ICN Ping Protocol Specification
draft-irtf-icnrg-icnping-12

Yes

Brian Trammell
Colin Perkins
Marie-Jose Montpetit

No Objection

Ari Keränen
Jane Coffin
Mat Ford
Melinda Shore

Recuse

David Oran

Note: This ballot was opened for revision 08 and is now closed.

Ballot question: "Is this draft ready for publication in the IRTF stream?"

Brian Trammell
Yes
Comment (2023-06-15 for -08) Sent 
This document presents a clear design and implementation of IP-analog "ping" functionality for NDN and CCnx. It is ready for publication on the IRTF stream.
Colin Perkins
Yes
Marie-Jose Montpetit
Yes
Ari Keränen
No Objection
Comment (2023-06-28 for -08) Not sent 
Nit: section 4.1 says "The nonce can be encoded as a base64 string."

Given there are many ways to do base64 encoding, this is a bit vague. But I suppose the encoding details are not important here but any encoding is really OK. Perhaps shortly clarifying why encoding is needed (to comply with name encoding rules?) would be useful or if there's value for consistent encoding, making that explicit with e.g., "base64-encoded string with the URL-safe alphabet as defined in Section 5 of [RFC4648], with padding omitted".
Jane Coffin
No Objection
Mat Ford
No Objection
Melinda Shore
No Objection
David Oran
Recuse
Comment (2023-05-30 for -08) Not sent 
Co-author