Purge Originator Identification TLV for IS-IS
draft-ietf-isis-purge-tlv-05

Note: This ballot was opened for revision 05 and is now closed.

(Ron Bonica) Yes

(Stewart Bryant) Yes

(Adrian Farrel) Yes

Jari Arkko No Objection

Comment (2011-02-17)
Some comments from Ari Keränen who helped me in some of my reviews today:

Abstract

This document updates 3 RFCs, should say that in the abstract. Also LSP acronym should be expanded.

(Gonzalo Camarillo) No Objection

(Ralph Droms) No Objection

Comment (2011-02-16)
Balloting no objection assuming there is an easy answer to my question
(posted to draft-ietf-isis-reg-purge-00) about the IANA ISIS-TLV
registry and notifying ISO JTC1.

(Lars Eggert) No Objection

(Russ Housley) No Objection

(Alexey Melnikov) No Objection

(Tim Polk) No Objection

Comment (2011-02-16)
In the Intro, this document states:

   Field experience has observed several circumstances where an IS can
   improperly generate a purge.  These are all due to implementation
   deficiencies or implementations that predate [ISO TC1] and generate a
   purge when they receive a corrupted LSP.

In the security considerations, it is noted that:

   Therefore, all implementations in a domain implementing
   authentication MUST be upgraded to receive the POI TLV before any IS
   is allowed to generate a purge with the POI TLV.

Since you need to touch every ISIS implementation in the domain anyway, is it worth stating that
implementations SHOULD be updated for consistency with [ISO TC1] (i.e., and not generate a purge
when they receive a corrupted LSP) at the same time?

(Dan Romascanu) No Objection

Comment (2011-02-14)
>   This document requests that IANA assign code point 13 for the 'Purge
   Originator Identification' TLV from the IS-IS 'TLV Codepoints
   Registry'.  The additional values for this TLV should be: IIH:n,
   LSP:y, SNP:n, Purge:y.



I assume that this is OK with this document but usually an Internet-Draft cannot / should not make a request for a specific value, but just require a code point value and recommend that this value be 13. 

(Peter Saint-Andre) No Objection

(Robert Sparks) No Objection

(spt) No Objection

Comment (2011-02-16)
Please add a pointer for where I can find the definition of system ID.