJECT=DTSTART,DTEND END:VEVENT In this example, all UPNs are given read access to "DTSTART" and "DTEND". "All CUs" is specified by the UPN value "ALL". Note that this enumerated UPN value is not in quotes.: BEGIN:VCAR CARID:"View Start and End Times 2" GRANT:UPN=ALL;ACTION=READ;OBJECT=DTSTART,DTEND END:VCAR In this example, rights are specified for all UPNs to read components classified as PUBLIC: BEGIN:VCAR CARID:"View PUBLIC Start and End Times" GRANT:UPN=ALL;ACTION=READ;OBJECT=DTSTART;DTEND DENY:UPN=ALL;ACTION=READ;OBJECT=CLASS;VALUE=PUBLIC, CONFIDENTIAL END:VCAR In this example, rights are specified for all UPNs to read or modify existing components classified as PUBLIC: BEGIN:VCAR CARID:"Read and Modify PUBLIC Calendar Entries" GRANT:UPN=ALL;ACTION=READ,MODIFY;OBJECT=ALL DENY:UPN=ALL;ACTION=READ,MODIFY;OBJECT=CLASS;VALUE=PRIVATE, CONFIDENTIAL END:VCAR In this example, rights are given to a standard calendar access right policy of "viewing" (i.e., READ) busy time information: BEGIN:VCAR Mansour/Dawson/Royer/Taler/Hill Expires: April 2000 71 Internet Draft CAP October 22, 1999 CARID:"View Busy Time Information" GRANT:UPN=ALL;POLICY=READBUSYTIMEINFO END:VCAR In this example, full calendar access rights are given to the OWNER and a hypothetical administrator is given access rights to specify calendar access rights. If no other rights are specified, only these two UPNs can specify calendar access rights: BEGIN:VCAR CARID:"Only OWNER or ADMIN Settable CARs" GRANT:UPN=OWNER;ACTION=ALL;OBJECT=ALL GRANT:UPN="cal-admin@host.com";ACTION=ALL; OBJECT=VCAR,CARID,GRANT,DENY END:VCAR In this example, rights to create, read, modify or delete calendar access rights are denied to all UPNs. This example would disable providing different access rights to the calendar store or calendar. This calendar access rights should not be specified, as they the ability to change calendar access; even for the owner or administrator: BEGIN:VCAR CARID:"No CAR At All" DENY:UPN=ALL;OBJECT=VCAR,CARID,GRANT,DENY 14.5 GRANT Component Property Property Name: GRANT Purpose: This property specifies those access rights granted to a UPN. Value Type: RIGHTS Property Parameters: Only non-standard property parameters can be specified on this property. Conformance: This property can only be specified in "VCAR" calendar component. Description: This property is used to grant calendar access rights to a UPN. Format Definition: The property is defined by the following notation: Mansour/Dawson/Royer/Taler/Hill Expires: April 2000 72 Internet Draft CAP October 22, 1999 grant = "GRANT" rightsparam ":" rights CRLF rightparam = *(";" xparam) Example: In the following example, a hypothetical "guest@host.com" UPN is granted rights to view busy time information. These rights are specified by referencing a standard calendar access rights policy, by name: GRANT:UPN="guest@host.com";POLICY="READBUSYTIMEINFO" 14.6 DENY Component Property Property Name: DENY Purpose: This property specifies those access rights denied from a UPN. Value Type: RIGHTS Property Parameters: Only non-standard property parameters can be specified on this property. Conformance: This property can only be specified in "VCAR" calendar component. Description: This property is used to deny calendar access rights to a UPN. Format Definition: The property is defined by the following notation: DENY = "DENY" rightsparam ":" rights CRLF rightsparam = *(";" xparam) Example: In the following example, any UPN who is not the owner is denied rights to create, modify or delete entries: DENY:UPN=NONOWNER;ACTION=CREATE,MODIFY,DELETE;OBJECT=ALL 14.7 VCAR Identifier Component Property Property Name: CARID Purpose: This property specifies the identifier for a "VCAR" calendar component. Value Type: TEXT Mansour/Dawson/Royer/Taler/Hill Expires: April 2000 73 Internet Draft CAP October 22, 1999 Property Parameters: Non-standard property parameters can be specified on this property. Conformance: This property can be specified in "VCAR" calendar component. Description: This property permits previously defined sets of calendar access rights to be