Comcast's ISP Experiences in a Proactive Network Provider Participation for P2P (P4P) Technical Trial
draft-livingood-woundy-p4p-experiences-10

Yes

(Cullen Jennings)
(Jari Arkko)
(Lisa Dusseault)

No Objection

(Adrian Farrel)
(Alexey Melnikov)
(Dan Romascanu)
(Lars Eggert)
(Ralph Droms)
(Robert Sparks)
(Tim Polk)

Note: This ballot was opened for revision 10 and is now closed.

Cullen Jennings Former IESG member
Yes
Yes () Unknown 

                            

                        
                    

                
            
                
                    

                        

                            Jari Arkko Former IESG member
                        

                        

                            
                            Yes
                            
                        

                    

                    

                        

                            

                                Yes 
                                
                                    (2009-07-02)
                                
                                
                                    
                                    
                                         Unknown
                                    
                                
                            

                        

                        
                            

                                
This is great document and excellent input for the WG efforts.

I do have one question though, and that relates to the complex 
selection process and "economics" of p2p peer selection. Basically,
there is a large number of variables that one has to take into account
when selecting a peer or evaluating the effectiveness of a peer
selection algorithm. In particular, download speed or localization is
not the only metric to follow. For instance, the ability to spread
the content in the Internet, grow the swarm, and retain the most rare 
segments of data are also important. I would be curious if the experiment
provided any information with regards to possible negative effects of
focusing on localization as the key startup connection criteria? Or
lack thereof.

(FWIW, I do not agree with the requirement raised in IESG discussion about
more extensive security considerations section.)

                            

                        
                    

                
            
                
                    

                        

                            Lisa Dusseault Former IESG member
                        

                        

                            
                            Yes
                            
                        

                    

                    

                        

                            

                                Yes 
                                
                                    ()
                                
                                
                                    
                                    
                                         Unknown
                                    
                                
                            

                        

                        
                            

                                

                            

                        
                    

                
            
        
            
                
                    

                        

                            Adrian Farrel Former IESG member
                        

                        

                            
                            No Objection
                            
                        

                    

                    

                        

                            

                                No Objection 
                                
                                    ()
                                
                                
                                    
                                    
                                         Unknown
                                    
                                
                            

                        

                        
                            

                                

                            

                        
                    

                
            
                
                    

                        

                            Alexey Melnikov Former IESG member
                        

                        

                            
                            No Objection
                            
                        

                    

                    

                        

                            

                                No Objection 
                                
                                    ()
                                
                                
                                    
                                    
                                         Unknown
                                    
                                
                            

                        

                        
                            

                                

                            

                        
                    

                
            
                
                    

                        

                            Dan Romascanu Former IESG member
                        

                        

                            
                            No Objection
                            
                        

                    

                    

                        

                            

                                No Objection 
                                
                                    (2009-07-02)
                                
                                
                                    
                                    
                                         Unknown
                                    
                                
                            

                        

                        
                            

                                
I support Tim's DISCUSS. I think that RFC 2223 requires all RFCs to have a Security Considerations sections. If security content is null for this document it should explain why.

                            

                        
                    

                
            
                
                    

                        

                            Lars Eggert Former IESG member
                        

                        

                            
                            No Objection
                            
                        

                    

                    

                        

                            

                                No Objection 
                                
                                    ()
                                
                                
                                    
                                    
                                         Unknown
                                    
                                
                            

                        

                        
                            

                                

                            

                        
                    

                
            
                
                    

                        

                            Ralph Droms Former IESG member
                        

                        

                            
                            No Objection
                            
                        

                    

                    

                        

                            

                                No Objection 
                                
                                    ()
                                
                                
                                    
                                    
                                         Unknown
                                    
                                
                            

                        

                        
                            

                                

                            

                        
                    

                
            
                
                    

                        

                            Robert Sparks Former IESG member
                        

                        

                            
                            No Objection
                            
                        

                    

                    

                        

                            

                                No Objection 
                                
                                    ()
                                
                                
                                    
                                    
                                         Unknown
                                    
                                
                            

                        

                        
                            

                                

                            

                        
                    

                
            
                
                    

                        

                            Tim Polk Former IESG member
                        

                        

                            (was No Record, Discuss)
                            No Objection
                            
                        

                    

                    

                        

                            

                                No Objection 
                                
                                    ()
                                
                                
                                    
                                    
                                         Unknown