Skip to main content

Complaint to IAB regarding a declaration of consensus to adopt a non-hybrid draft (Daniel J. Bernstein) - 2026-04-24
Response - 2026-06-30

The IAB has received an appeal from D. J. Bernstein, dated 24 April 2026, that challenges the IESG's denial of his appeal regarding the TLS WG chair’s declaration of rough consensus to adopt draft-connolly-tls-mlkem-key-agreement as a Working Group item. The IAB has reviewed the appeal and the underlying record.

The question before the IAB is narrow: whether the TLS WG chairs acted consistently with the IETF process when they determined that there was rough consensus to adopt draft-connolly-tls-mlkem-key-agreement as a working group item.

The IAB makes the following observations:

First, the IAB notes that the responsible AD's initial characterization of the adoption call did not accurately describe the record, and that a more precise account was provided subsequently. The IAB encourages chairs and ADs to take care in how participant responses are summarized.

Second, WG adoption is governed by RFC 2418 and informed by Section 2.2 of RFC 7221. Adoption places a document under WG control for further development; it is not a determination that the document is correct, that it is ready for publication, or that all participants agree with its content. The chairs' subsequent clarification that adoption rested on there being sufficient interest in the WG to work on the document is consistent with this understanding of adoption.

Third, RFC 2418 assigns to the chair(s) the responsibility of determining whether rough consensus exists. The record shows substantive participation on both sides of the adoption question and substantive discussion of the objections raised. While reasonable participants may disagree about whether the record demonstrates rough consensus to adopt, the IAB does not find that the chairs' determination fell outside the discretion afforded to them by RFC 2418, nor does it find that the adoption was procedurally invalid. The IAB further finds that the responsible AD and the IESG did not act outside their process role in declining to overturn that determination.

Fourth, the IAB does not take a position on the substantive technical objections raised by the appellant, including those concerning hybrid versus non-hybrid post-quantum key agreement — those are properly addressed through the WG's ongoing process, including Working Group Last Call. The WG has held multiple last calls on the document, and the chairs have stated that there is no current consensus to publish it as written. The IAB considers these the appropriate venues for resolution of the substantive disagreements about the document's content.

The appeal is denied.

The appeal also revisits procedural matters concerning transparency, the handling of appeals, and related complaints that have been addressed in the IAB's responses to the appellant's prior appeals dated 2025-10-06 and 2025-10-24. The IAB has nothing further to add on those matters.

Roman Danyliw recused himself from consideration of this appeal.