String Profile for Internet Small Computer Systems Interface (iSCSI) Names
draft-ietf-ips-iscsi-string-prep-06

[Note]: 'An RFC Editor Note change is needed - see Discuss by Steve Bellovin - and then this is approved.  It was noted that Paul Hoffman reviewed for Steve Bellovin.' added by Amy Vezza

[Note]: 'An RFC Editor Note change is needed - see Discuss by Steve Bellovin - and then this is approved.  It was noted that Paul Hoffman reviewed for Steve Bellovin.' added by Allison Mankin

[Note]: 'An RFC Editor Note change is needed - see Discuss by Steve Bellovin - and then this is approved.  It was noted that Paul Hoffman reviewed for Steve Bellovin.' added by Allison Mankin

An RFC Editor Note change is needed - see Discuss by Steve Bellovin - and then this is approved.  It was noted that Paul Hoffman reviewed for Steve Bellovin.

[Ballot comment]
If they authors have not talked to Paul and Adam recently, they may want to check with them about
draft-hoffman-rfc3454bis-01.txt.  Though there are no substantive changes noted in the change
section which would affect this doc, I know there has been some discussion of the bidi issues
that might eventually be incorporation in rfc3454bis.  Those sound to me like clarifications,
so nothing should block on that, but a check before AUTH 48 would be a good idea.

[Ballot discuss]
The draft looks fine with one big exception. Near the top of page 3, it says:

    In addition, any upper-case characters input via a user interface
    should be mapped to their lower-case equivalents.

That has  to be changed to a "...MUST be mapped". Otherwise, the
matching later in the document won't work.

(fixable with an RFC editor's note.)