specified with a reference. This capability facilitates repetitively specifying calendar access rights. Format Definition: The property is defined by the following notation: CARID = "CARID" textparam ":" text CRLF Example: The following is an example of this property: CARID:"Restrict Guests From Creating ALARMs On Events" 14.8 REQUEST-STATUS property This description is a revision of the REQUEST-STATUS property for VCALENDAR version 2.1. rstatus = "REQUEST-STATUS" rstatparam ":" statcode [";" statdesc [";" extdata]] rstatparam = *( ; the following is optional, ; but MUST NOT occur more than once (";" languageparm) / ; the following is optional, ; and MAY occur more than once (";" xparam) ) statcode = 1*DIGIT *("." 1*DIGIT) ;Hierarchical, numeric return status code statdesc = text ;An optional textual status description, content is ;decided by the implementor. May be empty. Mansour/Dawson/Royer/Taler/Hill Expires: April 2000 74 Internet Draft CAP October 22, 1999 extdata = text ;Textual exception data. For example, the offending property ;name and value or complete property line. Example: The following are some possible examples of this property. The COMMA and SEMICOLON separator characters in the property value are BACKSLASH character escaped because they appear in a text value. REQUEST-STATUS:2.0;Success REQUEST-STATUS:2.0;Success despite braindead LDAP implementation REQUEST-STATUS:3.1;Invalid property value;DTSTART:96-Apr-01 REQUEST-STATUS:2.8; Success repeating event ignored. Scheduled as a single event.;RRULE:FREQ=WEEKLY;INTERVAL=2 REQUEST-STATUS:4.1;Event conflict. Date/time is busy. REQUEST-STATUS:3.7;Invalid calendar user;ATTENDEE: MAILTO:jsmith@host.com REQUEST-STATUS:3.7;;ATTENDEE:MAILTO:jsmith@host.com REQUEST-STATUS:10.4;Help! That really shouldnt have happened. 15. CAP Entities Registration This section provides the process for registration of new or modified CAP entities. 15.1 Registration of New and Modified CAP Entities New CAP entities are registered by the publication of an IETF Request for Comment (RFC). Changes to a CAP entity are registered by the publication of a revision of the RFC defining the method. 15.2 Registration of New Entities This section defines procedures by which new entities (i.e., components, properties, parameters, enumerated values or restriction tables) for a CAP entity can be registered with the IANA. Non-standard, experimental entities can be used by bilateral agreement, provided the associated properties names follow the "X-" convention. Such non-standard entities are non-IANA entities and need not be registered using this process. Mansour/Dawson/Royer/Taler/Hill Expires: April 2000 75 Internet Draft CAP October 22, 1999 The procedures defined here are designed to allow public comment and review of new CAP entities, while posing only a small impediment to the definition of new properties. Registration of a new CAP entity is accomplished by the following steps. 15.2.1 Define the Entity A CAP entity is defined by completing the following template. To: ietf-calendar@imc.org Subject: Registration of CAP entity XXX Entity name: Entity purpose: Description: CAP terminology changes: CAP data model changes: CAP system model changes: Conformance considerations: Format definition: Examples: The meaning of each field in the template is as follows. Entity name: The name of the entity. Entity purpose: The purpose of the entity (e.g., Extends the CAP command set to poll for notifications, etc.). Give a short but clear description. Description: Any special notes about the entity, how it is to be used, etc. CAP terminology changes: Any change or additions to the existing CAP terminology needs to be specified. CAP data model changes: Any of the valid property parameters for the property needs to be specified. CAP system model changes: Conformance: A clear summary of how and where this CAP entity extension MUST, MAY, SHOULD or can be used. Any changes or impact to the existing conformance definition for CAP should be explained. The impact to implmentations conforming to the existing CAP specification should be clearly described. Mansour/Dawson/Royer/Taler/Hill Expires: April 2000 76 Internet Draft CAP October 22, 1999 Format definition: The ABNF for each element of the CAP entity needs to be specified. Examples: One or more examples of instances of the CAP entity and each of its usage scenarios needs to be specified. 