Liaison statement
OMA LS_0082 Liaison on Mobile E-Mail

Submission date 2006-02-12
From OMA (Dean Willis)
To IETF LEMONADE WG (Gparsons@nortel.com, eburger@brooktrout.com)
Cc lemonade@ietf.org, Ted Hardie, Scott Hollenbeck
Response contact Jerry.weingarten@comverse.com
Technical contact Jerry.weingarten@comverse.com
Purpose For information
Attachments LS_0082 on Mobile E-Mail
Body
1 Overview 

This liaison is in response to specific questions raised in a liaison from
IETF LEMONADE in  
OMA-MEM-2006-0023-ILS-fromIETF-on-LEMONADE-Profile. 

2 Proposal 

OMA MWG-MEM thanks IETF LEMONADE for their consideration of our previous
liaison.  We understand, and will take into consideration, your comments. 

However, we have the following additional comments to your questions: 

1. (on your question 2)  MWG-MEM has not yet considered this and thanks IETF
LEMONADE for bringing 
this to our attention.  As a result, we will study the possibility of a
shorter list that is mandatory for the MEM enabler (and likely solicit the
advice of the OMA STI group).  We will provide IETF LEMONADE an update on this
after our next meeting.  

2. (on your question 4)  According to the MWG-MEM RD, only notification and
send/receive roundtrip delay is of concern at this point.  We will inform IETF
LEMONADE if these requirements change. 

3. (on your question 6)  According to the MWG-MEM RD, message recall is still
a requirement.  Specifically, that the client be able to request a recall and
that success/failure be indicated back.  MWG-MEM will consider IETF
LEMONADE’s input in its realization of this requirement and will let IETF
know if any further work is requested. Note that work continues on the MEM
architecture document (AD).  OMA MWG-MEM intends to continue to provide
detailed updates of the Mobile e-mail enabler related activities as our work
progresses. OMA MWG-MEM will hold its next meeting on April 3-7 in Vancouver,
Canada. 

3 Requested Action(s) 
We request the IETF LEMONADE Working Group to consider and accept these
comments.   
4 Conclusion OMA MWG-MEM SWG wishes to thank the IETF LEMONADE WG for its
response to OMA MWG-MEM’s previous liaison and for the analysis and feedback
they provided regarding the draft OMA Mobile Email RD and AD.
 
OMA MWG-MEM looks forward to continued collaboration on these matters with the
IETF LEMONADE WG.  Finally, OMA MWG-MEM wishes to thank the IETF LEMONADE WG
for its kind consideration of this liaison.