Skip to main content

Agenda IETF127: genarea: Sat 00:00
agenda-127-genarea-sessb-00

Meeting Agenda General Area Open Meeting (genarea) AG
Date and time 2026-11-21 00:00
Title Agenda IETF127: genarea: Sat 00:00
State Active
Other versions plain text
On agenda genarea at IETF-127
Remote instructions:
Last updated 2026-11-19

agenda-127-genarea-sessb-00
# IETF 127 GENAREA Meeting #2

* Friday, 20-November 2026, Session IV, 1600-1730
* Location: Continental 5
* Remote Client: https://meetings.conf.meetecho.com/ietf127/?session=36144
* Onsite Client: https://meetings.conf.meetecho.com/onsite127/?session=36144
* Chat: https://zulip.ietf.org/#narrow/stream/genarea

## NOTE: Why a Second Session?
The GENAREA Open Meeting already convened on Wednesday (18-November 2026).  See
https://datatracker.ietf.org/doc/agenda-127-genarea/.  Due to an emergency in
the facility, this meeting was forced to abruptly end prematurely.  This second
session is to continue the originally planned agenda.

## Agenda

### Introduction (10 min)
* Session Plan and Scene Setting (Roman Danyliw, Mahesh Jethanandani)(see also,
guiding questions)

### Topics already covered in GENAREA Open Session #1 that will be skipped
during this Session #2 (included here for continuity with Session #1)

See agenda for the GENAREA Open Session #1,
https://datatracker.ietf.org/doc/agenda-127-genarea/.

* Measurements
* AI Workflows for Standards Work
* Meeting Minutes (Eric Rescorla)

### Possible Interventions/Considerations (60 min)

* Disclosure Requirements (Brian Carpenter)
* Norms for LLMs in mailing lists discussion(draft-fengfar-led-01) (Stephen
Farrell) * Principle of "We Are All Individuals"
(draft-gondwana-we-are-all-individuals-03) (Bron Gondwana) * Re-thinking when
to write a draft (Mark Nottingham)

### Open Mic / Discussion (20 min)

## Guiding Questions
The following are guiding questions  for the presentation materials.

* AI usage and conduct
  * When does AI-assisted or agent-generated activity in mailing lists, chat,
  GitHub, or meetings become disruptive? * Are existing conduct rules adequate
  for AI-assisted/agent-generated activity? If not, is the gap in the rules
  themselves, or in guidance on how to apply them? * How should participants
  raise concerns without it being disruptive (e.g., accusations, not engaging)?

* AI usage and accountability
  * Which activities/mechanisms of contribution are open to everyone, and which
  require an accountable human participant? * What responsibilities exist for
  “agent owners”? * What degree of AI usage requires disclosure?  How is usage
  disclosed?

* AI usage and workload
  * Do dispatch, intake, adoption or review processes need to be restructured
  or reassessed to meet the increase in contributions? * What support do WG
  participants, WG chairs, and AD need due to increased volume of contributions?

* AI usage and consensus
  * In what ways, if any, does the assessment of rough consensus need to change?

* AI usage and running code
  * How should "independent implementations” be defined with AI-generated code?
  * Is there additional consideration needed for AI-generated code to be the
  basis of interoperability claims?