15.2.2 Post the entity definition The entity description MUST be posted to the new entity discussion list, ietf-calendar@imc.org. 15.2.3 Allow a comment period Discussion on the new entity MUST be allowed to take place on the list for a minimum of two weeks. Consensus MUST be reached on the property before proceeding to the next step. 15.2.4 Submit the entity for approval Once the two-week comment period has elapsed, and the proposer is convinced consensus has been reached on the entity, the registration application should be submitted to the Method Reviewer for approval. The Method Reviewer is appointed by the Application Area Directors and can either accept or reject the entity registration. An accepted registration should be passed on by the Method Reviewer to the IANA for inclusion in the official IANA method registry. The registration can be rejected for any of the following reasons. 1) Insufficient comment period; 2) Consensus not reached; 3) Technical deficiencies raised on the list or elsewhere have not been addressed. The Method Reviewer's decision to reject an entity can be appealed by the proposer to the IESG, or the objections raised can be addressed by the proposer and the entity resubmitted. [Ed note: John Stracke to review any updates] 15.3 Property Change Control Existing CAP entities can be changed using the same process by which they were registered. 1. Define the change 2. Post the change 3. Allow a comment period 4. Submit the entity for approval Note that the original author or any other interested party can propose a change to an existing CAP entity, but that such changes should only be proposed when there are serious omissions or errors in Mansour/Dawson/Royer/Taler/Hill Expires: April 2000 77 Internet Draft CAP October 22, 1999 the published memo. The Method Reviewer can object to a change if it is not backward compatible, but is not required to do so. CAP entity definitions can never be deleted from the IANA registry, but entities which are no longer believed to be useful can be declared OBSOLETE by adding this text to their "Entity purpose" field. 16. IANA Considerations This memo defines IANA registered extensions to the attributes defined by iCalendar, as defined in [RFC2445], and iTIP, as defined in [RFC2426]. IANA registration proposals for iCalendar and iTIP are to be emailed to the registration agent for the "text/calendar" MIME content-type, <MAILTO: ietf-calendar@imc.org> using the format defined in section 7 of [RFC2445]. 17. Acknowledgments The following have individuals were major contributors in the drafting and discussion of this memo: Mario Bonin, Andre Courtemanche, Dave Crocker, Pat Egen, Gilles Fortin, Alex Hoppman, Bruce Kahn, Lisa Lippert, David Madeo, Bob Mahoney, Pete O'Leary, Richard Shusterman, Tony Small, John Stracke. 18. Bibliography [RFC1521] N. Borenstein and N. Freed, "MIME (Multipurpose Internet Mail Extensions) Part One: Mechanisms for Internet Draft UTF-825 July 1996 Specifying and Describing the Format of Internet Message Bodies", RFC 1521, Bellcore, Innosoft, September 1993. [TLS] Dierks, Allen, "The TLS Protocol", RFC 2246, January 1999 [RFC2608] Guttman, Perkins, Veizades, Day, "Service Location protocol, Version 2", RFC2608, June 1999. [RFC2609] Guttman, Perkins, Kempf, "Service Templates and Service: Schemes", RFC2609, June 1999. [RFC2396] Berners-Lee, Fielding, Masinter, "Uniform Resource Identifiers (URI): Generic Syntax", RFC 2396, August 1998. [RFC2445] Dawson, Stenerson, "Internet Calendaring and Scheduling Mansour/Dawson/Royer/Taler/Hill Expires: April 2000 78 Internet Draft CAP October 22, 1999 Core Object Specification (iCalendar)", RFC 2445, November 1998 [RFC2446] Silverberg, Mansour, Dawson, Hopson, "iCalendar Transport- Independent Interoperability Protocol (iTIP)", RFC 2446, November 1998 [RFC2447] Dawson, Mansour, Silverberg, "iCalendar Message-Based Interoperability Protocol (iMIP)", RFC 2445, November 1998 [SQL] "Database Language SQL", ANSI/ISO/IEC 9075: 1992, aka ANSI X3.135-1992, aka FiPS PUB 127-2 [SQLCOM] ANSI/ISO/IEC 9075:1992/TC-1-1995, Technical corrigendum 1 to ISO/IEC 9075: 1992, also adopted as Amendment 1 to ANSI X3.135.1992 [UNICODE] The Unicode Consortium, "The Unicode Standard --Worldwide Character Encoding -- Version 1.0", Addison-Wesley, Volume 1, 1991, Volume 2, 1992. UTF-8 is described in Unicode Technical Report #4. [US-ASCII] Coded Character Set--7-bit American Standard Code for Information Interchange, ANSI X3.4-1986. 19. Author's Address The following address information is provided in a vCard v3.0, the RFC 2426 electronic business card format. BEGIN:VCARD VERSION:3.0 N:Dawson;Frank FN:Frank Dawson ORG:Lotus Development Corporation ADR;TYPE=WORK,POSTAL,PARCEL:;;6544 Battleford Drive;Raleigh;NC; 27613-3502;US TEL;TYPE=PREF,WORK,MSG:+1-617-693-8728 TEL;TYPE=WORK,MSG:+1-919-676-9515 TEL;TYPE=WORK,FAX:+1-919-676-9515 EMAIL;TYPE=INTERNET,PREF:Frank_Dawson@Lotus.com EMAIL;TYPE=INTERNET:fdawson@earthlink.net URL;TYPE=X-HOME:http://home.earthlink.net/~fdawson END:VCARD BEGIN:VCARD VERSION:3.0 N:Mansour;Steve FN:Steve Mansour ORG:Netscape ADR;TYPE=WORK,POSTAL,PARCEL:;;501 E Middlfield Road;Mountain View;CA;94043;US Mansour/Dawson/Royer/Taler/Hill Expires: April 2000 79 Internet Draft CAP October 22, 1999 TEL;WORK;MSG:+1-650-937-2378 TEL;WORK;FAX:+1-650-937-2103 EMAIL;INTERNET:sman@netscape.com END:VCARD BEGIN:VCARD VERSION: 3.0 FN:Doug Royer N:Royer,Doug ORG:Software.com ADR;TYPE=WORK,POSTAL,PARCEL:Suite 106;;530 E. Montecito St; Santa Barbara;CA;93103 TEL;TYPE=WORK,VOICE:805-957-1790 x541 TEL;TYPE=FAX:805-957-1544 EMAIL;TYPE=INTERNET:Doug.Royer@Software.com URL;TYPE=X-HOME:http://Royer.com/People/Doug END:VCARD BEGIN:VCARD VERSION:3.0 FN:Alexander Taler N:Taler;Alexander ORG:CS&T ADR;TYPE=WORK,POSTAL,PARCEL:;;3333 Graham Boulevard;Montreal;QC; H3R 3L5;Canada TEL;TYPE=WORK,VOICE:514-733-8500 TEL;TYPE=FAX:514-733-8878 EMAIL;TYPE=INTERNET:alext@cst.ca END:VCARD 20. Full Copyright Statement "Copyright (C) The Internet Society (1999). All Rights Reserved. This document and translations of it may be copied and furnished to others, and derivative works that comment on or otherwise explain it or assist in its implmentation may be prepared, copied, published and distributed, in whole or in part, without restriction of any kind, provided that the above copyright notice and this paragraph are included on all such copies and derivative works. However, this document itself may not be modified in any way, such as by removing the copyright notice or references to the Internet Society or other Internet organizations, except as needed for the purpose of developing Internet standards in which case the procedures for copyrights defined in the Internet Standards process MUST be followed, or as required to translate it into languages other than English. Mansour/Dawson/Royer/Taler/Hill Expires: April 2000 80 Internet Draft CAP October 22, 1999 The limited permissions granted above are perpetual and will not be revoked by the Internet Society or its successors or assigns. This document and the information contained herein is provided on an "AS IS" basis and THE INTERNET SOCIETY AND THE INTERNET ENGINEERING TASK FORCE DISCLAIMS ALL WARRANTIES, EXPRESS OR IMPLIED, INCLUDING BUT NOT LIMITED TO ANY WARRANTY THAT THE USE OF THE INFORMATION HEREIN WILL NOT INFRINGE ANY RIGHTS OR ANY IMPLIED WARRANTIES OF MERCHANTABILITY OR FITNESS FOR A PARTICULAR PURPOSE. Mansour/Dawson/Royer/Taler/Hill Expires: April 2000 81
Datatracker
Report a datatracker bug
draft-ietf-calsch-cap-01
Internet-Draft
| Document | Document type |
This is an older version of an Internet-Draft whose latest revision state is "Expired".
Expired & archived
|
|
|---|---|---|---|
| Select version | |||
| Compare versions | |||
| Author | |||
| RFC stream |
|
||
| Other formats | |||
| Additional resources | Mailing list discussion |